Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
3-06-634/3 ECLI:EE:TLHK:2006:3.06.634.20482 AI generated

3-06-634/3 · Tallinna Halduskohus Pärnu kohtumaja

Case Number 3-06-634/3
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated



Legislator headnote

AI generated

3-06-634/3 · Tallinna Halduskohus Pärnu kohtumaja: 

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

















          











 









 !"





   #



 

  

$%&!$''(



 

)*'(*()+





 #,-



 . !!"$&')&$''( #

/( 0 !#1#2

  . !!"

,3 !#,"  !#"

/1!"3# !/###!#1#&







  

$%&!$''(

  

 

"!## #

  ! "

4#5$(6/(75)6+"68-



4  #,! &





 

 

  ##31,# /# #,#

6 #  !"

)'/#3"3 # # # 3 #6#!# $%&

!$''(&

/# #,## !#  #, 

 !" # " '/#3"

3 # # # 3 #6#!# &

!##  !6 #, # 7# #  "

1/  99/#31//  "3!#/#3&



# $



')&'&%%$#  3#163 # 311 3 6 !#7  ##

! 3#!:;  !#"!#  6 ! 7



$

# #"!3#!/###! & 3## #3! 7!#  7

# # 7! # "!# :)*%<=$''8 $;&

$8&'8&%%8. !!" #68( 3  7# 3!

##311!#"  #"#!6    #!  !#>

 #16  ,"# :)*%<=$''8 (';&

'<&'%&%%+ /"/!  ##  :)*

%<=$''8 8);&

$&')&$''( #631# 3  #3  3#& #6#  1# 7

#  8&$&$''8 # 3  /1" 3#

#!:; #  #-/ # #67"00!4: $;&

 #/("# !    !#"/1!"3# 7

 # #   #6 3   #  #!: $;&



33##! 163 # 311 3 

   !'<$%)&!! #"#  ")*%<=$''8

!#7!31# ##3"! #"#"#:! $'7$*?;&



"  ! ! $





#,"#7# 4   163 # 311 !"#  #

!7 1 56/1!"3# !&#,"

#6  ##  '$&')&%+8!#6<8 99 #,!"!

#! &3##!#### #!6 7

 #,#,"6@.63 # 311 3!!#"

!/###!###A5("5<&#,"#6  ##  !##

'$&8(6#,##  3# ## 311 3# !!

$?$8&#,"3# ##/# 6# #!!#03 !#

!/# 3# 3  &#,"3# #3#  #0##!

8'' 7! #)'' 6#/# 3# &



  "#  #, #  &   "#6  ## 31# #3 3 

3 8&$&$''8  # 3  "##& #6 3  7# #

#! !#3 ##  #!4&  " 3 !#

  #6#3  "6 3 7# !3311!#

# #4B#&   "#6  ## !3  # 8&'(&$''8

 $&1!"3# 3 , 5 #  #7# ##

311 !# "#  # &   "#6  ##  !!

 ##!#%+8& 66  1# ## !" 6!

3311  #! &

  "6/1"#! #,"# 7# 3!!#!!#

#,#! !##3##31 @#  0  #A7# #  

1# ## ##"#   1#### 7#  ## ! B 

#3163 # 311  5( ##&











  %&#"$$



)



#,"#  ##,#7!#  #,  0 ! &     

15(6$/&

#3 3 3 31# $&')&$''(&#,#   # 5%6

7!##  #/99!#  #6163 # 311 3

6 !#31!/###!#6 #   #/##73 #/#3 7

! # #!163  # &

#,#  $?&')&$''(&

##6#,#  5%6 #    ""&

3# ###  #,, 3&



#  ,6!#C! ###: ## '+&'$&$''(;56

# !#C!,"# 163 # 311 !##6/03 

# ,"# #67# #7#3#6 # #37/1!"3# 7

 !# ####7 " #73# ! #316&

 # /636+ # ,7# /1!"3# ##3## ##

/1!"  ,#  !7#!#7 99 "!&



# !"#3##*#! !7# #7! #"

!# #& 3#3  #"##3 ## #"! 6 ! 6

3# #"!303 ! :)*%<=$''8 $;&

  163 # 311 !# . 

!"$8&'8&$''8 #6?!#6 3  7# 163 # 

311 ##! !/6(87+##!46

  !#C!16  ,"# !/#6 >!1 ##! "

B=$!1 ##! : (';&

"#  !# ## 4#*#!8?!0#!6

!0#/#3! #"## (87+: 8%7('7?%7%';&

 ##   1# ##  3 @#  0  #A!0#

163 # 311 3 :)<7(;# ##&

D #6 1# #63# ## 7# !0@#  0  #A

!#C!,"# " 1#### 7#     16  ,"# 

 #   #7"#  ##&

! ##3  . !!"$8&'8&%%8  ?7!#6

!  /   # 3163 # 311 !"#&

##3 ##  # #,"1#6#!0@#  0  #A

163 # 311 !63# #*#! #'$7

8(&



. !!"'(&'%&$''8/ # #6+<3 , 

3##   #3 1#7!#63  1#7# #! 

# #!4&!"  " "1#8&'(&$''8 #$"3 

# #! 3 !#/99 /#:)*%<=$''8 %;&

 /99$8&'&$''8 /#  #6 0 . 

!!"'(&'%&$''8/ # +<6 3  " # 

,3 !#,"    # #:)*%<=$''8;&

  #6#, "'(&'%&$''8 +< 0  :! ';&

  #*#! # ## . 

!!"$&')&$''( #/ #7$7)& #6 3  7# 



+

#*#! # #!3163 # 311!#"$8&/

%+8463   16  ,"# 4/E : $;&

##6   163 # 311  # ## . 

!" #6$&')&$''( #/ 6)&



. !"8&'(&$''8 #6$3 ,    

33###!8? 3#& #6"#  !#C!

16  ,"#   !  33##!8? 3&

 #6 3  7#  3311 B  3$8&'+&%+8 6

/ +)#7!## 31# B !36!7

/1!"3# 7 #37!99 :)*%<=$''8  +(*+<7<?*<%;&

6  1# ## . !"8&'(&$''8  $

3  ##6##6 $# 3 &



##3 ##/ 3  "# " #"6  1## 3

!"/ 163 # 311 3# -

 163 # 311 !$8&'8&$''8 #6?2

 163 # 311  # # #6$&')&$''( #

/ #6*)2

 !163 # 311  3:!7/1!"3# 7

#37!99 ;. !"8&'(&$''8 #6$&



. !"$&')&$''( #/1"# ## "3  "

3 3# ##  #3 #3 31 !##  

")*%<=$''8: $7$<;&

")*%<=$''83   #*#! # #!

 6  #/1"#3 6 # #311!#6

# "##&

##3 ##  "##3 3 #/(/1"### 7# 

  ## #! 3 !#6# # !#"

/1!"3# !&



 3  !## ## 5(6&$/*#$31,#,#61 ! 

!6 ! &/#,###,#!73  "  

 ! !67#,## "161 !6 3  " 7 !6 ##

3 ! #,"  ##3##  "###!/1"# 3 3 #7!# 

##3 16 !6#316#&

   !163 # 311  3:!7/1!"

3# 7 #37!99 ;,3 . !"8&'(&$''8

 #6$63  # 37###,"1# . 

!!",3 !#,"  !#"/1!"3# 

!/###!#1#/1"# &## 1 #6 #,# 

311 /1!"3# !!#3# ##&



#,"#,# 3# ## #  ### !/# !!#

  #/# 63#  !/# !!3# &

1@.63 # 311 3## !/# !!#A

:# '(&'$&$''8*$+&')&$''(;/ )33!/###!#!##  "

!/###!   3!3 #  #36&



#,7# !3 #  #363!/###!#31

## ##!# #,16#7 16 #3 /8  #

 #36 ##! ! 31 0 ! &

 ###/ /  )+ ##!3 #  #36

!/# !!# 16  ,"# ## # 30!#/#3

" # #6#!#/#3 3 #&

##6 #,#,""7 #,7# !/# ! 3# 73 

!3 #  #36!/# !!# &

##3 3  ## /#3##/# 6#/ # #6#!#&







 #















F16#

 

==





















 #