Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-06-6441/3 ECLI:EE:PMK:2006:2.06.6441.19603 AI generated

2-06-6441/3 · Pärnu Maakohus Pärnu kohtumaja Rüütli tänaval

Case Number 2-06-6441/3
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus

Legislator summary

AI generated

!"2 )   ' (&$''&/&$' -'( '& "(' )1&/ (&! )1(2 !$%% *  C 4 '*5"6  (%&7 " 9=$&) (%

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-06-6441/3 · Pärnu Maakohus Pärnu kohtumaja Rüütli tänaval: !"2 )   ' (&$''&/&$' -'( '& "(' )1&/ (&! )1(2 !$%% *  C 4 '*5"6  (%&7 " 9=$&) (%

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text















      







 !"#$





"#%&!'((" #%)''$'!'%& &*&  +&!,-'$"('!(

 

  

 ./ &. !'((0.$







 











 



  



 



 !

"  

   





1(2&!3 4'*5"6 (%&78-# %$'(&&2')"(&% %*'$&* - 

*)"! % ( +'2.

-%&'9 !"%&# (*3:8









  

./ &.  ) (&!!"#%&$%2



#$ %&$' (

;#&**'$ !< (2.8< 8< - < (2.&2<0

(2.9.8



(% * )(-  4'*5"6 (%&79 !"%.



 %  4'*5"6 (%&79 !"%&# (*&!$:

 !"%&# (*&('$&% *  !"#%(' !< (2.&/'% %*'%%'! '9 !"%&)  

!"#% #&(-'/ (% . 2$%. .



 %  4'*5"6 (%&7)1( $ (* - %''$&/''=(*!""$"('! - !$ .-&. .!'((. 

 !"#%/&*'$ *'$$&( &2 %8!"$8$ (.8.



) (* * /'%(&!'$' * '%'$9 !"%&%' *'.1( $ (* - *"!"#$% %*#&(-'/ (%! #'!

-""!$(9 !"%&%' %')(- *'$/'%(&!*' * *'*&(//&$'9') $% ) %'$%' % / # (*&('

!1&2&$%"/ 1'%'$%)1(2&!) $%8$1(%/ % 1*'%'!!&/&$' - $%8 ($'$%- 1*'%&%/&$'

%#% - $%.



(- /1&$%  4(%'*5"6 (%&7 -%&$'9 !"%&# (*&:%>>% $$// $?.

=#'!$ 

%# %!$$ * !""& 4 )'(*$ )'.@? '$%&4#&$9 2 $

! $!$.



 !"%&"%$$!(+)&&)&% / %(%%&%/&$'('.









#

 

 

"#%"%$$'9' (')1&+)1(2&!'$&% *  9'(( %$&""! '+$' ((& &2!" !"#%(' 9') 

-""!$( ( %'$ "%$$' 9'(( *&(' !%%'%"&/'% /&$'$%8 !&* /&%%' #&(-'/ !& )&&' ! />>*/&$'(

!"#%"%$$' ) (&!(%%' % ) !$%'2'/&$'$%. '+$)1&* !$'( #'* * !&- (&!$/''%($'$8!&

! '+$'$'&% "%('% $'(('( #'* /&$%!"#%&$%2&(.



$



 



  !"#%(' '$&% %* 9 !"%& ) (*$' !"# $'(% %'#%& 4 '*5"6  (%&7 !"#%  '$/ ! '

&'2&$%&$$'..0. 8"$ ! 9&% (&$$!""&8"$ &!'!$" (2$'$%9' (')1*$'%'$

"$ *'$   -   . $ =#&2 91#&%'2')$'!$ "(& ! $% %* ! 9 *' &&*''$'/'%'

 - ' - 

#(2&! + *$8&/9"%+&% & $%. $ *'"/ * /&$'(('99&$&*"$ &!*!"!!8'%!/+!&

&)'$%''&+ 9&! - (&$' ( '  &=#&2$$' ?0. !8 !"!! 0 !""& ! +  -  )  

$"'% /&$'!$ '%%')1%($' ($% /&$'(. $ =#&2 %'2%$'$ ) $% ) (% &9( &('  #(* ) (% !&

0. $=2&$'&8/&("(!"*/%$8! "$ &!.% 2 '$!"!!('99'$%- # !! $"$ (&$'(%

% 2 $&1*/ &=#&2$$'&)'$%''&%* # .0. ")'/+&$% 2 $% %&2&% (('!""&.

&& )1(2&! =#' "$ &! !"!!('99') $% ' %'2')$ !& !  )1(2&! ('9&29 %'&$ /+$

%'!!&/&'

)&&$

&=#&2

! #-/&&.

'9&29 %'&

9""(%

$ *'%*

! + $%

"$%$

/!&/&$)'"$ /==2&!1(+/ %!$- "$ ! 9 &!'$$'"$'$)''! #-$%$%'2 8/&$%1%%%(&

! 9 .  -  &$ / #  ! * .  /%& '& "(' "$ =#&2 -+   0.  *'%$'/+&$% $ *

9 %'&(%! 9 - %'2')$"$&$(&$'(%$'&$!*.1(2&!"/ ! 9&% ("/%*'2 %&&)$'!$

-  )1(2&! " ! #-/&$. A. ..  $ +$ )1(2&!(' ;(& $ ! $" 2'% &(%

9 !"%&#"& %$8/&(('!"# $'(%."("")% *'&('"/ 1*'$// $0!""&- 

)1( $ (* - 1 +!""$&%'$$&*'- $&$$'1*'!(*'2 !"!!@@0?.A0!""&% $/&$%.

 )1(2&!)  $%'&-%!)1( $ (* - %'!1&2&1'%' #(* /&$'!$8$&&$9 (+-# %$'(&&2'

. (2 % *  4'*5"6 (%&79 !"%&/''%($- !(% * )(- 9 !"%.



  !"#$ . .. . /$'2  (2 % $ 4 '*5"6  (%&7 9 !"%&/''%($' &2

/ $ -%&$'!$9 !"%&# (*&!$:.



"   



"#%&$%2&( -%&'9 !"%&# (*: *&$ ) /$'8/&(('!"# $'(%")1(2&! 4'*5"6

 (%&79=$&) (%/ !$'-1'%&2%('+)(- !(% * )1(2&!9 !"%.

$ =#&2 " ! %* &'2&$%&$$' ..0.  "$ ! 9&% (&2   !""&8 91#&%'2')$ ( *'!$

%>>$%$ -  ! $% %* ! 9 *' - ' &2 #(2&! + *$8 '!$9"% -  &/9"%8 %&$/&%''$'*.

$ =#&2('*5"6 (%&7"-'(9&/&$%'- '%%')1%%' / %9&* /&$' */'%'91#- (!&*( !$

%'#%*)1(2')$&!"!!$// $?@ !""&8$.#.)1(2"$ &!0!.1(2&!("

)   9 2 !"%"(0?@.?!""&8! 9$"'% /&$)%$'$?@.@!8!&&$%&*8$1&*!'&*

'2  /* '2&$%&$$' ! % ) % )   '& "('. ''2  -%&$' # (*& #& 2( " )1(2&!(

' (&$''&% ) % )   "&'%'') (%  !""& )%$'$. 4 '*5"6  (%&7

9 !"%&/''%($'$ ) - + %9$'/ % $'(2&% /&$% )1(2&!(' !(* % $9"*&) #'*& '7'*'$

'B&%"'2./2&2 A

/==! ./ &(0. . 2 $&)1&%/&$')1&/ ($%'!"#% $ +

(19(&!

$'&$!"# 

)1%% 

9' ('

91#- (&!/ %

%%)/&$%

"$ =#&2

 / %9&* /&$*"!/'% %$&""&2 . 1(2&!( " !'$"(') !$ - !$  %>>% - 8 / !$'-1'%$

&(/'$ A. .. 8 !&  ;(& $' ! $$" 2'% '$&% $ 1*' )1(2&! ) $% $// $

@@0?.A0!!""$9 !"%&#"& %$'2 .

''2 8 %2&'*'$ -%&$' # (*& !$%$'$ "(') %'(' *"!/'%&*'(' -  !"2%* */'%'('8 ('& +

-%&'# (*8'%)1(2&! 4'*5"6 (%&7)1( *=('% ) */&%/'!"*$'(%)  )%$%&2! 

!"2 )   ' (&$''&/&$' -'( '& "(' )1&/ (&! )1(2 !$%% *  C 4 '*5"6  (%&7 " 9=$&) (%







/ !$'-1'%.-%&'# (*&#& 2(")1(2&!/ !$'-1'%$'91#-$'!$) $%"(*"$ &!'

) #'(8$.#.=#'"$ &!9""(% # (&$'1*''$&% /&'&=#&2) $%8/&$)(&$% $'* $9&*&/&%%'

&(% !""$%'2%$'/&$'8 ) &* !  =(*$' &=#&2 %"&/&/&$'8 !  )(&$9 %' (""+$ ! + 

'* $9&*&$'$% $ %/&$'$%. -%&' # (*& %>>9'&""*&( '& "(' %) $% %* )1(2&! %'2')$'$

9 !"%&!&%'"

)1&

/

/ - *$!&%'"

%$'&*

'2 

 $!'%

-#%&/&$)&2 8

!&*

9 !"%&/''%($'!&2$) - +$'(2&% /&$%8! $ 4'*5"6 (%&7-# %$'(&&2')1&"/ &!*"

$""&% *9 !"%&!&%'")1& $!'-#%&/&$)' .

-%&'# (*9 (+)(- !(% *  4'*5"6 (%&79 !"%8"(('$1$%'2%$'/  4'*5"6

 (%&79 !"%&/''%($'$9 !"%&# (*& .4#%( $&9 (+ -%&'# (*)(- /1&$% )1(2&!(%

-%&$'9 !"%&# (*&%>>% $!$- !(*'! %%'!$?!""&.



1(2&!)"(&% %*'$&* - !"#%&$%2&(('&*&$8'%9 !"%&/''%($%('!$(19'% *  2'/&$'2 8

-%&'# (*-&"/ $'&$!"# -*'8'%%('+ 4'*5"6 (%&79 !"%)(- !(% * .



     

"#$8 !( *   )1( $ (* -  $'('%$'8 -%&$' 9 !"%&# (*& ) /$' -  %%)* $- $

!"2%* !&- (&!' / %'- (&*'2  -  -%&$' # (*&  *'2 8 ('&*&$8 '% 9 !"%& ) (*$ "

91#-'* %*. '$"(') $ $- $%('+)(- !(% *  !<  ($'()1(2&!9 !"%8!&)1*

)1(2&!"9=$&) (%/ !$'-1'%.

1(2&!( " )1(2 $&* )#'/ (% ?@ . 0 !""& ''$%8 !&* )   $1(%) (% $'(('

' (&$''&/&$)1&/ ($%'$%=!$'$!""&''$%8/&$%1%%)1(2&!'&$*  #(* * 

)1( $ (* - %'1*'&*&2$''$%/ %$%('') (%"$ =#&2/ - *$(&!$%"(!" $%'&"('

-%&'.    % 2 $&)1&%/&$' )1&/ ($'* 9 !"%&9'$$  '& "(' %* #'%!'( %' *  &2 ) - ) *

%9$$% /&$%.  /%& " "$ =#&2( =!$ 9 (2 (&' %>>% - 8 !'((' - "!$ " ) - (&! %'#  % "(%$

>>%! $$ ('. "#$ ('& +8 '% %('+ )(-  !(% *  )1(2&! 4 '*5"6  (%&7 9 !"%.

 !"%&# (*&!$ &/'% *   :8 !'$ " $'(('!$ ** 1$"('! &2 ) $% +  ! < 0

'$&% % ) %'('1'%'('.

-%&$' 9 !"%&# (*& % $ -  !(%$%' $$'!$ !&&% *  ?. !""&8 /&$ " !""$!1( $

-$%&&%$/&&$%& .AD?.. . . /$'2  E !"%&# (*& -  -%&$' 9 !"%&# (*& % $*'

9&&/ *- #=)&% /&$'('!() %'!(%$%' )'$% /&$'!" $F!'#%'$% %*9&&/ *'2 &2

/&$%('+)1(2&!(%)(- /1&$%  -%&$'# (*&:! $!$+=""(' 4.



'((" #%)''

"#%&!