Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-05-169/1 ECLI:EE:VMK:2006:2.05.169.16837 AI generated

2-05-169/1 · Viru Maakohus Narva kohtumaja

Case Number 2-05-169/1
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

'% !"%&% 0 +     !"#%$"%$' $'  =$7 ,*% !"%&% '% $,,

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-05-169/1 · Viru Maakohus Narva kohtumaja: '% !"%&% 0 +     !"#%$"%$' $'  =$7 ,*% !"%&% '% $,,

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text























          

 











  !"#$





"#%$ !%& "'%"

'!

'%(

)'' $%%" ' 

*!)'!%'

 )!"'

 

  

+ ,   -









 













%&  .,%

&' #/ '

 .,%

&' %$ '%' ,((



$$

' 0,' *$0' 

  

     





/'&1%& .,%

&'2345

"%&1'

.,%

&'2345









  

 6

   

  

)(%%%& .,%

&'#/

#$0,% 



 

$,7!6""! 7",,' '%$!$$0' 





 

 

"#%$"%$' 6'' "  */$ '%0 6'%"" !'7$ "%' 

$  /!" !"#%$' 8 6('

&""!$

%'!"#%$"%$',' '%$"%''!(%%'%",'%,'% 



       !



 "#!   $#!  

  



!









%&  .,%

&' & '

 .,%

&' 7'$ #$%% 8  9   

  !"#%$

+    ,((

$'/

 

9  ,*%'% !"%&% #/'& !$! ' 0' :#%' 6'



'! 0

 .,%

&'- : 0  3  - :60,'! ,' 00 $$

$' ;  !*!'

'%$'!$!%'%/!$'%!$ 3 

 





/'&'%     

  !"#%$'%"%$2% 4'%'(&,*%,'!6''

$$

' 0,'% 

/'& ,(

! %"%$'- '% "  6 %', :60,'  "%& ' %"'% ,%'

'% 

%

#' $0%,%%':#%'/!"

0!"%&% 2#/'&4'",%%<<!"#% ="'/

*67 !""  $$!$$%$'0 6"&'1 %"%

 !

"" - 6"

%

 !

"" - !""%

7'0



!

"" -

0'

8!

""  

/'& 6$7 &$# 0$0' ='

'!" '0$' >  (& ,*% !"%&% '%

# /!$'

$,,!

""  

/'&%'%-'%%'"'6<<

0$ $0!"#%$%(%$

6""' ''6*#&$'+   



 !"#%$"%$'



9%(%,'!'"',0/%'#%$0!"#%$%(%$

6""% 

'0 ?"%!"%&

%&,%'

'%"$!"

0!"#% /'&", 0!#'%" '

!"

%'

%'

 '"$!"

0%'"',$$% $0 2%  -84



 



"%& !

&!$ %$' ' %$ % $0 #/ & ,(

!- '% ' *% " '! 0

 -

!$ "   9@  

  !"#%$"%$'/%::0,*%'%$0  /! %$0!

%$%

 / %'   9   !$     '" $0'& %,$#%'0%& 

.,%

&'/ 





  



"#%$%$ /&(#/'&#/0$''%%$0 *$'%'&$$

0'  /%"%'-'%!"#$,*%

(&'%%6"&''! 0

$,,!

"" !$$-!$ 9%&""!$

#!"%&%

' $0 "%&',! $0'%!$ %" !"/$'/ / $!"%&!

&$%7-'%%'

"' '! 0

 -  #/'& "  *$ ''/  /'& '/%- '% '% 0$ !"#%$'

''!- '% 0"!$,' 00 "'! !"

!$% "

,%%$0   ' *% $0 ,0/ '%%' ''!- '%

'% !"%&% 0 +     !"#%$"%$' $'  =$7 ,*% !"%&% '% $,,

!

"" 6':60,'! " #""0& ','%$'!,""0$%7 +

+

!

"" !$$ !$$%76'6''!

"" !$$ 



  







"#$'7-'%'"'6*#&' 0%$0#/'& *$'%'%'(&,*%,'!"%&%#/'&!$!

6"&'! 0

:60,'!$$

$'!

"" !$$ 

>(%'%7-'%!$,7!6""6'7%*' 0, '0&"$0-,''%$/ '0%',

*$0'0&%$(%'0 

+    

  !"#%$,((

$'/",*%'%$0(&!"%&%#/'&!$! ' 0'

:#%'6''! 0

.,%

&'-: 0 3 -:60,'!,' 00$$

$';!*!'

'%$'!$!%'%/!$'%!$ 3 



='

'!" '0$'2'0=

4&(

/*7!"#$ $%:!!"

0,*%(&'%% 

%%=

>/8*7!"#$ ',

''$ 0*6'&0$',$$%$,'

#$%%$0!$ *$0''%'$$

$%,$$% 





"#$ "  '$!"#- '% #/'& *$0' '%' $$

$' ,$$%,' ' "' !""!* !"#%$'

'%%$0%*' 0%'/ 

/'& '/%- '% '% 0$ !"#%$' ''!- '% 0"!$,' 00 "'! !"

!$%

"

,%%$0- !$   % "

$7- / 6

'/$ "  !

""    ' *% $0 ,0/ '%%'

''!- '% '% !"%&% 0 +     !"#%$"%$' $'   ' "' 6<<

0$ $0

!"#%$%(%$

6""' ''6*#&$'+   

  !"#%$"%$'



9%(%,'!

'"',0/%'#%$0 "%&'%"'%6"&7%#%!$% 

'0 ?"%!"%&

%&,%'

'%"$!"

0!"#% /'&", 0!#'%" '

!"

%'

%'

 '"$!"

0%'"',$$% $0 



"%&(%7-'%%'6':60,#/'&6"&'! 0

"  / 



=! >  /  !"#'% ,((

%!' '% 6'' ! 0! /!$' '%$

# - (#%$0'

!$,,/ ',

'%'$ 0%&6'&0$%'% 

=!>/+!"#'%/!$ ''%$

#:#''6'''*"(!',!$6""2A 4

7

/%$'!'#%'%%$0!$$6/,,((

2  %B8+!

"" 4 



=!>/&(

/!"#$*7&(%%'%'(&,*%,%*''$$

$%(#' 00

,'%%$0 $$

$' !$  ',- !''% '%% *$%!'- "  %<<*,'%$ * 6' "  6

'%$'!*, '0,$$0!"#%$6""%,*&$!%$ %%$06*#&$'0 



=!>/8 ',

''$ 0*6'&0$',$$%$,'*7!"#$#$%%$0

!$ *$0''%'$$

$%,$$% 

)(

/ '%# 07!"#$ ',%'

%'$ 0%  /%*' 0'0''!"#%-! ',%'



 ' '$ 0 * %' &0$'0 "  ,$$%$ $0 *

'0' '%' ,((

,' *$0'

,' '%','/2%



94 



''/ '7 !"#$- '% 6' '%' $$

' 0, ' ' "' 6*#&' 0%$0 % /%$ %'  $'

,$$%$,'% &  $'/ '"%$0 :60,'!$$0' $$

' ','%  /  /'& & !"%&



''$ 0!',$$% $0 '"'''/'"''0$!$$%'%'(&,*%,'

!"%&%$$

$'!

""  

," !"#$! 0!%' $0#/'&''%$%'/-'%%':60,!$$0,""0$%0

!

"" !$$&''?!%" !""!*!#/'&'%%$00$'/ 



='

'!" '0$'>/&(

/"  ',%'*/$&!"#$%$6'''%#""%'0  /

 ',%'*/$'0&!"#$%$'06'$#%'" *

0'02=!>+4 

 ',0" !"#$%%$0:60,",'%%2=!>/4 



%'$$

$*%$76'&0$%'%  /,*', ',

'%'$ 0% 

"%& ! 7 !

%$% !$  9 8 9  - ' %<<%- % ' "' ", 0  

   /

! %$% 

/'&%<<%7#""0& &",7'%$'!$,7' !

"" !$$ ",7! %$ 



%%=!>*!'' "  ',!"#$%%$0",6'*/$&#$'!%, ''/

!$%' ' ','%(06':60,!"#$%$%6%-"  ',-!''&$$

'6

'7- !"#$%%$0 *$0, %''%  ',% =! >  *!'  (%'%%$0 6'

:60,!"#$%$'%(%,% 



/'&'"',0/%'#%$0+   

  !"#%$"%$'



9%(%,'! 



+

"#$'0-'%#/0$'"'6*#&' 0%$0  /'!$$

#$0,'' 

"#$&$# 0$7='

'!" '0$'2=!4>+->/->/->/ -8-+->>

+-+8+

+8-++

++ -+ -+9/652!'#% !$ 8  4>+/