Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
BS-2708/2003-VLR ECLI:DK:VLR:2024:BS0000000979 AI generated

Court dismisses creditor's claim for gift payments as they exceed reasonable family support standards.

Case Number BS-2708/2003-VLR
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Denmark (DK)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the creditor's claim for gift payments made to the debtor's spouse, ruling that the amounts exceeded reasonable family support. The debtor argued the gifts were for household expenses, but the court found no evidence of undue influence or legal grounds for conversion. Consequently, the lower court's decision was upheld based on the lack of justification for such transfers.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Konkursloven § 137, stk. 1; Resolutionsloven § 2, § 30, § 32, § 74: Gifts exceeding reasonable family support cannot be converted or claimed as debts in bankruptcy proceedings.

Keywords

AI generated
bankruptcy conversion family support standards undue influence gift payment validity creditor rights

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Konkursloven § 137, stk. 1
Resolutionsloven § 2
Resolutionsloven § 30
Resolutionsloven § 32
Konkursloven § 64
Konkursloven § 74
AI generated
BS-29699/2023-OLR
Court dismisses court action and mandates arbitration under company law and arbitration act provisions.
BS-307/2011-OLR
Court upholds dismissal of payment claim due to failure to disclose signer's position at creditor.
BS-49/2018-VLR
Court allows separate payment claims under DSR 249(1) when claims exceed 50,000 DKK each.
BS-1504/2014-VLR
Court dismissed appeal as bankruptcy filing deadline under Section 81 of the Bankruptcy Act was not met.
BS-898/2012-OLR
Danish court allows German bankruptcy trustee to recover fictive payouts under German Insolvency Code.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

Landsretten stadfæster byrettens afgørelse i sag vedrørende krav om betaling til kreditor i konkursbo jf. konkurslovens § 137, stk. 1

[DOKUMENT] Afgørelse (3 sider) DOM

afsagE den 5. oktober 2004 af Vest.re LandsreE.s 12. afdelinq (dommerne Marie S. Mikkelsen, Torben Geneser og Jette F. Skole (kst. ) ) i ankesag 8-2708-03

DAI Fordrirger A/S (advokat Michael Serring, Kobenhavn) mod ADoelindstavnte

(advokaE Bj arne Henriksen, Lemvig).

Ret.Een i Holst.ebro har den 31. okEober 2003 afsagt. dom i 1 insEans (BS 7-277 / 20031 .

DAI Fordriuger A/S er indtradts som appellanE i sEedeE for Finansieringsselskabet at 9/ro ]-992 A/s som falge af, aE DAr Pordringer A/s fra f inansieringsselskabet. har erhvervet cilgodehavendeE. mod Person 1 og dermed er indEradt som kredi.Eor i konkursboeE.

DAf Fordringer A/S har gentaget FinansieringsselskabeE af g/ao L992 A/s' pistand for byret E.en.

Appelindstavnte har pAstieE sEadfasEelse.

DeE er oplyst, aE der f::a lankonEo nr. @ i Linde Andelskasse Ei1 vestjysk Bank j. erene 2000-2002 er overforE. henholdsvis 5.1-00 kr., 112.400 kr. og 42.O0o kr., dvs. i a1.E 159.500 kr., i husholdningspenge ti1 dakning af udgifEer E,il Eoj og mad.

ParEerne har genEaget deres anbringender for byreEEen. Landarettena begrundelee og reeultat:

Det kan efEer de for landsret.cen foreliggende oplysninger om egt.efallernes j.ndkomst.- og formueforhold ikke antages, ats de midler, som Person1 lsbende har bidraget. med EiL familiens forsorgelse, oversEigrer, hvad der efter agtefellernes livsvilkAr mA anses for passende, jf. herved reEsvirkni.ngslovens S 2 .

Der er herefEer ikke grundlag for at antage, aE Person1

har ydec gaver Eil Appelindstavnte , ti1 hvis 9v1- dighed der kreves egtepagt, jf. relsvirknings lovens S 30, jf. S 32, eIler som kan omsEodes efter konkurslovens S 64.

Der ses endvidere ikke at foreligge utilborJ.ige dj.spositioner, der kan omsEodes ef t.er konkurs lovens S 74.

LandsreEEen stadf est.er derfor dommen.

Thi k endes f or r e t:

Byrettens dom stadfasE,es.

Sagens omkos toinger for landsreE.t,en skal appellanten, DAI For- Appelindslavnte dringer A/S, beEale Ei1 med 20.000 kr.

De idamE.e sagsomkosEninger skal betales inden 14 dage

Marie s. Mikkelsen Torben Geneser Jett.e F, Skole (kst. )

cfr. uden beE.aling.

Udskriftens rigtighed bekraftes. VesE,re LandsreE, Viborg, den 5. oktober 2004

Anonymiseret

reEssekreEer