BS-2794/2008-OLR · Family court dismissed claim that family authority must consider corporate profit results when assessing a person's contribution ability. (Østre Landsret)

Legislator summary

AI generated

The family court dismissed the plaintiff's appeal regarding the assessment of a person's contribution ability in a custody dispute. The plaintiff argued that the family authority should have weighed the net profit results of a company in which the person held shares, even though only a portion was distributed as dividends. The court ruled that the authority correctly focused on actual income received rather than potential corporate profits, as the law requires a concrete assessment of current financial resources.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Family Law Act; Child Custody Act: The family authority may assess a person's contribution ability based on actual income and assets without being required to speculate on or weigh unrealized corporate profit results.

Keywords

AI generated

contribution ability assessment family authority discretion corporate profit results dividend distribution child custody dispute financial resources unrealized gains

Cited Legislation

AI generated

Family Law Act

Child Custody Act

AI generated

BS-46164/2021-OLR

Court dismissed claim that pilot was an employee of bankrupt airline, ruling he was a contractor paid by leasing firm.

BS-35989/2023-OLR

Court dismisses appeal for costs as High Court's decision lacks suspensive effect under administrative law.

BS-7775/2022-FRB

Court rules plaintiff is legal shareholder and company cannot enforce restrictive private agreement terms against him.

BS-12/2015-LYN

Danish court dismisses divorce claims for business valuation and spousal compensation due to lack of evidence.

BS-20633/2021-HJR

Tax court denies loss carryforward for company deemed economically inactive during share transfer.

Full text

Sag om, hvorvidt Familiestyrelsen ved vurdering af persons bidragsevne kan lægge vægt på resultat i et aktieselskab i en situation, hvor kun en del af resultatet udloddes som aktieudbytte

[DOKUMENT] Afgørelse (10 sider)

!

""""""""""""

#$%&'()*3+&,,%'2664&$-%'.)/&*(%.)'%7+&$()01*

20&*(%(33).*)4+/).56)78,91& ). :.)'6) ;.)*%)*29%'+<<+

7+&$(+*.+1234567=

Sagsøger

2@ABCD@EFGHIJHEEKFL@IIHMJNOPMA<

3(

,%'1'%31*1%').1)'

Q&3101)%'R.)0%)*

2S@TTKI@ABCD@EKMFBU@ABCD@EFVWCT@XFYTKA<

Z))%& (.)).%1376[.[1('%&%;')7,%'1'%31*1%').1)'7Q&3101)%'R.)0%)*726).)$').=

Q&3101)%'R.)0%)*<[)([,.().1*)*&$)*\1(.&%]01'1]).%*%\1(.&%)[*)9&*0^ )

[^ ']_.)%,0'&')'1)'&9'1)%)0%9&\7%3()*\1(.&%]01'1)).3)()).&$71)*%1',&'1*7

6[.9,*)*()0&$.)%,0'&')',(0(()%%3&9'1),(\R'')+

`&)*).&*0&'[)(a;\)*6&[*%1R.)'()*2b+,*12667 ).&$\R.)'')*13)($;.&$.)'%

]0))0[)*%c22b7%'9+d76)*[1%''10\)6&*(01* [)(0&*(%.)'')*+

020

Sagsøger 4989964567584869868 845885

6444869868645798684289492 !"8656458#80

6864869868988454 Sagsøgers $65945

45964594$89854$8$6

34567584869868 49689868

%&'()*+,(-.//.0'1

2686$48 Holdingselskab A/S 1 5$4$"9898$95899284$0

"98986$69498594 Sagsøgers 49 Person 1

8#88<9$4=>?44$898686$4886 Sagsøger 54667689

Person 2 898#88<9$42>?27584$"98986$684989

858469"88964$68954686$485899479889655

8$:894$"98986$68$89 Person 1 898

88994$ 8899458684$8984876$886

Sagsøger 54667689499584889864$89 Person 1

88984446$789798$ 889945889864$8958894$80

899458686$8"9894 Person 1

2899=8 Holdingselskab A/S 1 68988686$48

Virksomhed A/S 1 28986884$8$4488

2 $99489A2 $95#98604$898688=! $9

5#98;04$89604$898845868899894$8878

8 $986;04$898845868898649884$887386$48

" 988899B48"988 Virksomhed A/S 2

D898985888498984 Sagsøger 8#894884;04$898640

9882A=?4864884$8$44

Sagsøgers 89658$654$8$649758469657986899

9882 >2 B"987588E

020

3442 3445 3446 3447 3448

9

7345 653 3386 23577 8225

8264 8264 37236 375644 375644

0 0 0 6644 6644

!" Virksomhed A/S 2's #:7$7%;0$'()%7#"7%<;:7#)&(0,*#(0,%*=

3443>3442 3442>3445 3445>3446 3446>3447 3447>3448

? 8542 36864 52638 67368 35638

@

A 244444 244444 444444 444444 444444

BC @D

E A 23576 65866 88422 365634 2857

F 36 G 3443C GAD

Sagsøger

Person 3's (P3) LMDC@LC

E

MDCC@@D@D LLCG

E@64N344N @ E@44NC

O@ CP C@D @3Q3448

F 37C 3448@O@ CP CGA@D D

@R Sagsøger LF @ A@

@D S

T

O@ CL CA Person 4 S

VW%#X(7#$3;*#6<#"67X3Y @ P3

M P3 D@ E@344N

Z@LCALC RF DD

020

3

456786898 5 886678878689695689856 8

8!"26785#98678568868!26$

Sagsøgers

456 8 5 88668986 586589

8698986869688

'5#988568988656869586868886898(868860

869695 889885869 8695 88689888868

867888659985 5869 8 8)889

7868956 695 88955 9856558688688658*60

9888868695 89868656)8(9586586868688

+ 869886869888689)96886888689)986589889

8 89686#56695 889(898868 8786565689

5869,86956 689986869689)86788865 8986

869866695 889(8988

&6695 889(895689898656 89#69056880

869 69 9989686-8 9985986869 99)8#

./89686)899569#695 89959655016

8656 8)8#

'688Sagsøger

5#98656 98898695689869 2988983$"565)

86688 *695689856868 8856566

5885Virksomhed

)8689A/S

)82856'68 86888898898690

65686688 568(865868'86)89 898

868696568668689865 6)665#90

8667'368 688Sagsøger ($6968888 96 560

6868 856886689)95#986

Sagsøger

65#96)8(8695 6888!2869688

86$6

63$"569 69656868 68686)8)#8!56456

96856"89895#986689886629

56886689 8"!56)#868692

88!"66,889 55)#8$86

'68689899856556886 88696 80

65656(8)68)6878)8 689856)89895 88860

658568695 895869,869686895868868865856

682988986 Sagsøger 65868688)#88599$86

865!5688688 92"6'868)6

8Sagsøgers 98)8688#8686856(898)680

6889

:;:;:<:

=

>

-5 888(56)8988-95689)8986-90

56886886#6898888 )86$7868 686)0

8?

<

<@ABACDEFGBHAIJIKLI;LF;DFB Kommune 1 ;QHL8(565 695 869#80

88869888(56)8988-95689)878689)699786

020

34536378947 383539433343634343436438349

0900

33 5333 3

!46374763793373!767"6395373763!43543"5536

3!76737038!4476"643689463794 0

64336#$%4763&3

'()*+,)-.)/01234.1251)6+77,825)925,14)0/,13)+:7;,1<31)+:)=>?)2/01@61,)=AAB?)C14)61D

341@@13)*1,015E)+4)6(5,+714)@15)0(,F2(27):,+)512)G?)51H1@61,)=AAB):/,*;I13)4(<)2/,@+<D

6(5,+714)@15)4(<<97)+:)=AA)J)+:)7,82561<;614?

K94567463&97939L7734"6353836376343777349494!&8330

64395476 3!3753637&43&4337M795334

7634363" Sagsøgers 76#753 734763"64394!&8336

5477463794 663345943&433M795334

QRQRQS

3763T334 363 Sagsøger 9534&4337K3L4337

K3L43374 637M34 4&433 337U&43377&43V

SW:7;,1<31)/@)6(5,+7

K3L4337!473!76367 39534X945 7737Y9536637&433

M63T3349&4736436&433794!&8363945 7737664

P3 794 643[$463763T334

!4369"643394!&83 !49L"638373479 330

3794 643[$

'()*+,)71221@7.14)3+712E)/7)0()925,1,)(FF1)34+43:/,0+<42(27123)+:7;,1<31?

%&4337344 33346333334"4377734939L7734"6344

945 7737&433

343437"634&79634"963435#7634!53456453763"66

3834TM$3473 Virksomhed A/S 2

438634 6695494_437"!53543437476#T

4

343444943794 Virksomhed A/S 2 94 8__4

`"33!563364#43 &4T224

36343773763343 !453944457734536 !#763370

6437#"6573467739347349349467#439363393763

6379467#4364

U&344943794 8`a_42!56333364#43

T`_24"94 82a_4546364#343 T2M

4

020

3456748979 6 94574595454554344792

4!797

"67947484#47444 Virksomhed A/S 2 844745

74455467544548844644445'48

474548844644 Virksomhed A/S 2 84479547

47479467944(8 95(759445547844#47640

45954767744445474845544454

-997645448447574445545478 7945./

$8447476744747979675745567594(8 9469(744

0123456789:;2;:<669=;9>?

@

ABCDEFCGHIJC@

3474747 94694567796 Sagsøger 8767745547L

7M 456755474P3's 8 7 8477 47M 4745

495845 8479M 7745494674#8 74459

75947454574#45 87 Arbejdsplads 1 ST40

9544597 8484455954 847457S50

47!575444947 84848 746(79M 759454#470

4#9467566449457 84

M 4844#476454474 Virksomhed A/S 2 42;:76:9U27V2WXXYZ96U9>2

M 7467448458(47 458474845557664

459473457674745485434747548456846745944M 7

796(75(4574#4677 844M 4758(47 844[998

7457476794489744574994477474554M 7

4695847 8449M 47484555766445980

55455(7744M 7455846785545467(#4M 675

67447455R84674577455948494474578495

M 47#96(4948446774M 755584(547

474674948M 67755859474#48(8

84(4757494M 4446748#57 844M

674955759454#949445544749459

M 7447(95894467 965474M 74474#45544

678564466784M 445549457 844

476747

020

34567589 6 4456663454799697646 45755

4855 45755746545 24454457

Virksomhed A/S 2 48&8'(9)

)

*+,-./0+.

Sagsøger 476 67564583858444 776'65640

64&4584 45784466475 4784

87346485(87 2767863 63454830

858444 776'654& 5959 9467844 776'654

4&77695 Virksomhed A/S 2's ;C98HIDJD;94579947580

'864663 64578484646&85879758797580

'86758454$04975 Person 1 L8695560

86736'85754 Sagsøger &58588449757

Virksomhed A/S 2 4456497K04976 74 5754584

6 576694485365766 45879 45646 45

79943795'575795569549&5579M87557

$0497K04977(NNO93 569 4 Sagsøger 45666694

3&85758'8676 86&8575879758'86&4564 770

8379 4 Sagsøgers 8497575869359

Sagsøgers 7 589 65959&8754456 84663 6749&

57589 6&8&84485&865&85'6873449769

&84&8'4 Virksomhed A/S 2

Sagsøger 45878 394646 4575564645 0

2578 45755447&5844548497&8'

(77597

44 776'65476 6756458454546 57843 6

57 56 66656958895865

PO4(O4PK7846664663 6Q(R&5856'574564

385695 7699&588665" 38& 780

84663 6784747587875 4784

020

34567898 9948476 457 454758979454548 970

944858968797458745857494857897440

57849744858954749568948476549575467898 9948

7944856949 488 5784 8494959849675780

497448569496848476754 4694 868484

77648447597549966484694454766 5448844

5494977957849744599484484449676484

47644949848954544874

!8549 489579578497444599484484449

6754469474788479 95458957849744

4748454545994548448444967

"87454 54685975784974487#4764449464

!85784974474647648894845447#4498454879544

476789444494767897544694895454488 889

48 94$48448457954444846949459954 489

5784974484589857457667898 9948476 4570

49889484

%6 477678975897978884484494487944&

'48454448894754764984878797795454489445450

65484848749(588448484545445448754476485549

948484494475459947849485549549748

)4845405479544894454565484$544478447547649

84878797*44949549474958487+48549 990

984874984444584445465897597954565484

848749865(58844848454547544694776789750

89797888 496 5446944495488 8899748489

7948474994754764855497849485549549748

020

34567896767667666 668688986686678

6 68686864978866789678696 66766860

87788666 69678697686678968 674

Sagsøger !76767896977494687686!78668967680

86686678877887667668888

6!68 Sagsøger !7766 69678 686996780

6686764

687686!796797 6976 6676677 978686

68768687686"#4677"$$%!976 Sagsøgers 767

688977666"$$&7'46(667"$$)4

* 6 676866 6687686697686 679767890

6767!666768667667!678789!6 67676688886

!68886678967!7766 69678 68699678 6

686764

+

,-..-/0+1-234/5-60-+72+3-046.8.+

9 6 8867686:6 9:78978768674'3%2;"$$$86

%% 6677<

=>

?697686 69767896767!666768667686868 66

9678 6868666 686666 76 678699670

8 66684

>=

@ 8766677 Sagsøger 667"#AB&6768686

Virksomhed A/S 2 687686868667668!6!988

Sagsøgers 79!888679 Sagsøger 6!76866 6 0

68686864@ 8766676767 Virksomhed A/S 2

768876"$$3;"$$A!7!6768"4B')4B2$74!973$$4$$$

74676 68686768876"$$A;"$$B!7!6768

'4A3B4")%74!97'4$$$4$$$74676 698686768876

"$$B;"$$#!7!6768'4B#%4"B)74!97'4$$$4$$$74676 64

0230

456789 6679596795558986 79 5967795 985

Virksomhed A/S 2 %979665 Sagsøgers 79580

%6( 999 999675"95878) 7 5589867%7

86%75986"5678) 795 %"9"985676"9 67858

( 6"8)677558"9%566659865*+6"%9*33,%76-59

5695 Sagsøger 7 2333333995 Virksomhed A/S 2

%79967968589*33.$*33+569567 985

456789 659%7588) 8658568""8669558986580

8677)6657 657%"58567

/

0/1//2////3//4//5//6//4//7////8//9//:////://4//;/</

&8 8 8 9 589869 678

=858""866985 Sagsøger 6762>75 5*.3339

&8 8 8 9 58986

58""86696"996 8 996 "%68?@5

/

Family court dismissed claim that family authority must consider corporate profit results when assessing a person's contribution ability.

Legislator summary

Legislator headnote

Keywords

Cited Legislation

Related Decisions

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Full text