Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
BS-1280/2013-OLR ECLI:DK:OLR:2023:BS0000003730 AI generated

Court upholds landlord's appeal confirming housing judge lacks recusal grounds for housing dispute.

Case Number BS-1280/2013-OLR
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Denmark (DK)
Decision Date
Outcome Allowed / Granted
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Eastern High Court upheld the City Court's decision rejecting the landlord's request for the housing judge's recusal. The landlord argued the judge should step aside due to prior involvement, but the court found no legal basis for such recusal in this housing dispute. Consequently, the judgment confirmed the judge's continued participation and the landlord must pay the tenant's legal costs.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Housing Act; Housing Judge Act: A housing judge is not required to recuse themselves when presiding over a dispute between a former landlord and former tenant regarding the same housing matter.

Keywords

AI generated
housing judge recusal landlord tenant dispute judicial impartiality housing law Denmark recusal grounds
AI generated
BS-1095/2014-OLR
Court dismisses appeal against judge's refusal to recuse based on alleged bias comments.
SS-3912/2011-OLR
Appeal dismissed; court upholds lower court's decision to require jury participation for potential combined sentence.
BS-1488/2008-OLR
Judge recused for expressing certainty on case outcome violating impartiality under Retsplejeloven § 61.
BS-2959/2010-OLR
Court dismisses case against bankruptcy estate as illegal cash payment agreement violates public order.
BS-1122/2011-VLR
Court dismisses tenant's claim for rent reduction due to structural defects in the apartment.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

Landsretten stadfæster byrettens kendelse om, at boligdommer ikke er inhabil

[DOKUMENT] Retsbog med kendelse (2 sider) UDSKRIFT AF ØSTRE LANDSRETS RETSBOG ____________

Den 3. juni 2013 satte Østre Landsret retten i retsbygningen, Bredgade 42, København.

Som dommere fungerede landsdommerne Taber Rasmussen, Michael Kistrup og Julie Skat Rørdam (kst.), førstnævnte som rettens formand.

Som protokolfører fungerede Medarbejder ved retten.

Der foretoges

21. afd. kære nr. B-1280-13: Kærende, tidligere Udlejer (Sagsøgte) (advokat Steffen Olsen-Kludt) mod Indkærede, tidligere Lejer (Sagsøger) (advokat Jakob Busse)

Ingen var mødt eller indkaldt.

Der fremlagdes kæreskrift af 17. april 2013, hvorved Kærende, tidligere Udlejer (Sagsøgte) har kæret Lyngby Rets kendelse af 3. april 2013 (BS 150-415/2012) om at Boligdommer 2 ikke skal vige sit sæde, dommerens fremsendelsesbrev af

18. april 2013 og udskrift af retsbogen med den kærede afgørelse.

Der fremlagdes endvidere processkrift af 19. april 2013 fra indkærede.

Dommeren har ved sagens fremsendelse henholdt sig til den trufne afgørelse.

De modtagne bilag var til stede.

Efter votering afsagdes

kendelse:

Landsretten er enig i byrettens resultat og begrundelsen herfor.

Landsretten stadfæster derfor byrettens afgørelse.

Thibestemmes:

Den påkærede kendelse stadfæstes.

Kærende, tidligere Udlejer (Sagsøgte) skal i kæremålsomkostninger inden 14 dage betale 1.500 kr. til Indkærede, tidligere Lejer (Sagsøger).

Retten hævet.

(Sign.)