Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
BS-2145/2012-VLR ECLI:DK:VLR:2022:BS0000000213 AI generated

Court dismisses appeal against dismissal of construction contract dispute due to unclear arbitration agreement.

Case Number BS-2145/2012-VLR
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Denmark (DK)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Vestre Landsret upheld the Kolding District Court's decision to reject STR Byg AIS's claim against Phønix Tag Århus AIS. The court found that the evidence did not clearly establish a valid arbitration agreement between the parties. Consequently, the case was not dismissed as required by the appellant, and the original judgment was confirmed.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Arbejdsaftale 1991; § 10: An arbitration agreement must be clearly established to exclude court jurisdiction; absence of clarity permits court intervention.

Keywords

AI generated
arbitration agreement jurisdiction construction contract dismissal of claim court appeal

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Arbejdsaftale 1991
AI generated
BS-16215/2018-VLR
Court allows party agreement to transfer jurisdiction to Copenhagen City Court despite prior ruling.
BS-124/2008-OLR
Appeal dismissed; failure to prove defendant's financial inability or rights-losing inaction upholds arbitration agreement breach.
BS-2959/2010-OLR
Court dismisses case against bankruptcy estate as illegal cash payment agreement violates public order.
SS-1801/2011-OLR
High Court dismisses prosecution appeal, upholding lower court's dismissal of tax fraud charges due to insufficient indictment details.
SS-645/2022-VLR
Court upholds conviction for joint burglary theft, rejecting plea for sentence reduction due to lack of statutory mitigation.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

Byrettens kendelse blev stadfæstet

[DOKUMENT] Afgørelse (2 sider) Vestre Landsret holdt den 12. september 2012 kl. 15.00 møde på tingstedet i Viborg.

Som dommere fi.ingerede landsdornrneme Eva Staal, Olav D. Larsen og Carsten Busk (kst.).

V.L. B—2145—12

STR Byg AIS mod Phønix Tag Århus AIS

Fremlagte bilag:

— kæreskrift — brev af 28. august 2012 fra Retten i Kolding — udskrift afretsbogen (sag nr. BS 3-223/20 12)

— e-mail af 24. august 2012 fra advokat Anette Kusk.

Ved kendelse af 9. august 2012 har Retten i Kolding ikke taget afvisningspåstanden fra STR Byg AIS til folge.

Kendelsen er kæret af STR Byg AIS med påstand om, at sagen afvises.

Landsretten afsagde

K e n d e I s e:

Af de grunde, som byretten har anført, tiltrædes det, at det ikke er klart, at der er indgået en voldgiftsafiale, og at der således ikke er grundlag for at afvise sagen fra domstolene.

Thi bestemmes:

Byrettens kendelse stadfæstes.

Sagen sluttet.

Eva Staal

Anonymiseret