Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2 ARs 306/24 ECLI:DE:BGH:2024:201124B2ARS306.24.0 AI generated

Refusal of jurisdiction allocation under § 13a StPO and appointment of defense counsel in criminal sentence execution proceedings

Case Number 2 ARs 306/24
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Germany (DE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Federal Court of Criminal Justice (BGH) rejected the convicted defendant's applications for a determination of the competent court under § 13a StPO and for the appointment of his counsel of choice, thereby upholding the rejection of his procedural requests. The dispute arose from the defendant's attempts to challenge the enforcement of a two-and-a-half-year custodial sentence imposed by the Stuttgart-Bad Cannstatt District Court, specifically seeking a jurisdictional ruling by the BGH regarding his "lawsuit" against the prison. The court determined that the prerequisites for a judicial forum allocation under § 13a StPO were absent because a competent court already existed within the scope of the Code of Criminal Procedure: the Karlsruhe District Court (Pforzheim branch) retained exclusive jurisdiction over execution matters under § 462a para. 1 StPO and prison law under § 110 StVollzG. Consequently, the ancillary request for the appointment of defense counsel was denied due to the lack of prospects of success for the primary application.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

§ 13a StPO, § 462a Abs. 1 StPO; Refusal of jurisdiction allocation under § 13a StPO and appointment of defense counsel in criminal sentence execution proceedings: The dispute arose from the defendant's attempts to challenge the enforcement of a two-and-a-half-year custodial sentence imposed by the Stuttgart-Bad Cannstatt District Court, specifically seeking a jurisdictional ruling by the BGH regarding his "lawsuit" against the prison. The court determined that the prerequisites for a judicial forum allocation under § 13a StPO were absent because a competent court already existed within the scope of the Code of Criminal Procedure: the Karlsruhe District Court (Pforzheim branch) retained exclusive jurisdiction over execution matters under § 462a para. 1 StPO and prison law under § 110 StVollzG. Consequently, the ancillary request for the appointment of defense counsel was denied due to the lack of prospects of success for the primary application.

Keywords

AI generated
administration of justice determination of jurisdiction choice of defense counsel code of criminal procedure e-justice custodial sentence

Cited Legislation

AI generated

Cited Case Law

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
§ 13a StPO

Main ground for rejecting the defendant's application for the determination of the competent court.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

Die Anträge des Verurteilten auf Bestimmung des zuständigen Gerichts gemäß § 13a StPO und auf hilfsweise Beiordnung seines Wahlverteidigers werden abgelehnt.

[GRUENDE]

Der Verurteilte ist durch das Amtsgericht Stuttgart-Bad Cannstatt rechtskräftig zu einer Freiheitsstrafe von zwei Jahren und sechs Monaten verurteilt worden, die derzeit in der Justizvollzugsanstalt Heimsheim vollstreckt wird. Gegen die Vollstreckung der Freiheitsstrafe wendet er sich mit verschiedenen Einwendungen und beantragt, für seine „Klage“ die „Zuständigkeitsbestimmung durch den BGH gem. § 13a StPO“.

Die Voraussetzungen für eine Gerichtsstandbestimmung nach § 13a StPO (vgl. dazu nur BGH, Beschluss vom 21. Juli 2020 – 2 ARs 177/20, NStZ-RR 2020, 320) liegen hier ersichtlich nicht vor. Es fehlt im Geltungsbereich der Strafprozessordnung (§§ 7 ff. StPO) nicht an einem zuständigen Gericht, da das Landgericht Karlsruhe – auswärtige Strafvollstreckungskammer Pforzheim – für Entscheidungen im Sinne von § 462a Abs. 1 StPO wie auch für vollzugsrechtliche Angelegenheiten gemäß § 110 StVollzG zuständig ist.

Die für diesen Antrag auf Gerichtsstandbestimmung begehrte Beiordnung seines Wahlverteidigers kommt angesichts der von vornherein fehlenden Erfolgsaussicht seines Hauptantrags nicht in Betracht (vgl. BGH, Beschluss vom 4. Februar 2020 – 5 AR (VS) 89/19 Rn. 1).

Menges

RiBGH Dr. Appl ist wegen Urlaubsgehindert zu unterschreiben.

Zeng

Menges

Grube

Schmidt