Legislator Case Law & Legislation
XI ZA 2/22 ECLI:DE:BGH:2022:261022BXIZA2.22.0 AI generated

Fixed fee classification for rejected hearing complaint without separate legal aid application

Case Number XI ZA 2/22
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Germany (DE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed
Court Costs No costs imposed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The plaintiff’s objection (interpreted as a complaint under § 66 GKG) against the Federal Court of Justice’s cost assessment is rejected, with the cost determination upheld as correct. The dispute concerns the procedural costs arising from a rejected *Anhörungsrüge* (complaint regarding a denial of the right to be heard), where the plaintiff’s initial objection against the prior decision was not accompanied by a separate application for legal aid. The court determined that the fixed fee for the summary review procedure under § 321a ZPO is calculated according to item 1700 of the Cost Tariff for Courts (KV GKG), not item 4500, as required by prior precedent for such applications without legal aid. The decision was issued free of court fees, and no reimbursement of out-of-court costs is granted pursuant to § 66 para. 8 GKG.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

§ 66 GKG, § 321a ZPO, § 66 Abs. 8 GKG; Fixed fee classification for rejected hearing complaint without separate legal aid application: The dispute concerns the procedural costs arising from a rejected *Anhörungsrüge* (complaint regarding a denial of the right to be heard), where the plaintiff’s initial objection against the prior decision was not accompanied by a separate application for legal aid. The court determined that the fixed fee for the summary review procedure under § 321a ZPO is calculated according to item 1700 of the Cost Tariff for Courts (KV GKG), not item 4500, as required by prior precedent for such applications without legal aid. The decision was issued free of court fees, and no reimbursement of out-of-court costs is granted pursuant to § 66 para. 8 GKG.

Keywords

AI generated
legal fees right to be heard legal aid reimbursement of costs procedural objections tariff classification

Cited Legislation

AI generated
§ 66 GKG
Cited in the tenor as the legal basis for interpreting the plaintiff's objection as a formal complaint and for the final order rejecting the objection.
§ 321a ZPO
Für das Verfahren nach § 321a ZPO, mit dem die Abhilfe bei einer Verletzung des Anspruches auf rechtliches Gehör geltend gemacht werden kann, ist Prozesskostenhilfe gesondert zu beantragen (Senatsbeschluss vom 28.
§ 66 Abs. 8 GKG
Cited in the dispositive to justify the non-reimbursement of out-of-court costs.

Cited Case Law

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
§ 66 GKG

Cited in the tenor as the legal basis for interpreting the plaintiff's objection as a formal complaint and for the final order rejecting the objection.

§ 66 Abs. 8 GKG

Cited in the dispositive to justify the non-reimbursement of out-of-court costs.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

Der als Erinnerung gemäß § 66 GKG auszulegende Einspruch des Klägers gegen den Kostenansatz in der Kostenrechnung des Bundesgerichtshofes vom 21. September 2022 - Kassenzeichen 780022141927 - wird zurückgewiesen.

Der Kostenansatz ist im Ergebnis richtig. Für das Verfahren nach § 321a ZPO, mit dem die Abhilfe bei einer Verletzung des Anspruches auf rechtliches Gehör geltend gemacht werden kann, ist Prozesskostenhilfe gesondert zu beantragen (Senatsbeschluss vom 28. Januar 2014 - XI ZR 372/12, juris). Da der Kläger mit seinem "Einspruch" gegen den Senatsbeschluss vom 19. Juli 2022 einen solchen Antrag nicht gestellt hat, ist für die Zurückweisung seiner Anhörungsrüge durch Senatsbeschluss vom 29. August 2022 die Festgebühr gemäß Nr. 1700 KV GKG (statt Nr. 4500 KV GKG) in Höhe von 66 € entstanden (vgl. Senatsbeschluss vom 28. Januar 2014, aaO).

Die Entscheidung ergeht gerichtsgebührenfrei. Außergerichtliche Kosten werden nicht erstattet (§ 66 Abs. 8 GKG).

Derstadt