Legislator Case Law & Legislation
5 ARs 1/20 ECLI:DE:BGH:2020:060220B5ARS1.20.0 AI generated

Commencement of limitation period for tax evasion as due-date offenses vs. genuine omission offenses

Case Number 5 ARs 1/20
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Germany (DE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Fifth Criminal Senate of the Federal Court of Justice (BGH) declined to adhere to its own prior jurisprudence and affirmed the legal interpretation of the referring First Criminal Senate regarding the commencement of statutory limitation periods for specific tax offenses. The dispute centered on whether the limitation period for "due-date offenses" (Fälligkeitsdelikte), such as tax evasion, begins to run at the moment the tax liability arises or only upon the expiration of the duty to act, challenging the established principle that limitation for genuine omission offenses typically starts only when the obligation to act lapses. The court held that the specific structure of these due-date offenses justifies a deviation from the standard rule, effectively allowing the limitation period to start earlier than the cessation of the handlungspflicht (duty to act), thereby aligning with the referred senate's view and overriding the previous strict application of § 78 StGB principles for genuine omissions.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Commencement of limitation period for tax evasion as due-date offenses vs. genuine omission offenses: The dispute centered on whether the limitation period for "due-date offenses" (Fälligkeitsdelikte), such as tax evasion, begins to run at the moment the tax liability arises or only upon the expiration of the duty to act, challenging the established principle that limitation for genuine omission offenses typically starts only when the obligation to act lapses. The court held that the specific structure of these due-date offenses justifies a deviation from the standard rule, effectively allowing the limitation period to start earlier than the cessation of the handlungspflicht (duty to act), thereby aligning with the referred senate's view and overriding the previous strict application of § 78 StGB principles for genuine omissions.

Keywords

AI generated
commencement of limitation period tax evasion law of obligations time of filing date of commencement preliminary ruling on tax liability
AI generated

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

An etwa der beabsichtigten Entscheidung des 1. Strafsenats entgegenstehender Rechtsprechung hält der Senat nicht fest und schließt sich im Ergebnis der Rechtsauffassung des anfragenden Senats an.

Die besondere Struktur der in Rede stehenden Tatbestände als „Fälligkeitsdelikte“ rechtfertigt eine Abweichung von dem – vom Senat weiterhin als zutreffend erachteten – Grundsatz, dass die Verjährung bei echten Unterlassungsdelikten regelmäßig erst mit dem Wegfall der Handlungspflicht beginnt (vgl. LK-StGB/Greger/Weingarten, 13. Aufl., § 78 Rn. 12, LK-StGB/Möhrenschlager, 12. Aufl., § 266a Rn. 112 ff.).

Sander

Schneider

König

Berger

Mosbacher