Legislator Case Law & Legislation
II ZR 130/08 AI generated

Statutory cap on aggregate dispute value when summing main claim and counterclaim

Case Number II ZR 130/08
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Germany (DE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Federal Court of Civil Senate (BGH 2. Zivilsenat) dismissed the parties' motion to set the dispute value at 30 million euros for both the claim and the counterclaim, confirming that the total dispute value is capped at 30 million euros. The dispute arose during appellate proceedings regarding the assessment of the court fee base, specifically whether the statutory cap applied cumulatively to the main claim and the counterclaim or individually to each. The court ruled that when the values of claims and counterclaims in a single proceeding are added together under § 45 Abs. 1 Satz 1 GKG, the total dispute value cannot exceed the statutory maximum of 30 million euros established in § 39 Abs. 2 GKG, which applies to the cumulative sum of all multiple issues in a single proceeding.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

§ 39 Abs. 2 GKG, § 45 Abs. 1 Satz 1 GKG, § 39 Abs. 1 GKG; Statutory cap on aggregate dispute value when summing main claim and counterclaim: Zivilsenat) dismissed the parties' motion to set the dispute value at 30 million euros for both the claim and the counterclaim, confirming that the total dispute value is capped at 30 million euros. The dispute arose during appellate proceedings regarding the assessment of the court fee base, specifically whether the statutory cap applied cumulatively to the main claim and the counterclaim or individually to each. The court ruled that when the values of claims and counterclaims in a single proceeding are added together under § 45 Abs. 1 Satz 1 GKG, the total dispute value cannot exceed the statutory maximum of 30 million euros established in § 39 Abs. 2 GKG, which applies to the cumulative sum of all multiple issues in a single proceeding.

Keywords

AI generated
value in dispute counterclaim added value assessment of costs proceeds merger of debt and claim

Cited Legislation

AI generated
§ 39 Abs. 2 GKG
Determines the statutory maximum dispute value of 30 million euros for the cumulative sum of claims in the proceeding.
§ 45 Abs. 1 Satz 1 GKG
Establishes the rule that values of main claims and counterclaims are added together to determine the total dispute value.
§ 39 Abs. 1 GKG
Wenn in einem Verfahren die Werte mehrerer Streitgegenstände zusammenzurechnen sind (§ 39 Abs. 1 GKG), beträgt der Streitwert insgesamt höchstens 30 Millionen Euro (§ 39 Abs.
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
§ 39 Abs. 2 GKG

Determines the statutory maximum dispute value of 30 million euros for the cumulative sum of claims in the proceeding.

§ 45 Abs. 1 Satz 1 GKG

Establishes the rule that values of main claims and counterclaims are added together to determine the total dispute value.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

Streitwertbemessung: Höchstgrenze bei Zusammenrechnung der Werte von Klage und Widerklage

[TENOR]

Der Antrag des Prozessbevollmächtigten der Beschwerdegegner, den Streitwert für Klage und Widerklage jeweils auf 30 Mio. € festzusetzen, wird zurückgewiesen.

[GRUENDE]

Der Streitwert beträgt - wie festgesetzt - 30 Millionen Euro (§ 39 Abs. 2 GKG). Auch wenn die Werte von in einer Klage und in einer Widerklage geltend gemachten Ansprüchen, die in einem Prozess verhandelt werden und nicht denselben Gegenstand betreffen, zusammengerechnet werden (§ 45 Abs. 1 Satz 1 GKG), bleibt es bei diesem Höchstwert. Wenn in einem Verfahren die Werte mehrerer Streitgegenstände zusammenzurechnen sind (§ 39 Abs. 1 GKG), beträgt der Streitwert insgesamt höchstens 30 Millionen Euro (§ 39 Abs. 2 GKG).

Strohn Caliebe Reichart

Drescher Bender