155.21 VRPGLPJALGA

CH-BE

Art. 73 Gesetz über die Verwaltungsrechtspflege (VRPG) - Änderung der Verfügung durch die Beschwerdeinstanz

Verwaltungsinternes Beschwerdeverfahren - Beschwerdeverfahren

Originalquelle öffnen Gesamter Erlass (140 Artikel) Maschinenlesbares Markdown (.md)

Art. 73 Gesetz über die Verwaltungsrechtspflege (VRPG) · Änderung der Verfügung durch die Beschwerdeinstanz

1. Zuungunsten der beschwerdeführenden Partei darf die angefochtene Verfügung oder der angefochtene Beschwerdeentscheid nur wegen Rechtsverletzung, nicht aber wegen Unangemessenheit geändert werden.

2. Die Beschwerdeinstanz gewährt dazu das rechtliche Gehör; einem Beschwerderückzug muss sie stattgeben, ausser die Gesetzgebung bestimme es anders.

3. Beabsichtigt die Beschwerdeinstanz, die angefochtene Verfügung oder den angefochtenen Beschwerdeentscheid zu ändern, so gewährt sie erstmalig betroffenen Dritten dazu vorgängig das rechtliche Gehör, wenn sich diese am bisherigen Beschwerdeverfahren nicht haben beteiligen können.

← Art. 72 Gesetz über die Verwaltungsrechtspflege (VRPG) Grundlagen - Geltungsbereich Art. 74 Gesetz über die Verwaltungsrechtspflege (VRPG) →

Gerichtsentscheide zu dieser Bestimmung (11)

100 2022 303 · be (Art. 73 Abs. 1 VRPG)

Property Owner v. Municipality Regarding Unauthorized Retaining Wall Height and Terrain Elevation

Cited in the context of discussing the prohibition of deterioration (Verschlechterungsverbot) in administrative appeal proceedings, even though the court ultimately found it not violated.

2019 GEF 283 · be (Art. 73 Abs. 1 VRPG)

Social Service Providers v. State Directorate Regarding 2018 Contribution Calculation and Equity Requirements

The court noted that the appeal decision could not be changed to the detriment of the appellants (no reformatio in peius).

2021 GSI 1228 · be (Art. 73 Abs. 1 VRPG)

Asylum Seeker Eviction Deadline Appeal

Cited in the reasoning for why a shorter deadline than the original 28 days could not be set.

120 2017 14 · be (Art. 73 VRPG)

Farmhouse Addition Demolition Order Overturned Due to Procedural Flaws in Enforcement

Mentioned regarding the prohibition of reformatio in peius, which justified the need to repeal order point 7 lit. b (regarding the retaining wall).

110 2016 174 · be (Art. 73 Abs. 1 VRPG)

Property Owner's Unauthorized Farmhouse Alterations Exceeding Permit Scope

Cited regarding the prohibition for the BVE (as an administrative appeal authority) to modify the contested decision to the detriment of the appealing party, except in case of a legal violation.

2016 2504 · be (Art. 73 Abs. 1 VRPG)

Appeal Regarding Food Safety Inspection Fees and Meat Origin Declarations

Applied because the court could only change the appealed decision to the detriment of the appellant based on a legal violation, not inappropriateness, regarding the fees.

200 2013 1061 · be (Art. 73 Abs. 2 VRPG)

Cantonal Equalization Fund v. Insured Person (Reduction of Supplementary Benefits Based on Hypothetical Income)

Although not explicitly in the dispositive, as this is a cantonal court decision based on cantonal procedure, the lack of explicit cost/legal aid citation in the final orders (which only refers to Art. 61 lit. a ATSG and a general rule about compensation) implies that the handling of costs adheres to governing cantonal law, which typically governs the final orders concerning costs and compensation in the absence of a BGG/LTF appeal.

500 39 12 · be (Art. 73 Abs. 2 VRPG)

Retroactive Salary Adjustment Denial Based on Legal Finality and Prospective Application of Qualification Changes

Cited in passing when noting that the Directorate did not grant the complainant a hearing regarding a correction detrimental to her.

32 13 11 23 · be (Art. 73 VRPG)

Property Transfer Tax Calculation on Turnkey House Acquisition and Limits on Tax Assessment Increase

Cited as the procedural basis allowing the appeal body to amend the contested decision to the detriment of the appellant (reformatio in peius) under specific conditions.

32 13 10 9 · be (Art. 73 Abs. 1 VRPG)

Real Estate Transfer Tax on Linked Land Purchase and Construction Contracts

Cited in the reasoning (E. 6) to explain the limit on the administrative authority's ability to change the decision to the detriment of the appealing party.

140 2008 29 · be (Art. 73 Abs. 1 VRPG)

Cost Allocation for Contaminated Site Remediation Upheld Against Legal Successor

Cited as the procedural basis allowing the respondent (Beschwerdegegner) to request a worsening of the decision against the appellant in their response.