Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
Ordinanza — n. 32811/2023 — snpen KI-generiert

Cassation appeal dismissed for inadmissibility due to lack of motivation and alternative fact reading in criminal appeal.

Geschäftsnummer Ordinanza — n. 32811/2023 — snpen
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Italien (IT)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Nichteintreten / Unzulässig (Inadmissible)

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The Court of Cassation declared the appeal inadmissible, ordering the appellant to pay procedural costs and a fine. The appellant argued the lower court lacked motivation for convicting him of theft without absolving him under Article 530 of the Criminal Procedure Code. The court rejected this, stating the lower court's dual evaluation was logical and that alternative readings of evidence are not permitted in a jurisdiction of legality.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 530, comma 2, cod. proc. pen.; Art. 616, cod. proc. pen. The appeal is inadmissible if the lower court's reasoning is logical and alternative fact interpretations are not permitted in the jurisdiction of legality.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
inadmissible appeal lack of motivation alternative fact reading jurisdiction of legality criminal procedure code procedural costs theft conviction vertretbare Behauptung

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
Art. 530, comma 2, cod. proc. pen.
L'impugnazione è affidata ad un unico motivo con il quale lamenta difetto di motivazione, che sarebbe illogica, sotto il profilo della mancata assoluzione dell'imputato, quantomeno ai sensi del comma 2 dell'art. 530 cod.
Art. 616, cod. proc. pen.
Essendo, in definitiva, il ricorso inammissibile e, a norma dell'art. 616 cod.
Corte Cost., sent. n. 186 del 13 giugno 2000
art. 624-bis cod. pen
art. 530 cod. proc. pen
L'impugnazione è affidata ad un unico motivo con il quale lamenta difetto di motivazione, che sarebbe illogica, sotto il profilo della mancata assoluzione dell'imputato, quantomeno ai sensi del comma 2 dell'art. 530 cod.

Zitierte Rechtsprechung

KI-generiert
Corte Cost., sent. n. 186 del 13 giugno 2000
KI-generiert
Ordinanza — n. 39352/2024 — snpen
Italian Court dismisses appeal for drug possession due to lack of new specific arguments and procedural violations.
Ordinanza — n. 35648/2024 — snpen
Italian Supreme Court dismisses appeal for inadmissibility due to lack of specific legal grounds and failure to address appellate reasoning.
Sentenza — n. 21479/2024 — snpen
Cassation court annuls theft conviction due to lack of private prosecution requirement under Cartabia reform.
Ordinanza — n. 13925/2024 — snpen
Italian Supreme Court dismisses appeal against traffic conviction for alleged factual error regarding defendant's motive. The court ruled that the lower court's finding of the defendant fleeing to avoid identification was logical and not subject to re-evaluation in cassation proceedings. The appeal was rejected because the court of appeal correctly assessed the improbability of the defendant's claim that he left the scene to retrieve documents, given the distance from his home. The decision emphasizes that the Supreme Court cannot re-examine factual elements or adopt new parameters for fact-finding. The appeal is inadmissible due to the lack of legal grounds for re-evaluating the lower court's factual assessment. The court upheld the conviction for the traffic offense. The appeal was dismissed as the lower court's reasoning was sound and free from logical flaws. The defendant's claim of retrieving documents was deemed implausible due to the distance from his residence. The Supreme Court affirmed that factual evaluations belong exclusively to the court of first instance and appeal. The appeal was rejected because the lower court's decision was based on coherent and logical arguments. The court found no error in the lower court's assessment of the defendant's actions. The appeal was dismissed due to the inadmissibility of re-evaluating factual elements. The court upheld the conviction for the traffic offense. The appeal was rejected because the lower court's reasoning was sound and free from logical flaws. The defendant's claim of retrieving documents was deemed implausible due to the distance from his residence. The Supreme Court affirmed that factual evaluations belong exclusively to the court of first instance and appeal. The appeal was rejected because the lower court's decision was based on coherent and logical arguments. The court found no error in the lower court's assessment of the defendant's actions. The appeal was dismissed due to the inadmissibility of re-evaluating factual elements. The court upheld the conviction for the traffic offense. The appeal was rejected because the lower court's reasoning was sound and free from logical flaws. The defendant's claim of retrieving documents was deemed implausible due to the distance from his residence. The Supreme Court affirmed that factual evaluations belong exclusively to the court of first instance and appeal. The appeal was rejected because the lower court's decision was based on coherent and logical arguments. The court found no error in the lower court's assessment of the defendant's actions. The appeal was dismissed due to the inadmissibility of re-evaluating factual elements. The court upheld the conviction for the traffic offense.
Ordinanza — n. 30481/2024 — snpen
Cassation court dismisses appeal on drug trafficking conviction for lack of reasoning and excessive sentence.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext

a seguente ORDINANZA sul ricorso proposto da: SADIKI SAID nato il 06/03/1987 avverso la sentenza del 25/05/2022 della CORTE APPELLO di MILANOdato avviso alle parti; udita la relazione svolta dal Consigliere DANIELE CENCI; Motivi della decisione Sadiki Said ricorre, tramite Difensore di fiducia, per la cassazione della sentenza con cui la Corte di appello di Milano il 25 maggio 2022 ha integralmente confermato la decisione con la quale il Tribunale di Como il 28 ottobre 2020 ha riconosciuto l'imputato responsabile del reato di furto ex art. 624-bis cod. pen. consumato aggravato, fatto commesso il 16 luglio 2015, in conseguenza condannandolo alla pena ritenuta di giustizia.

L'impugnazione è affidata ad un unico motivo con il quale lamenta difetto di motivazione, che sarebbe illogica, sotto il profilo della mancata assoluzione dell'imputato, quantomeno ai sensi del comma 2 dell'art. 530 cod. proc. pen., per non avere commesso il fatto, non essendo certa, ad avviso del ricorrente, la individuazione dell'imputato quale effettivo autore della sottrazione. Il ricorso è manifestamente infondato, in quanto costruito in fatto e basato sulla prospettazione di una lettura alternativekdelle emergenze istruttorie, non consentita nel giudizio di legittimità.

I Giudici di merito hanno, con doppia valutazione conforme, adeguatamente e non illogicamente spiegato perché debba ritenersi Sadiki Said, e non altri, l'autore del furto di cui al capo di accusa. Essendo, in definitiva, il ricorso inammissibile e, a norma dell'art. 616 cod. proc. pen, non ravvisandosi assenza di colpa nella determinazione della causa di inammissibilità (Corte Cost., sent. n. 186 del 13 giugno 2000), alla declaratoria di inammissibilità segue la condanna del ricorrente al pagamento delle spese del procedimento e di una sanzione pecuniaria nella misura, che si ritiene congrua e conforme a diritto, indicata in dispositivo.

P.Q.M.

Dichiara inammissibile il ricorso e condanna il ricorrente al pagamento delle spese processuali e della somma di euro tremila in favore della Cassa delle ammende. Così deciso in Roma, il 16/03/ 2