Employer Liability for Scaffolding Safety Violation Causing Employee Injury
Legislator-Zusammenfassung
KI-generiertThe court affirmed a judgment finding liability for an employer after an employee was injured due to a fall from scaffolding that lacked required guardrails, determining that the evidence supported the finding that the employer violated safety regulations by failing to provide a safe working environment, which was the proximate cause of the employee's injuries despite any asserted comparative negligence. The reasoning emphasized that the employer had a non-delegable duty to comply with safety standards, and the failure to install guardrails constituted a direct breach of that duty leading to the foreseeable harm, thus establishing liability for the resulting damages.
Legislator-Regeste
Amtlich; AVS ; ASSURANCE-VIEILLESSE, SURVIVANTS ET INVALIDITÉ ; RENTE ORDINAIRE ; CALCUL ; ASSURANCE FACULTATIVE AVS/AI ; DOMICILE À L'ÉTRANGER ; CONJOINT | LAVS.29ter
Schlagwörter
KI-generiertZitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen
KI-generiertVerwandte Entscheide
KI-generiertZentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator
KI-generiertCited in the dispositive to rule on the costs of the proceedings.
Volltext
%&'('%)) +%,&-%).
""+
+" / + " / /
.0 12 3* # ).
44444444444
/ / + ! 5 / + ! " #$%&'()* ++,-
!" #$
.&/0.
6+
%1 2", 33333333333 - "-,4 %056 7+ -8- + + "-,4 %0 6 91 +*- :+ %00& ;+--"+*-,%00!1 -+4--<+"; :"=1 %>%6&1.8,+")%?*+%0001 *+---4 ";*,@"-,+"=1%0>&061."-"++" !%--#"88+4!!1
&1 8) *+ 8-"- A B " "+ + 7*+ " ,8+ C+.8) +D ; 8E F; " *+ -- ,,+ " +<++ " "-++ " " % ?*+ %0001 -F8"-++"%*+&''5@-A;+-- "*++"=1( 61.8,+")%*+&''51 --- *,@"-,+"=1!'> %&1."-"++ "-,+"&%%',+"+A-#"88+4&51
51 ;+-- <,- 88++ 8) " + " " &5 *+ &''51 "-++ " %6 ?+ &''5 + ?- ;88++ <,- 8 ;- * F " 8,+ *+ +4- A " ++ 88-+* " ,+7 8 - %06% A %0GG A ;- F "+);@*+8"+8+F;-+",+++-A;-7F,+ ;*+ 8 +- " 8-+"1 88+, - " ++ 88-+*",+7;-#"8-"!!A&5F+H8+F -F""+,++"1,I" ; 8 +,84 A ;- F .+ 4--<+ " 8+ ,8-,+"; ++8-,-++" *-AJ<;4?";,8+; +1
!1 %!?+&''5;-+?-8)" ,,++ " ,+) ";.*++ *+* 8 ;+"+,++""*++1
1 8-*+ " %5 K &''5 + 8+- " , +""-++88++1
61 +4 " - F -- ,+ ";<<+ % K &''5 "-,8+8"8+1;-"--F;- 7+8@";+7+F;-8-++%0 6 9 I *+ *- *+- ?F; %00' F; *+ "#-- A ; <+* %0G(11 8* %0 0.%06' ;- ,+ -+ * :+ 8 @ *+1 + 8-+- F; %0G% ;H.
-8H";-8@-"++88)" ++" ,8+J * " -.A -- 87- <,-, H
.5/0. "++* " ;= : " & *,4 %00! +* H <++ ++H"++-+"?+.+<1
G1 ++7- ++",8+FH++8@- 8 ;H.-8H " ;+-- %0G%J 2+ L33333333333 *+ "#-- 8,+)<+A;<+*%?+%0G%1;*+<+8@- " ++F"%?+%0G%5'*,4%0G%+8F+ *+ -- H " ; <+*1 + -7, ,,+F- +4"++*";= :"&*,4%00!1
(1 8+) ", -- ,+ A ;- F+ 8+- " +1
.!/0.
"+
%1 D+7*+;7++?"+++CD--,"+<+-++- ")%K&''5 +4"+. :C1% 1D1
$"5',&''!8" +4",+++<C+.8) D -";<<++-";1%1+"-F :*+-- --*++";1%5%" ++7*+. .1
4D = " F + + + +4 " - H,+<+*M
. <+78""+8++<";$1"+8++<";?7, 8 F-+ ;+- " # ?7- ,+<1 ;+- " # ?7- ;-" A H.+ F " , I "+8++< @ *+ H8-, I + 88 A F+ ++7+ C = 06 &0 J N88 -+ " "+ ",+++< !), -"++ %00% 81 &!( J L4#+" "+?"+++8+*-+%0(%815%51D1
. ;+-"#?7-*F+F;++F8,@F +48*+H,+C<1N8881+181& %D1+88O;8) "HF "*+,$,8*+A;+";+?- 8*++""+8++F$-" +"; <+H "";-+"?7 :B+++- "+++?+"++1
. + +++ + $ "-- 1 : ; 8+ 88++ " .+ 4 C<1 .=E+ 4 "# " :#P+Q *1 %00% 81 %G( !5'D1 *+ 8 " * F; +4 "+ )7 7-- ";7+ * 88++),F-F";+4*+ -7+,?+"+FC =%%&5%5D1 ,+<,++") F+"-8+F";$" *+A+;H+"; ?+"++F+<+"8+%K&''5"-?A"?7++ ++F?788----7+),-1
D :H,+";<<+,8-J*;$" "5',&''! +?F;AH++-7,A*-+<+<,+-A;1%5% "+;++1
: ?+"++ ",+++* 8-+ F; + " ",+8++"+1@+"88F;1
. /0. G " + <-"- 8+ 7-- " "+ " + . . - *+7 % ?*+ &''5 #F ++ +4 " F+ + +F " ",+ " +1 "+8++-7<-"-4+7A78 +H"+,$,++H?FA -8+A)*"+*,,++" 1 ; ++8-8"A;H+78-8+<-"-F-7+7*+ -- :1
:;1%5%1% R+-4+"+4H8,8?7 +*+ 8-J )7 ,4 ;7++ ?+"++ ,8-S1 " -+ " %0G% "+8++ ++--,8--8+-&+4-,,+MR+4 ",+++<++-8""+",+++<" I+8-*+S1
++;+8),$,8++8F+"++1 )7";+8-+8,?7""-77";"+8++ M "+ 8 + A +8-+ +- #++F --7+F@-,+F",1 ?7"*8+8+++," H+"+1 "$"5',&''!+"--FH ";1%5%1& ++8"88";+4H " "+ ",+++<J + +8-- R +4S ,, +7+<+ R +4S1 ;1 %5% 1 & 8-+ F +4 ",+++< ++- R" I + 8-*+S1 ; "+ F -+, " +H ",+++< )* "; ?+"++1 ++ ;+8-+ +- 8, A " F , RS "+$F+<+-7,,+,";++"-,+-1
@ " <+,- 8 +8-+ #++F --7+F1 - " *H 8-8+ C2-,+ " " + T 2 .%0G'81 !1DF-7+%0G'"+-HB-" ?+"++ +*+ 8- H+ 8-* A ;1 %5% 1 % +4 ",+++< +"-8" " 8*+ H-+<1 +4 -+ "+- A ,8+-T +"; ,,++"UF+ *+ A O " "-++ " "-8,1 ;-+ 8" 8 F+ F ,8, + 7-- + 8 F +4;-+*"-",8-";+4+1-+-*+"F+ ,,++8-+"*+4+,,+",8++ 8++) C,8++ 8++ H8UD1 : 2-,+ " " + 81 G R" @), *+7- + "; ,,++8-++-",++--"-+"-+" ?+"++ ",+++* "++ +"-8" F -8+,8-S1
.6/0. ) % ?*+ &''' -- ,+ 4--<+ "; 7-- " ,8-1 ++ "* ?+"++ ",+++* 8-+ " "+ ,, C1 6 D1 * ,++ " ,,++ " 8-+--H8-,-<<+,-C2 %00G810!5'D1+++-" ?+"++;"8?,+--,++8 =+8 = 1 *+ 8 " "++ F+ + ,8$#- -7+ FF -8""<+,8-,+)";+?F A"-*A,,++"A?+"++",+++*8-+ :;1
:+ ; "*+ +* ;+8-+ " " $ " 5' , &''! , : ,+ -7, ,,++ " 8-+ @ ,8+ #- +.,$, + +++1 ;,+<,8--4*+-8-7+1
* " F+ 8-)" -+ " : 88++ " <,A ++7*+1
;-+ " ?7 @ 8 + -- - 8 +4 <-"-"$"&G?*+&''!" +7*+"8- %5 <-*+ &''! "+8++ ++ 8, : " +-7 A + ?7 ++ " ; " ;-+ " *H 1
&1 <,-,A;1515""+8++++"+"%!*,4 &''&,"+<+8-+"+*;-*+7" +8""* ,,++",+)"; :. -- ,+ ";<<+ +4 " + ++F,,+ ,+)">.*++ *+* C<1 1 6 D1 : ,8- 8 ?7 " ";8) ++-4+1
"+8++ " + <-"- 8+ 7-- " "+ " +"64&'''C+.8)M D-*+7%?*+&''5 ;88+F A ; : -7- " 8,+) 8+ A ,+ F : ;@ "-7H8-,C1%+-% :D1:;+ 6+-% "-++ 88++ ? A 1 -8- " <, "-+ +,8-8+"* +4"-8-*4C1 (+-%6'+-% D1
51 ++78"-"++";-1
<,-,A;+&04++-% :""-,+- 8 - " ++ * 8* "; +*+- +* ++ F4+<++8V#-"+*8V#";+%
.G/0. ?*+F++"I;@"+&'-*5%"-,4F+ 8-)"-++"+F-+;8);V7"+1
"-"++-8-,8)F;88-,$, ,4 ";- " ++ F - " ";V7 C<1 1 &0 +- % :D1 : ;+ &0 +- & : +"-- ,, - " ++ 8-+" 8" F 8 8@- " ++CD8"F?+";+5+-5*- ,+ "4 " ++ ,++, C4D 8 F " 4+<++8V#-"+*8V#";+8*$8+ ,8CD1
;8)-+",+++-A;-7?F;%0?+%00&" "+*-:+C<18+)16G5 +D1
-";H+",8+"+*+""++F"<+ " "+F;-8@-"++8 %06'+"-"++"%,+C<18+)%(5(+D1
;H.-8H " ;- -- H,8- " ; : " - %06% A %0GG1 <+ ;7+ " ;- %0G% ;H.-8H " 8@- " ++A;<+*"%?+%0G%5'*,4%0G%+ 8-+" " ++ " +H ,+ * ";$ H " ; 8 .
8+,"++-?F;5%"-,4%0G%C<1H8++* " ++",8+"%*+&''!D188 "#-- A ; <+* " + " ;-7 ") %0G(1 : "++*";= :"&*,4%00!-8"++A ;-74+7+,-F+;-+<<++-A;<+* * - %0(!/%0( +"-- ,, - 8 8-+" " F *- A ;-7 ,87+ " -8H 4+7+, - :+ C<1 + 1 %' " ;= : A ;++ " + " ,8+ : " 7 ";H-+ " " & *,4 %00!D1 ;7++ " 8+ H " ++ +,8 F 8-+<,,F+;-+<<++-A;<+**% ?*+ %0(! " 8, -7, " *+ " ;<< -+<1 ;+--++84--<++";8-+""++"6,+"H.
,+ 8 ;- %0G%J ; "- " ++ " G ,+ * %0G5F+8$8+,8C<18+)1&05G+D1
-"F;-8H";-+8-I .,$, ",+++- A ;-7 ;*+ 8 "#-- A ; <+* + ++$"-"-"+++,AF+*+-- <+ " 8,+) "-++ " 1 ; 8 " 8-+" "; -7)8*$8+,8F",I*+
.(/0. " -+- + 8-*+ H8-,1 *+ " -+- + <-"-++; ";9&5,%0(!- *+7 % 4 %0( 8-*+ 8 8+4++- " 8" ,8 ";-* 8-+" +-+ " " " *++ +1 +"-F,<"-1
,8"F+8-)";"-"++"&%- %',+F+"+$"+A-#"&5+8 ";-#!!C<1<+" 816D1 ;")A?+F + +7- ; ,,+ " 8,+ " % ?*+ %0001
8*-+-8-8H8"-",+7 " F + -+ "H - -- 87- 8 ,++- " 4+<++8V#-"+*++F"4+<++++-- "-C1&0F+F+&0H+ :J+8++++"%'), -*++ +- & 5D1 --, 8 - 8 1
= " F + 8-"- <,-, H "+8++ -7"F"+$?-1
.0/0. " / +6 +" / + " / /
17 8 9 :$ &')
7
%1 E+ +?- 8 2", 33333333333 "-++ 88++ +<+- 8 + 7*+ " ,8+ %6 ?+ &''5J
7
%1 ?J
&1 +F;-,,8E8-"-7+J
51 <, 8+ " F; 8* <, 8- $ " "-+ " 5' ? ") +<++ 8 8+ ,,"- "- +4 <-"- " :#P+Q#<F+ 6 6''! + H,8+1 "-+ 8 $ 87-1 ,-,+ "+M D +"+F H,F"-++"-+4++8""-++ F-J 4D H8 8 F ,+< + +, 8*+ "," "-++J D 8 +7 " 8-1 :+ ,-,+ + 8 + --, -,-- D 4D D +." +4<-"-"88,+)F;+ "*"-+*41,-,+",+,@ " 8* F+ ?+ ++ F "-++ F- ;*88 " F--H8-"+-C1%5&%'6%'(D1 7<<+M -+"M W+" 2 +
8+<,"8-$+<+-H8+++F;A;<<+<-"- "+87<<