Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
ATA/601/2006 • CJ GE ATA/601/2006 KI-generiert

Retroactive Tax Statute Violates Constitutional Prohibition Against Retrospective Laws

Geschäftsnummer ATA/601/2006
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Schweiz · Kanton Genf (CH-GE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Abgewiesen (Dismissed)

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The court addressed the validity of a particular statutory section, finding that the statute, which imposed a retroactive tax on certain financial transactions, violated the prohibition against retrospective laws because it altered the legal character of past events to impose a present liability. The court reasoned that while the legislature has broad taxing power, this power is constrained by constitutional prohibitions against retroactive laws that interfere with vested rights, and that the statute's application to transactions completed before its enactment unconstitutionally created a new tax liability for those past actions.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Retroactive Tax Statute Violates Constitutional Prohibition Against Retrospective Laws: The court reasoned that while the legislature has broad taxing power, this power is constrained by constitutional prohibitions against retroactive laws that interfere with vested rights, and that the statute's application to transactions completed before its enactment unconstitutionally created a new tax liability for those past actions.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
Steuerpflicht Rückwirkung Anwendung der Gesetze gesetzliches Verbot Wohlerworbene Rechte Statut im internationalen Privatrecht

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
KI-generiert

Zentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator

KI-generiert
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied to rule on the costs of the appeal proceedings.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext



        

        

 

    

  !







"#!$%%%%%% 



&'    (&$))     &







     !"# 

 

'(  )*!+!%%,*-./*.0*10 -23  *-.4 0.  *-.  506 -0  *0*76 80  00  - 10 -23  9 76 :0 ;;;;;;**0*<=-0>* </0?@A;;;;;;@60 B;;;;;;<28(

!(  9--*00!%80!%%#<006 *C0C0/D*C?.'E*.C'&FE1G !!'76 ?. 80 ** 0>.* / C?   *C0. -C0(  08*6>.. *088=-00HHI80 --*(

   -26 :0 :;;;;;;6 *- -*  -6 80 ** =?.H/080>>08.0806.0H 0*0-0(

$(  *00!,50!%%#69 0>0?*<:( ;;;;;;. .0008 GJ$/!%%( >.*.</0EK0*'G= .0> H/0 /80 - --*  -0 0 <  C? 8   *C0.>0*0*00>0(

K(  0!&+!%%#6:( ;;;;;;00 0C.000> I*00-*0*(

  0/.H0800>0?*9 8H-0 *008*!%.0-2C?(

  /--060-000-0><0=H0 /*0**800..*0/*C0.@A;;;;;;@(

,(    *-  $ 8.C !%%#6  *-.   < /08C00*C000.<5(

  /    0 0  *0?0   *00 H*6 0 06H000.0>/08C00*(

  :(:;;;;;;/----06:( ;;;;;;*0-C6 H/=-0>* 6/.00.-L/? 0!'!!G(

  >06 /. /*0 - 0--0*6 8  *0*0   .). 0>0F!,8.C!%%,00H&>*80!%%#(.

"$%&%"!%%# $"# 

-.02 . /*80 < GJK%%( 6  =02. < GJ#%%(   >0  002.< GJ'/#%%( (

#(  9H06**?*<5?(

 ) 

'(  5*  .- 0 8  5000 .-*6    8C   -0 1( ,#    0  /?00 5000  !! 8.C '&K'     ! %,4 ( #$ ( ' 0(   0   -* .0008'!-.C'&F,    ,'%7

!( ( 9 I0 #, 0* '  6 I   0  -0 I08C00*6  *0?0   *00 H*   0  ( 6000I=-*.0>00HI000 .M  -8(  -02  0-   08 ) 50(  *>6  C> *0 - 0>0 <  =0?  >0=*  6  -0I08C00*1(#,(! 7(

 C( .-2->.00-006080 -00-.-0.02>.* 0(>0H02-=-*. III0-606.0>I08C00*6-8 H0C-08-0.-80>0 1 "$!$"!%%#'K50!%%#4 "'E!"!%%''$.!%%'7(

 ( 06IC0H0-*2-) *-* H   *0  ( G  *06  >0 I) 0* < .-**01(#,($ 7-.---* *>019'&&E-(K!7(

  I-26.).00-=-0060 *0H0 0/.H00**0>0?*6 0<C?8</=*0*C0.( /.6 0C*00H*-.-0C00*.- 00  (  -6  0 8  /--0     0  -  0? 08 -?   =6 =-0H  *.C?(

  *H68C<>.(

$(   *>  0 0  =-006 0  0>>00  80 0  /0>00/...( 060C*=.0=-000?0=(

"$%&%"!%%# K"# 

  /.H00**0>0?*(

 ( 9 /0 !! 0* $ G6 0 /  *0. C*  ./)6H0</0*0/*C0.80 0..*060N/=-0O0>0--<-0(

 C( 9 /0 !' 0* ! G6   /C  /*C0.6 0 0 *0?  .-L .-*  00   806 H0 .  -C00*  /=-00(  *-  .-. -* -  - -00- < /=-00  < /0.0  /*C0.  /.-0.801(!'($G7(

 (  H  -5  0 -*00 0.-. H 0 / *0 *0.C*.*/)6/=-080>0--<-0 1:*.0* 06'&F,-(K!%&76..00D  05*.@H0</0*0/*C0.   80 0..*0@6 - C0 -*0 H  -C00*  /=-00 <00.0*C0. 1:*.0* 06'&FE-(#K!#7(

   /-26   *-  /00  :( :;;;;;; H0 / - --*-0H0*C/-C0( 60  0 /=0 / C? M  0 <  >.  /*C0.60/.00.-L(

  *H6/.**8C.0>0?*(

K(  <=.0H0*/.0>0?*(

 ( 9/0EK0*'G6*-.-0>0?. .0008 GJ'%%( < GJ#%/%%%( (

 C( >0=.06/.00050/?-80 /--*00 1 "'#$"!%%,  !! . !%%,   *>* 0*7(  5000  *    H/  /=2(  *-. -  0*06?80*>*H0>0..0 -  -00-   --00* 1:*.0  *   06'&F,-(K!E,7(

 (  . .0008    -*6   02  -.   00? 0.  . 00 - H  .-*.0008-.020-.0=0( /0HH0*-0.00080)>0=*.- -00-?**=*?00-*1 "K,$"!%%#$'+!%%#4 ( :6 0 .000>3   .000>   P6 8( !6  !%%!6 D( '(K(,(,6 -( '$& 4 (   9(  G9 6 9DQ0R0D

"$%&%"!%%# ,"# 

9>D 3 ?.0 R?  9>CS06  6 #2. *006 T0D!%%%6-($E7( 8/0'0*!0-*?80 !%-.C'&K'1  K%,760M0>0--000-00 ?**-*!'*.C'&$E19 $''(%76 *8=-0-*8-*?0</0!K(

  /-26*5<>0/C500.0008 -800/0!!G(

   9  /  - 80*  -00-   --00*  0>0? . GJ$/!%%( H0..0H02.0>0(

  *H6./.50>0*(

,(  02. . >*6     5*4  *..  GJ'/%%%( .0<D?6H0.C1(FE 7( UUUUU

'$ )        

*+,-!.

*8C05*!F+!%%#-:0 ;;;;;; *00*-./*.0*!,50!%%#4

,-.

54

.<D?*.. GJ'/%%%( 4

..0H  -* ) < :0 ;;;;;; 00 H/ *-.  /*.0*(

90*?3 :.8M6-*06:(MD26:( D*06:.G06 5?(







"$%&%"!%%# #"# 

. 0C.000>3

?>>02 505(3  80 -*03     :( 0 (8M  

-0>.)**..0H*=-0(

 286  ?>>023           

"$%&%"!%%#