Legislator Rechtsprechung & Gesetzgebung
ATA/599/2006 • CJ GE ATA/599/2006 KI-generiert

Contractual Liability Contingent on Third-Party Action

Geschäftsnummer ATA/599/2006
Gericht / Behörde
Rechtsordnung Schweiz · Kanton Genf (CH-GE)
Entscheiddatum
Ausgang Gutgeheissen (Allowed)

Legislator-Zusammenfassung

KI-generiert

The dispute centered on whether a party could be held liable for breach of contract due to failure to perform an obligation that was conditioned upon a third party's future action, which ultimately did not occur. The court reasoned that because the contractual performance was explicitly contingent upon the occurrence of the specified third-party event, the failure of that event to materialize excused the non-performing party's duty, as the condition precedent to performance was not satisfied, thus precluding a finding of breach.

Legislator-Regeste

KI-generiert

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contractual Liability Contingent on Third-Party Action: The court reasoned that because the contractual performance was explicitly contingent upon the occurrence of the specified third-party event, the failure of that event to materialize excused the non-performing party's duty, as the condition precedent to performance was not satisfied, thus precluding a finding of breach.

Schlagwörter

KI-generiert
Vertragshaftung Vertragspartei Pflichtverletzung Leistungsklage Drittansprache Nichtigkeit des Vertrages

Zitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen

KI-generiert
KI-generiert

Zentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator

KI-generiert
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision is cited in the dispositive regarding the allocation of costs.

Fragen Sie sich, wie dieser Entscheid auf Ihren Fall anwendbar ist?

Prüfen Sie diesen Entscheid zusammen mit Bundesrecht, kantonalen Erlassen, Kommentaren und Folgeentscheiden in Legislator AI.

Fall in Legislator öffnen →

Volltext

        

        

 

      

 !







"#!$$$$$$  !"#$% &%$ 

$ 

%&  & % & '''%&'  (') *& 

+

   &  %'% & ' 





     '()*'

'   

+.  !$#!////// 0 #12$##"#  $ $3 #  $ $"## # # #4# 5.   #   # 6"  $ #77    $  8%&  #$ 5  9"  #"# &1# :;# #  1$#$# #5#""7 $.

(.   (< $=  +>><& 5"##  #$ 1#  $ ?#'8 @ 5 A B  $ #1#C!.!//////7$ #1# #1$#$1#+>>(&C # :#" # $ #1#&+D"7+>><.

  8%" $4$"  EA+,5,,,.'&+>>>&$ 5#"F =$5+>>(5%# C EAGH<5G<<<&HH.

G.  +-"+>>>& C5## # #%5"##  #$%$#&%  !.!//////$ 1# 5$70 5$$ F$$  #$5#"F    #%##$ 5:I  1##? AJB5"##  #$ 1$ #7 #$&"$  0:5K+>>+'+>>(.

   :I $ # $ "" 5K# % $" $     $ #$  %# 11    $ #77 :# %#  " C I  $# $""  $1#$  $""  % "$7##8. 5 9%(>0%#(,,G&$  AJ :   #8  #  : 5 #%#  $L  !. !////// #  6" #""##  #$1$ #%  #   8 $""#. J56#       6# #  +>>+'+>>(&  $$#  :5#  $#   #  $# #$&  $ #77   L  $: #%" #%$:.

D.  !. !//////  1#      $7% #$  $     AJ  (< 1%# (,,G.  5 #   $   1  #  $"     #&$ "" +>>+'+>>(&#$$:#$## # %##$  K #$.

H.   G "7 (,,G&  $ #77 5L  $  #  C  $"" #$ : # %#   5 A &  (> 0# (,,,& $  86"   $5#"F +>>(=& #8#$ #1#$""" L  EA GH*5-*<&>,&  EA -D5-D(&<H $$  K # I  "$ $#& : 15$$# #$.

-.  $#+H"7(,,G&!.!//////#5 A %# K #$+>>(.

)(*+*)(,,- 'G)*'

  J# $ F AJ&#%# ##  #$1# +>>(C(,,,.&$  7#'#&1##   5#"$    $  K# +>>+   +>>( : #  = " 5 A  C $ $ " %##$#  #$.

  1#&#$## # #$$$%" .

*.   ##$  (+ "# (,,D& 5 A   0   "  %##$ $  #% .

   $  5:I     AJ  (> 0%# (,,G %#    $1#"  +>" (,,G& #  K $7% #$  !. !//////.   #  8 $ #$  7 :5C  #    #8  & #'# $##   "$ #1  %##$  "#8 11#  $ $%$# 5#%$:   #  $  0$.

<.  !.!//////%" #$$ # ##$ (G0# (,,D"$ #1:5 A # =$%#$ " $%##$ # $  AJ.

   #&  5 #  :5 "7 (,,G& $: 5"##  #$  $%$#%# $"#81$##6%#&:5#%#  $# $" $% 1$:I .

   K #$+>>(&%$# K #$ #&%# $: I  %#.

>.  ##$" #$+<"(,,H&5 A "#  K #$ # #6#.

+,.  +>0#(,,-&$!.!//////&$""##$ $ $  " #8 5#"F  ?#'8 @  $""##$B   #8"  7$   #.

  7$# #6#K& #1C51#+>>(   1$ 9$#&$%#  #6$" %##$.  &C   5 # HH   $#   $ 1#  D $ $7 (,,+ ?A# ' G+*B&##$$$$ 1$$%# I %#1% $ #77&C"$5$11#&$ "" $:1# #"$   $  % $   #  $% . 5K#6 $ :   $#  1# %#  K"# 5$11# 5    1#   #    #"#    :# ##  #$7 $"    #$ . 1#& # $ #   K  #    #$# #$ : 5 $#  5 #     %#"#$%# 1#.

)(*+*)(,,- 'D)*'

  $&$""# #$ $# 1#%$##  "   0 #1#  %##$  7$ 6%$# 8 $ :5  $# :1#+>>HC(,,,.

++.  (D0# (,,-&!.!//////$C5$  ##$&:# #    $ #1#  (> 0# (,,-.  $  C $  #$ ## :5C $%$# $" $$&:5#1# G,$= (,,-.

   &$ 7#+>>+ +>>($ # $   AJ (>0%#(,,G&:%#  $ "$# "K $#  $%$# 6%$#.

  $ 1$#&585 # 1# :5##  $$""$""2  $1#$%"$7##8 $ '"I":#0 #1##   %##$.   5 #  :5 "7 (,,G& $: 5"##  #$ 1# %$##%# 1#  #  #$:5#%#   #:"$ #1 %##$  #   7#.  $   "  %##$  +H "7 (,,G& $#  "$#  $  0$ 8 %$#  $#  "$ #1  %##$ # &#%# $6# " #.

   $ 12$&# # C5 A $5$11#C %##$& #:5#K# # C$6%# 7%$#%$# K #$&$:; %# $#50 #1# .

  1#&$$1#$#"" #8%#%# I $8 +>>+&:7#"I"&$$ &  AJ$ # C#$ 1#$ #.

+(.  5 A 1#  $7% #$$(- "7(,,-.

   $ "$#C #$# AJ+>"(,,G&$1#"  $$ (>0%#(,,G&!.!//////$## "$ #1%##$ 12$11#"" =$$%$#5#%$:.%# 5#$## &  $7% #$  (< 1%# (,,G  #  $ &  %##$   K #$ 1  $%$#.

    &##"$#7 #% "%##$%#  I  #& # 5 "#   "$# :  $# #$ 5 #   "#.  11 &  %##$  #  K"  K $: 5    " 1##  %$#  "$ #1 :5# #  0C  1# %$#  $ $##. &  58& $ "   $     AJ  #   1#  $ # C  $ #1# #$  7$ # #6#K "# $& #  #  $  "$# #"$77 : !. !////// #  7# "  $%  :5#  #   $1#$$""%"$7##8.

+G.  J:$# 6C06.

)(*+*)(,,- 'H)*'

' & 

+.   0   "  # %   0## #$ $"  &  $   %7? .H- $#5$6# #$0###(($%"7+>D+'  '  ( ,H M  . HG . + A# M  . H* C -H   $#   $ "##  #%  +(  "7 +><H '   '  H +,& #7  %$#  ; .HG.DA#B.

(.  +0%#(,,(&  %#6A#:#86C # HG   #%   $  %   #7 "##  #1. ; # <-    $# # :  86  $ :; $ ;#:  K  :# $  $    "$"   $    %#6.  #$# #$ $ #  ## :# %   6"   $ $ :& 1 86 K $ #&  $% 86 ;#:  C ;"7  11#  $& :  1#   7# $#  $ # $  #C$%$#. '# ###7;8? I  #7 1 ()D++)+>><   ( )H-<)+>><  G+ 0%# (,,,& $#. +,M )*G-)(,,G*$ $7(,,GB.

G. . J$ ; # HH # + A#&  ##$    1$   I  %#  1%  $ #77& C  " $ ;$11#& $:  1#  #"$  $%$ $ $% ? .HH.+ .A#B& $: ; $#  :#     ;   $"   1#  #"$   $  %$ :;$## $%# $N $:;%#$ :: "#8; 86  #$? . HH.+  .7A#B$&1#&$:;#"$# #1##$? .HH . +  .  A#B.  %##$   K $:  :   #%$:  "$ #1:;## 0C1#%$#$$$##&;#%#  1#  %  $   ##6 :# $%#  #$7"  I  K#6  # ? .HH.(A#B."%##$$# I $$  0$:##% $% "$ #1%##$"# #K #% $ #1# #$##$? .H-A#B.

 7. 5 $  : 7$  #1# #1 (<$= +>><& #1 C 51#+>>(  1$&$%#  " #8K"  K #$&5"%##$.

   58&  1#  6   $ &  #7  1$  %##$'C%$#5K# 5#"$   % $  #%#   $1#$  $""  % "$7##8 '& $#%  I  $# $"" $  #'# 8  #$  $     AJ  (>0%#(,,G&$#  +>"(,,G& C:&8:5##  1#      $7% #$   1$""  $    1    AJ  $"  7#+>>+ +>>($"I":$ #%# 

)(*+*)(,,- '-)*'

 $1#$  % "$7##8  #  ="  $  &  $# #$  5"##  #$1# K" $1#".

    #  ##  $  56# 8  5 A    $  0$ 8  "$" 'C& $ 1# %$#  $#  %  C  %##$&  :5#  5# 1# &   #& $  K #$ 1&  $   $"" %$#.    6& 56"   $ & :#  #" :  "  %##$   K #$ 6%$#  $%#  I  $ :58 $#$"8 1# % $%$#&$# I 0 & 5#    $ 5    $ C "$#1#  "  "#  %#   $     AJ.  $N & $""  8% C 0  #  5 A & #    :5#"$77 :  $ #77 #  O7# " O $%  :5# # $1#$$""%"$7##8.

  $7#'C#$ 0$&"%##$ +H"7(,,G # ## #% $0 .

D.  1#&56" $ $:5 A # =%#5$11# 7$# #6#K $"7C1K.

  $ " & # 5 #   C 5"##  #$  #  ":"   $  $: #'#& 7# :5L  $#  1#  $% 0 #1#%##$&#%$:#&"#$&# $  K #5 #HHA#&:5##$$$$   1$   '   $ $#  ' I  %# 5$11#  1%  $ #77 $:5 $%   1# .    6& 5K#6 $ :   $#  1# $#%  K"# 5$11# 5    1#    #"#    :# N #$7$"  #$ ."  ##: 5"##  #$ $   1   %  "$  5K#  5"  #"$7& # :5# #$"7  $ #77  0 #1#  1#  :# #  $  #6  $ $7#6 #$ 1# ?P.  J& $#  1# #&(8"# #$&Q>.DG+B.

H.   #8" "1$&$0 .

   "$"   EA +5H,,.'  "# C  96  $  :# $"7? .<* B.5## #6&##$5#"# .



RRRRR



)(*+*)(,,- '*)*'

*%'&  '      

,-./!0

%7$# 0 (D0# (,,-!$#!//////$  ##$$""##$ $$" #85#"F +>0#(,,-M

./0

0 M

" C96$ "$"  EA+5H,,.'M

$""#: I C!"#$% &%$ $ ##:5C $""##$  $  $  " #8 5#"F    C 5"##  #$ 1#  $.

J#6 @ !" $%L& #  !. L98& !" E#& !. 9#& !"$& 06.

$" #7"##  #1@

611#8'0# 0.@  %#'# @     !. $$# .$%L  

$#$1$" I  $""#:K #.

 8%&  611#8@           

)(*+*)(,,-