Contractual Liability Contingent on Third-Party Action
Legislator-Zusammenfassung
KI-generiertThe dispute centered on whether a party could be held liable for breach of contract due to failure to perform an obligation that was conditioned upon a third party's future action, which ultimately did not occur. The court reasoned that because the contractual performance was explicitly contingent upon the occurrence of the specified third-party event, the failure of that event to materialize excused the non-performing party's duty, as the condition precedent to performance was not satisfied, thus precluding a finding of breach.
Legislator-Regeste
KI-generiertArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contractual Liability Contingent on Third-Party Action: The court reasoned that because the contractual performance was explicitly contingent upon the occurrence of the specified third-party event, the failure of that event to materialize excused the non-performing party's duty, as the condition precedent to performance was not satisfied, thus precluding a finding of breach.
Schlagwörter
KI-generiertZitierte Gesetzesbestimmungen
KI-generiertVerwandte Entscheide
KI-generiertZentrale Rechtsfragen, extrahiert von Legislator
KI-generiertThis provision is cited in the dispositive regarding the allocation of costs.
Volltext
!
"#!$$$$$$ !"#$% &%$
$
%& & % & '''%&' (') *&
+
& %'% & '
'()*'
'
+. !$#!////// 0 #12$##"# $ $3 # $ $"## # # #4# 5. # # 6" $ #77 $ 8%& #$ 5 9" #"# &1# :;# # 1$#$# #5#""7 $.
(. (< $= +>><& 5"## #$ 1# $ ?#'8 @ 5 A B $ #1#C!.!//////7$ #1# #1$#$1#+>>(&C # :#" # $ #1#&+D"7+>><.
8%" $4$" EA+,5,,,.'&+>>>&$ 5#"F =$5+>>(5%# C EAGH<5G<<<&HH.
G. +-"+>>>& C5## # #%5"## #$%$#&% !.!//////$ 1# 5$70 5$$ F$$ #$5#"F #%##$ 5:I 1##? AJB5"## #$ 1$ #7 #$&"$ 0:5K+>>+'+>>(.
:I $ # $ "" 5K# % $" $ $ #$ %# 11 $ #77 :# %# " C I $# $"" $1#$ $"" % "$7##8. 5 9%(>0%#(,,G&$ AJ : #8 # : 5 #%# $L !. !////// # 6" #""## #$1$ #% # 8 $""#. J56# 6# # +>>+'+>>(& $$# :5# $# # $# #$& $ #77 L $: #%" #%$:.
D. !. !////// 1# $7% #$ $ AJ (< 1%# (,,G. 5 # $ 1 # $" #&$ "" +>>+'+>>(&#$$:#$## # %##$ K #$.
H. G "7 (,,G& $ #77 5L $ # C $"" #$ : # %# 5 A & (> 0# (,,,& $ 86" $5#"F +>>(=& #8#$ #1#$""" L EA GH*5-*<&>,& EA -D5-D(&<H $$ K # I "$ $#& : 15$$# #$.
-. $#+H"7(,,G&!.!//////#5 A %# K #$+>>(.
)(*+*)(,,- 'G)*'
J# $ F AJ&#%# ## #$1# +>>(C(,,,.&$ 7#'#&1## 5#"$ $ K# +>>+ +>>( : # = " 5 A C $ $ " %##$# #$.
1#&#$## # #$$$%" .
*. ##$ (+ "# (,,D& 5 A 0 " %##$ $ #% .
$ 5:I AJ (> 0%# (,,G %# $1#" +>" (,,G& # K $7% #$ !. !//////. # 8 $ #$ 7 :5C # #8 & #'# $## "$ #1 %##$ "#8 11# $ $%$# 5#%$: # $ 0$.
<. !.!//////%" #$$ # ##$ (G0# (,,D"$ #1:5 A # =$%#$ " $%##$ # $ AJ.
#& 5 # :5 "7 (,,G& $: 5"## #$ $%$#%# $"#81$##6%#&:5#%# $# $" $% 1$:I .
K #$+>>(&%$# K #$ #&%# $: I %#.
>. ##$" #$+<"(,,H&5 A "# K #$ # #6#.
+,. +>0#(,,-&$!.!//////&$""##$ $ $ " #8 5#"F ?#'8 @ $""##$B #8" 7$ #.
7$# #6#K& #1C51#+>>( 1$ 9$#&$%# #6$" %##$. &C 5 # HH $# $ 1# D $ $7 (,,+ ?A# ' G+*B&##$$$$ 1$$%# I %#1% $ #77&C"$5$11#&$ "" $:1# #"$ $ % $ # $% . 5K#6 $ : $# 1# %# K"# 5$11# 5 1# # #"# :# ## #$7 $" #$ . 1#& # $ # K # #$# #$ : 5 $# 5 # %#"#$%# 1#.
)(*+*)(,,- 'D)*'
$&$""# #$ $# 1#%$## " 0 #1# %##$ 7$ 6%$# 8 $ :5 $# :1#+>>HC(,,,.
++. (D0# (,,-&!.!//////$C5$ ##$&:# # $ #1# (> 0# (,,-. $ C $ #$ ## :5C $%$# $" $$&:5#1# G,$= (,,-.
&$ 7#+>>+ +>>($ # $ AJ (>0%#(,,G&:%# $ "$# "K $# $%$# 6%$#.
$ 1$#&585 # 1# :5## $$""$""2 $1#$%"$7##8 $ '"I":#0 #1## %##$. 5 # :5 "7 (,,G& $: 5"## #$ 1# %$##%# 1# # #$:5#%# #:"$ #1 %##$ # 7#. $ " %##$ +H "7 (,,G& $# "$# $ 0$ 8 %$# $# "$ #1 %##$ # &#%# $6# " #.
$ 12$&# # C5 A $5$11#C %##$& #:5#K# # C$6%# 7%$#%$# K #$&$:; %# $#50 #1# .
1#&$$1#$#"" #8%#%# I $8 +>>+&:7#"I"&$$ & AJ$ # C#$ 1#$ #.
+(. 5 A 1# $7% #$$(- "7(,,-.
$ "$#C #$# AJ+>"(,,G&$1#" $$ (>0%#(,,G&!.!//////$## "$ #1%##$ 12$11#"" =$$%$#5#%$:.%# 5#$## & $7% #$ (< 1%# (,,G # $ & %##$ K #$ 1 $%$#.
&##"$#7 #% "%##$%# I #& # 5 "# "$# : $# #$ 5 # "#. 11 & %##$ # K" K $: 5 " 1## %$# "$ #1 :5# # 0C 1# %$# $ $##. & 58& $ " $ AJ # 1# $ # C $ #1# #$ 7$ # #6#K "# $& # # $ "$# #"$77 : !. !////// # 7# " $% :5# # $1#$$""%"$7##8.
+G. J:$# 6C06.
)(*+*)(,,- 'H)*'
' &
+. 0 " # % 0## #$ $" & $ %7? .H- $#5$6# #$0###(($%"7+>D+' ' ( ,H M . HG . + A# M . H* C -H $# $ "## #% +( "7 +><H ' ' H +,& #7 %$# ; .HG.DA#B.
(. +0%#(,,(& %#6A#:#86C # HG #% $ % #7 "## #1. ; # <- $# # : 86 $ :; $ ;#: K :# $ $ "$" $ %#6. #$# #$ $ # ## :# % 6" $ $ :& 1 86 K $ #& $% 86 ;#: C ;"7 11# $& : 1# 7# $# $ # $ #C$%$#. '# ###7;8? I #7 1 ()D++)+>>< ( )H-<)+>>< G+ 0%# (,,,& $#. +,M )*G-)(,,G*$ $7(,,GB.
G. . J$ ; # HH # + A#& ##$ 1$ I %# 1% $ #77& C " $ ;$11#& $: 1# #"$ $%$ $ $% ? .HH.+ .A#B& $: ; $# :# ; $" 1# #"$ $ %$ :;$## $%# $N $:;%#$ :: "#8; 86 #$? . HH.+ .7A#B$&1#&$:;#"$# #1##$? .HH . + . A#B. %##$ K $: : #%$: "$ #1:;## 0C1#%$#$$$##&;#%# 1# % $ ##6 :# $%# #$7" I K#6 # ? .HH.(A#B."%##$$# I $$ 0$:##% $% "$ #1%##$"# #K #% $ #1# #$##$? .H-A#B.
7. 5 $ : 7$ #1# #1 (<$= +>><& #1 C 51#+>>( 1$&$%# " #8K" K #$&5"%##$.
58& 1# 6 $ & #7 1$ %##$'C%$#5K# 5#"$ % $ #%# $1#$ $"" % "$7##8 '& $#% I $# $"" $ #'# 8 #$ $ AJ (>0%#(,,G&$# +>"(,,G& C:&8:5## 1# $7% #$ 1$"" $ 1 AJ $" 7#+>>+ +>>($"I":$ #%#
)(*+*)(,,- '-)*'
$1#$ % "$7##8 # =" $ & $# #$ 5"## #$1# K" $1#".
# ## $ 56# 8 5 A $ 0$ 8 "$" 'C& $ 1# %$# $# % C %##$& :5# 5# 1# & #& $ K #$ 1& $ $"" %$#. 6& 56" $ & :# #" : " %##$ K #$ 6%$# $%# I $ :58 $#$"8 1# % $%$#&$# I 0 & 5# $ 5 $ C "$#1# " "# %# $ AJ. $N & $"" 8% C 0 # 5 A & # :5#"$77 : $ #77 # O7# " O $% :5# # $1#$$""%"$7##8.
$7#'C#$ 0$&"%##$ +H"7(,,G # ## #% $0 .
D. 1#&56" $ $:5 A # =%#5$11# 7$# #6#K $"7C1K.
$ " & # 5 # C 5"## #$ # ":" $ $: #'#& 7# :5L $# 1# $% 0 #1#%##$&#%$:#&"#$&# $ K #5 #HHA#&:5##$$$$ 1$ ' $ $# ' I %# 5$11# 1% $ #77 $:5 $% 1# . 6& 5K#6 $ : $# 1# $#% K"# 5$11# 5 1# #"# :# N #$7$" #$ ." ##: 5"## #$ $ 1 % "$ 5K# 5" #"$7& # :5# #$"7 $ #77 0 #1# 1# :# # $ #6 $ $7#6 #$ 1# ?P. J& $# 1# #&(8"# #$&Q>.DG+B.
H. #8" "1$&$0 .
"$" EA +5H,,.' "# C 96 $ :# $"7? .<* B.5## #6&##$5#"# .
RRRRR
)(*+*)(,,- '*)*'
*%'& '
,-./!0
%7$# 0 (D0# (,,-!$#!//////$ ##$$""##$ $$" #85#"F +>0#(,,-M
./0
0 M
" C96$ "$" EA+5H,,.'M
$""#: I C!"#$% &%$ $ ##:5C $""##$ $ $ " #8 5#"F C 5"## #$ 1# $.
J#6 @ !" $%L& # !. L98& !" E#& !. 9#& !"$& 06.
$" #7"## #1@
611#8'0# 0.@ %#'# @ !. $$# .$%L
$#$1$" I $""#:K #.
8%& 611#8@
)(*+*)(,,-