Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
VSRS Sklep II DoR 378/2023 ECLI:SI:VSRS:2023:II.DOR.378.2023 AI generated

Supreme Court dismisses review application against a second-instance order rejecting a seizure request under ZIZ Art. 10.

Case Number VSRS Sklep II DoR 378/2023
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Slovenia (SI)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Supreme Court rejected the applicant's request for permission to file a review against a second-instance decision that dismissed a seizure application. The applicant had previously filed a request for a temporary order prohibiting contact in an improper case, which the first instance court partially granted but the second instance court upheld. The court ruled that Article 10 of the Enforcement and Security Act only permits review against specific orders rejecting seizure requests, not other procedural decisions, and since the challenged order did not conclude the proceedings under Article 384 of the Civil Procedure Act, the review was inadmissible.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 10 ZIZ; Art. 384 ZPP: Review is permitted only against specific orders rejecting seizure requests under Art. 10 ZIZ; other procedural orders in enforcement proceedings do not qualify for review.

Keywords

AI generated
enforcement proceedings seizure request review application ZIZ Article 10 ZPP Article 384 procedural order inadmissible review

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Art. 10 ZIZ
Art. 384 ZPP
Art. 377 ZPP
Art. 324 ZPP

Cited Case Law

AI generated
VSRS II DoR 400/2018
3 Glej tudi sklep VSRS II DoR 400/2018 z dne 10.
VSRS II DoR 490/2019
2019 in sklep VSRS II DoR 490/2019 z dne 19.
AI generated
VSRS Sklep II DoR 400/2018
Supreme Court dismisses appeal against interim order decision, ruling review not permitted under enforcement law.
VSL Sklep IV Cp 1762/2019
Appeal dismissed because the plaintiff filed the complaint after the statutory deadline expired.
VSRS Sklep Cp 20/2024
Appeal against correction order dismissed; appellant challenged main judgment content, not correction legality.
VSRS Sklep Cp 12/2021
Appeal against interim order in enforcement proceedings dismissed as appeal not permitted by law.
VSRS Sklep II Ips 78/2019
Direct appeal rejected for psychiatric facility admission without consent; prior permission required under ZPP. Direct appeal rejected for psychiatric facility admission without consent; prior permission required under ZPP.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

Predlog se zavrže.

[JEDRO]

Predlog se zavrže.

[OBRAZLOŽITEV]

1. Predlagateljica je v nepravdni zadevi III N 438/2021 vložila predlog za izdajo začasne odredbe za prepoved stikov. Sodišče prve stopnje je v delu ugodilo predlogu, pritožbeno sodišče pa je zavrnilo pritožbo nasprotnega udeleženca in potrdilo izpodbijani sklep.

2. Predlog ni dovoljen.

3. V skladu z določbo 10. člena Zakona o izvršbi in zavarovanju (v nadaljevanju ZIZ 1 ) je revizija (pod pogoji, ki jih določa Zakon o pravdnem postopku, v nadaljevanju ZPP 2 ) dovoljena zoper sklepe, izdane na drugi stopnji, s katerimi je pravnomočno odločeno, da se predlog za izvršbo zavrže ali zavrne. Revizijo je torej zakonodajalec omejil le na točno določene sklepe, izdane v postopkih izvršbe in zavarovanja in sicer na sklepe, s katerimi je zavržen ali zavrnjen predlog za izvršbo. To pomeni, da zoper druge sklepe, izdane v tovrstnih postopkih, revizija še vedno ni dovoljena.

4. Izpodbijani sklep tudi ni odločba s katero se je postopek pravnomočno končal v smislu prvega odstavka 384. člena ZPP. 3 Zato revizija zoper ta sklep ni dovoljena, s tem pa tudi ni dovoljen predlog za dopustitev revizije. Glede na to je Vrhovno sodišče predlog za dopustitev revizije zavrglo (377. člen ZPP).

5. Vrhovno sodišče je odločalo v senatu, ki je naveden v uvodu odločbe. Odločitev je sprejelo soglasno (sedmi odstavek 324. člena ZPP).

1 Uradni list RS, št. 3/07 s spremembami in dopolnitvami.

2 Uradni list RS, št. 26/99 s spremembami in dopolnitvami.

3 Glej tudi sklep VSRS II DoR 400/2018 z dne 10. 1. 2019 in sklep VSRS II DoR 490/2019 z dne 19. 12. 2019.