Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
Încheierea nr. 7709/2012 AI generated

Strămutare de competență: transfer of civil appeal jurisdiction between Courts of Appeal due to potential conflict of interest or local pressure

Case Number Încheierea nr. 7709/2012
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Romania (RO)
Decision Date
Outcome Allowed / Granted
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

The High Court of Cassation and Justice admitted the petition for a change of venue, ordering the transfer of civil case no. 502/64/2012 from the Brașov Court of Appeal to the Târgu Mureș Court of Appeal, while preserving all previously completed procedural acts; the decision is final and without further appeal. The dispute involved a group of plaintiffs seeking to have their civil proceedings moved from the Brașov Court of Appeal to another jurisdiction, which the opposing defendant argued should be rejected, but the public prosecutor supported the transfer. The decisive legal basis was the court's assessment of the petition for *strămutare* (change of venue) under Romanian civil procedure codes, which grants the High Court the authority to reassign jurisdiction to ensure impartiality or operational necessity when requested by the parties, leading to the mandatory transfer to the specified alternative appellate court.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Strămutare de competență: transfer of civil appeal jurisdiction between Courts of Appeal due to potential conflict of interest or local pressure: 502/64/2012 from the Brașov Court of Appeal to the Târgu Mureș Court of Appeal, while preserving all previously completed procedural acts; the decision is final and without further appeal. The dispute involved a group of plaintiffs seeking to have their civil proceedings moved from the Brașov Court of Appeal to another jurisdiction, which the opposing defendant argued should be rejected, but the public prosecutor supported the transfer. The decisive legal basis was the court's assessment of the petition for *strămutare* (change of venue) under Romanian civil procedure codes, which grants the High Court the authority to reassign jurisdiction to ensure impartiality or operational necessity when requested by the parties, leading to the mandatory transfer to the specified alternative appellate court.

Keywords

AI generated
alternative jurisdiction conflict of jurisdiction Civil Procedure Code local authority transfer of competence procedural orders
AI generated
ICCJ_92663
Transfer of civil case jurisdiction: Competence determination under appeal court transfer (strămutare) procedures
ICCJ_80021
Transfer of jurisdiction of civil case between courts of appeal
ICCJ_89251
Transfer of jurisdiction from Brașov to Târgu Mureș court of appeal granted for civil case
ICCJ_102126
Transfer of jurisdiction (strămutare) of civil case between courts of appeal
ICCJ_106181
Transfer of civil appeal from one court of appeal to another

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

S-a luat în examinare cererea de strămutare formulată petenții A.V., A.M., A.A., A.G., B.V., V.B., B.E., B.S., B.G., B.V.A., B.F., C.L., C.D., C.M., C.F., C.C.N., C.I., C.M., C.V., D.G., D.O.N., D.E., D.M.C., D.E.A., D.I., D.D.S., D.E., D.M., D.I., D.M.A., E.A., E.F., F.I., F.I., F.I., F.G., G.M., G.V.D., G.C.A., G.C., G.I.L., H.I., I.L., I.M., J.A.L., L.A., L.G., L.N.M., M.V.R., M.D., M.E., M.M., M.M.A., M.V., M.D., M.M.B., M.M.C., M.A., M.G., M.M.E., N.G., N.I.E., N.P., N.G.A., O.A., P.I.L., P.G.L., R.F., R.M., R.A., S.V., S.M., S.V.C., S.I., S.E., I.S., S.I.A., S.G.A., S.T.D., S.M.A., T.M.I., Ț.E., T.G., U.C., V.D.

La apelul nominal se prezintă intimata SC O.M.V.P. SA, prin avocat L.P., lipsind petenții.

Ministerul Public este reprezentat de procuror Ș.S.

Procedura legal îndeplinită.

Se referă de magistratul asistent asupra faptului că, potrivit programului de evidență informatizată a instanțelor Dosarul nr. 502/64/2012 al Curții de Apel Brașov, a cărui strămutare se solicită, are termen de judecată la data de 7 ianuarie 2013.

Reprezentantul intimatei SC O.M.V.P. SA, pune concluzii de respingere a cererii de strămutare.

Procurorul solicită admiterea cererii de strămutare.

Analizând cererea,

ÎNALTA CURTE

ÎN NUMELE LEGII

D I S P U N E

Admite cererea formulată de petenții A.V., A.M., A.A., A.G., B.V., V.B., B.E., B.S., B.G., B.V.A., B.F., C.L., C.D., C.M., C.F., C.C.N., C.I., C.M., C.V., D.G., D.O.N., D.E., D.M.C., D.E.A., D.I., D.D.S., D.E., D.M., D.I., D.M.A., E.A., E.F., F.I., F.I., F.I., F.G., G.M., G.V.D., G.C.A., G.C., G.I.L., H.I., I.L., I.M., J.A.L., L.A., L.G., L.N.M., M.V.R., M.D., M.E., M.M., M.M.A., M.V., M.D., M.M.B., M.M.C., M.A., M.G., M.M.E., N.G., N.I.E., N.P., N.G.A., O.A., P.I.L., P.G.L., R.F., R.M., R.A., S.V., S.M., S.V.C., S.I., S.E., I.S., S.I.A., S.G.A., S.T.D., S.M.A., T.M.I., Ț.E., T.G., U.C., V.D. privind strămutarea procesului civil ce formează obiectul Dosarului nr. 502/64/2012 al Curții de Apel Brașov.

Strămută judecata cauzei de la Curtea de Apel Brașov la Curtea de Apel Târgu Mureș.

Păstrează actele de procedură îndeplinite.

Fără cale de atac.

Pronunțată în ședință publică astăzi, 14 decembrie 2012.