Legislator Case Law & Legislation
0210302 AI generated

Portuguese court rules no abstract hierarchy exists for substitute prison penalties, requiring concrete assessment based on special prevention needs.

Case Number 0210302
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Portugal (PT)
Decision Date
Outcome Partially Allowed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Tribunal da Relação do Porto partially allowed the appeal regarding the substitution of prison sentences. The appellant argued that substitute penalties lack a clear legal hierarchy, while the lower court had applied a rigid ranking. The court decided that no abstract hierarchy exists; instead, the choice of penalty must be determined concretely based on the specific requirements of special prevention and social reintegration in each case.

Legislator headnote

Official

PENA DE PRISÃO SUBSTITUIÇÃO DA PENA PREVENÇÃO ESPECIAL REINSERÇÃO SOCIAL

Keywords

AI generated
substitute prison penalties special prevention requirements social reintegration needs concrete legal assessment hierarchy of punishments

Cited Legislation

AI generated
CP 95 Art. 30
CP 95 Art. 50
CP 95 Art. 58

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

[DATA DEC. RECORRIDA] 11/15/2001

[Nº CONVENCIONAL] JTRP00033585

[Nº DO DOCUMENTO] RP200205220210302

[PRIVACIDADE] 1

[PROCESSO NO TRIBUNAL RECORRIDO] 233/01

[TEXTO INTEGRAL] N

[TRIBUNAL RECORRIDO] 3 J CR GUIMARÃES

[URL] https://www.dgsi.pt/jtrp.nsf/56a6e7121657f91e80257cda00381fdf/7F16C01DC32222F980256C440031067C?OpenDocument

SUMÁRIO

Não existe em abstracto uma hierarquia legal das penas de substituição, antes, só em concreto, em função das exigências de prevenção especial e de socialização que no caso se façam sentir e da forma mais adequada de as satisfazer, deve ser proferida decisão em conformidade.