Legislator Case Law & Legislation
01282/12 AI generated

No opposition of precedents exists when different legal solutions arise from distinct factual realities and different applicable laws.

Case Number 01282/12
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Portugal (PT)
Decision Date
Outcome Allowed / Granted

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the opposition of precedents raised by the Public Prosecutor against the lower court's judgment. The parties argued that conflicting rulings violated legal certainty, but the court found the cases involved distinct factual realities and different applicable legal norms. Consequently, the court held that no binding precedent opposition existed because the legal solutions differed due to the specific circumstances of each case.

Legislator headnote

Official

OPOSIÇÃO DE JULGADOS REQUISITOS

Keywords

AI generated
opposition of precedents legal certainty distinct factual realities different applicable laws binding precedent judicial inconsistency civil procedure code

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Art. 240.º do Código de Processo Civil

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

[Nº CONVENCIONAL] JSTA000P15910

[Nº DO DOCUMENTO] SAP2013060501282

[RECORRENTE] A......................

[RECORRIDO 1] FAZENDA PÚBLICA

[URL] https://www.dgsi.pt/jsta.nsf/35fbbbf22e1bb1e680256f8e003ea931/F7A0481EBDA337B280257BA300555434?OpenDocument

SUMÁRIO

Não se verifica oposição de julgados no caso de a diversidade das soluções jurídicas encontrada nos arestos em confronto não resultar de entendimento inconciliável quanto à mesma questão fundamental de direito, mas antes do enfrentamento de realidades fácticas distintas, que levaram à apreciação de questões jurídicas diversas à luz de normas também diferentes.