Legislator Case Law & Legislation
025552 AI generated

Implicit revocation of agrarian reform reservation acts creates a time-based incompetence defect. The court ruled that replacing a granted reservation area constitutes implicit revocation under the Administrative Law. Consequently, any subsequent act violating this rule is incompetent due to timing. The Supreme Administrative Court dismissed the appeal regarding the procedural defect. The court held that replacing a granted agrarian reservation area constitutes implicit revocation under the Administrative Law. Therefore, any subsequent act violating this rule is incompetent due to timing. The court dismissed the appeal regarding the procedural defect. The court held that replacing a granted agrarian reservation area constitutes implicit revocation under the Administrative Law. Therefore, any subsequent act violating this rule is incompetent due to timing. The court dismissed the appeal regarding the procedural defect.

Case Number 025552
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Portugal (PT)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Supreme Administrative Court dismissed the appeal regarding the implicit revocation of an agrarian reform reservation act. The appellant argued that a subsequent act replacing the reserved land area constituted an implicit revocation, rendering the new act incompetent due to timing. The court ruled that such replacement creates an implicit revocation subject to Article 18, paragraph 2, of the Administrative Law, thereby validating the incompetence finding.

Legislator headnote

Official

REFORMA AGRARIA ACTO CONSTITUTIVO DE DIREITOS INCOMPETENCIA EM RAZÃO DO TEMPO ACTO ATRIBUTIVO DE RESERVA REVOGAÇÃO IMPLICITA

Keywords

AI generated
agrarian reform reservation implicit revocation of acts incompetence due to timing administrative law principles substitution of reserved areas

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Lei n. 77/77, de 29/9
II - Como tal, sempre que um acto posterior substitua a area da reserva concedida pelo primeiro acto ao abrigo da Lei n. 77/77, de 29/9, por outra, estar-se-a em presença de um acto de revogação implicita sujeito ao regime estatuido no artigo 18, n.
L.O.S.T.A., art. 18, n. 2

Cited Case Law

AI generated
AC STA PROC24388 de 1988/12/15
[JURISPRUDENCIA NACIONAL] AC STA PROC24388 DE 1988/12/15.
AC STAPLENO PROC18933 de 1989/02/21
AC STAPLENO PROC18933 DE 1989/02/21.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

[AREA TEMATICA 1] DIR ADM ECON - REFORMA AGRARIA. DIR ADM CONT - ACTO.

[LEGISLACAO NACIONAL] L 77/77 DE 1977/09/29. LOSTA56 ART18 N2.

[JURISPRUDENCIA NACIONAL] AC STA PROC24388 DE 1988/12/15. AC STAPLENO PROC18933 DE 1989/02/21.

[ANO DA PUBLICACAO] 91

[DATA DE ENTRADA] 11/17/1987

[Nº CONVENCIONAL] JSTA00033341

[Nº DO DOCUMENTO] SA119911119025552

[OBJECTO] DESP MINAPA DE 1987/07/27.

[PRIVACIDADE] 01

[RECORRENTE] UCP AGRICOLA BOA ESPERANÇA DE LAVRE CRL

[RECORRIDO 1] MINAGR E OUTRO

[REFERENCIA A DOUTRINA] MARCELLO CAETANO MANUAL DE DIREITO ADMINISTRATIVO 10ED VI PAG540.

[REFERENCIA A PARECERES] P PGR 149/83 IN DR IIS 1984/03/20.

[URL] https://www.dgsi.pt/jsta.nsf/35fbbbf22e1bb1e680256f8e003ea931/978B8AF55F03703F802568FC0037F9B0?OpenDocument

SUMÁRIO

I - O acto atributivo de reserva, no ambito da Reforma Agraria, e acto constitutivo de direitos.

II - Como tal, sempre que um acto posterior substitua a area da reserva concedida pelo primeiro acto ao abrigo da Lei n. 77/77, de 29/9, por outra, estar-se-a em presença de um acto de revogação implicita sujeito ao regime estatuido no artigo 18, n. 2, da L.O.S.T.A..

III - Em consequencia, o acto posterior praticado em Violação do citado preceito legal padece de Vicio de Incompetencia em razão do tempo em que foi proferido.