Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
01406/04 AI generated

Supreme Administrative Court rules that lack of decision by an incompetent authority does not create a tacit denial of request.

Case Number 01406/04
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Portugal (PT)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Supreme Administrative Court dismissed the appeal regarding a tacit denial of a request submitted to an incompetent administrative body. The appellant argued that the authority's failure to decide constituted a tacit refusal, while the respondent contended that procedural inaction by an incompetent organ does not transfer jurisdiction. The court held that the formation of a tacit denial strictly requires the addressed authority to have a legal duty to decide, which was absent here.

Legislator headnote

Official

INDEFERIMENTO TÁCITO. DEVER LEGAL DE DECIDIR.

Keywords

AI generated
tacit denial formation legal duty to decide incompetent administrative authority procedural inaction jurisdictional transfer

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Art. 34 of the CPA
Art. 9 of the CPA
Art. 109 of the CPA
D. 52/94 of 09/03/1994

Cited Case Law

AI generated
AC STA PROC46436 DE 2000/11/09
AC STA PROC40487 DE 2001/05/09
AC STAPLENO PROC46925 DE 2003/05/08
AC STA PROC2080/03 DE 2004/10/06
AC STAPLENO PROC41130 DE 1999/12/07

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

[AREA TEMATICA 1] DIR ADM GER - FUNÇÃO PUBL / ESTATUTÁRIO.

[LEGISLACAO NACIONAL] CPA91 ART34 ART9 ART109. DREG 52/94 DE 1994/09/03 ART1 ART3 ART4 ART12 ART13 D.

[JURISPRUDENCIA NACIONAL] AC STA PROC46436 DE 2000/11/09.; AC STA PROC40487 DE 2001/05/09.; AC STAPLENO PROC46925 DE 2003/05/08.; AC STA PROC2080/03 DE 2004/10/06.; AC STAPLENO PROC41130 DE 1999/12/07.; AC STA PROC37593 DE 1998/10/01.; AC STA PROC45481 DE 2000/05/18.; AC STA PROC37319 DE 2001/10/03.; AC STA PROC46915 DE 2001/10/24.

[DATA DE ENTRADA] 12/21/2004

[Nº CONVENCIONAL] JSTA00062047

[Nº DO DOCUMENTO] SA12005042801406

[OBJECTO] AC TCA SUL DE 2004/07/08.

[RECORRENTE] A...

[RECORRIDO 1] GENERAL CEMFA

[REFERENCIA A PARECERES] P PGR 17/95 DE 1995/06/08.

[URL] https://www.dgsi.pt/jsta.nsf/35fbbbf22e1bb1e680256f8e003ea931/6A7AB04D7682DB5B80256FFC0054672D?OpenDocument

SUMÁRIO

I - A formação do indeferimento tácito pressupõe que o órgão da Administração a quem foi dirigida a pretensão tenha o dever legal do decidir.

II - O incumprimento, pelo órgão incompetente a quem foi dirigida essa pretensão dos deveres procedimentais impostos pelo art.º 34.º do C.P.A., não transforma esse órgão em competente