Legislator Case Law & Legislation
019070 AI generated

Administrative act dismissed for lack of reasoning regarding a third party's request incompatible with the deliberation.

Case Number 019070
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Portugal (PT)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Supreme Administrative Court dismissed the administrative act because it failed to provide adequate reasoning for its decision. The deliberation granted a request to one party while implicitly denying a separate request from another interested party, creating a contradiction. The court ruled that administrative acts must explicitly state the reasons for their specific outcome to ensure legal certainty and protect the rights of all affected parties.

Legislator headnote

Official

FUNDAMENTAÇÃO DO ACTO ADMINISTRATIVO FALTA DE FUNDAMENTAÇÃO

Keywords

AI generated
administrative act reasoning lack of justification third party rights implicit denial legal certainty principle

Cited Legislation

AI generated
CPC 67 Art. 659 n.º 2
DL 256-A/77 Art. 1 n.º 2

Cited Case Law

AI generated
AC STAP PROC13729 DE 1982/10/27
[JURISPRUDENCIA NACIONAL] AC STAP PROC13729 DE 1982/10/27.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

[AREA TEMATICA 1] DIR ADM GER.

[LEGISLACAO NACIONAL] CPC67 ART659 N2 ART668 N1 B. DL 256-A/77 DE 1977/06/17 ART1 A N2.

[JURISPRUDENCIA NACIONAL] AC STAP PROC13729 DE 1982/10/27.

[1ª PAG. DE PUBLICACAO DO ACORDAO] 3843

[ANO DA PUBLICACAO] 90

[APENDICE] DR

[DATA DE ENTRADA] 06/08/1983

[DATA DO APENDICE] 01/31/1995

[Nº CONVENCIONAL] JSTA00029616

[Nº DO DOCUMENTO] SA119900524019070

[OBJECTO] SENT AUDITORIA PORTO.

[PRIVACIDADE] 01

[RECORRENTE] CM DE VALENÇA - CRUZ , MANUEL

[RECORRIDO 1] CARVALHO , JOÃO

[URL] https://www.dgsi.pt/jsta.nsf/35fbbbf22e1bb1e680256f8e003ea931/020C3003C39C8B89802568FC0037DD84?OpenDocument

SUMÁRIO

I - A fundamentação do acto administrativo deve dar a conhecer, a um destinatario normal, as razões que levaram a autoridade decidente a pronunciar-se naquele preciso sentido e não noutro qualquer.

II - Não satisfaz essa exigencia a deliberação camararia que defere uma pretensão que lhe e dirigida, com o que fica prejudicado ou implicitamente indeferido um requerimento, incompativel com essa tomada de posição, apresentado por outro interessado.