Legislator Case Law & Legislation
000362 AI generated

Administrative courts lack jurisdiction over civil compensation claims against the state for judicial acts; judicial courts are competent.

Case Number 000362
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Portugal (PT)
Decision Date
Outcome Allowed / Granted

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Tribunal dos Conflitos declared the administrative court incompetent and assigned jurisdiction to the judicial court. The Ministry of Public Prosecution sought compensation from the state for damages arising from judicial acts, while the Tribunal Judicial de Bragança and TAC do Porto argued for their respective competencies. The court ruled that administrative courts cannot hear civil indemnity claims based on judicial acts, reserving such matters exclusively for judicial tribunals.

Legislator headnote

Official

CONFLITO NEGATIVO DE JURISDIÇÃO. RESPONSABILIDADE CIVIL. ESTADO. FUNÇÃO JUDICIAL. COMPETÊNCIA DOS TRIBUNAIS JUDICIAIS.

Keywords

AI generated
negative jurisdiction conflict judicial acts liability state compensation claims administrative court competence judicial court jurisdiction

Cited Legislation

AI generated
CPC Art. 66
ETAF Art. 3
ETAF Art. 4, N. 1, D
ETAF Art. 51, N. 1, H
Const. Art. 202
Const. Art. 205
Const. Art. 214, N. 3
Const. Art. 237
Const. Art. 266

Cited Case Law

AI generated
AC STAPLENO PROC31372 DE 1995/06/27
AC TCF PROC260 DE 1996/02/22
AC TCF PROC278 DE 1996/01/18
AC TCF PROC300 DE 1996/05/21
AC STA PROC32732 DE 1993/10/14
AC STA PROC25101 DE 1990/10/09
AC STA PROC31873 DE 1993/06/08
AC STA PROC39389 DE 1996/10/01
AC STA PROC43422 DE 1998/10/28
AC STA PROC43973 DE 1999/03/23
AC STJ DE 1987/06/11 IN BMJ N364 PAG494

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

[AREA TEMATICA 1] DIR ADM CONT.

[AREA TEMATICA 2] DIR CIV - DIR RESP CIV.

[LEGISLACAO NACIONAL] CPC96 ART66. ETAF96 ART3 ART4 N1 D F ART51 N1 H. CONST92 ART202 ART205 ART214 N3 ART237 ART266.

[JURISPRUDENCIA NACIONAL] AC STAPLENO PROC31372 DE 1995/06/27.; AC TCF PROC260 DE 1996/02/22.; AC TCF PROC278 DE 1996/01/18.; AC TCF PROC300 DE 1996/05/21.; AC STA PROC32732 DE 1993/10/14.; AC STA PROC25101 DE 1990/10/09.; AC STA PROC31873 DE 1993/06/08.; AC STA PROC39389 DE 1996/10/01.; AC STA PROC43422 DE 1998/10/28.; AC STA PROC43973 DE 1999/03/23.; AC STJ DE 1987/06/11 IN BMJ N364 PAG494.

[DATA DE ENTRADA] 09/20/2000

[Nº CONVENCIONAL] JSTA00055937

[Nº DO DOCUMENTO] SAC20010510000362

[OBJECTO] NEGATIVO JURISDIÇÃO TJ BRAGANÇA - TAC PORTO.

[RECORRENTE] MINISTÉRIO PÚBLICO

[RECORRIDO 1] TRIBUNAL JUDICIAL DE BRAGANÇA

[RECORRIDO 2] TAC DO PORTO

[URL] https://www.dgsi.pt/jcon.nsf/35fbbbf22e1bb1e680256f8e003ea931/4A8CB54881FD7A908025713B003B5A4E?OpenDocument

SUMÁRIO

Os tribunais administrativos são incompetentes para conhecer dos pedidos de indemnização dirigidos contra o Estado, fundados em danos emergentes de actos de natureza jurisdicional, incumbindo aos tribunais judiciais o conhecimento de tais pedidos.