Court dismisses administrative penalty case against judge due to conflict of interest and recusal. Judge E. L. is dismissed from the case due to conflict of interest. The court ruled that the presiding judge must recuse himself because he is also a judge in the criminal division, creating a conflict of interest under the Criminal Procedure Code. The court dismissed the administrative penalty case against the judge, E. L., due to a conflict of interest arising from his dual role as a presiding judge in the administrative case and a judge in the criminal division. The court decided to dismiss the case and transfer it to the court president because the presiding judge must recuse himself to ensure impartiality. The court dismissed the administrative penalty case against the judge, E. L., due to a conflict of interest arising from his dual role as a presiding judge in the administrative case and a judge in the criminal division. The court decided to dismiss the case and transfer it to the court president because the presiding judge must recuse himself to ensure impartiality.
Legislator summary
AI generatedThe court dismissed the administrative penalty case against judge E. L. due to a conflict of interest. E. L. was the presiding judge in the administrative case and simultaneously a judge in the criminal division, raising concerns about impartiality. Consequently, the court ordered the case to be transferred to the court president for further proceedings.
Legislator headnote
AI generatedLietuvos Respublikos BPK 58 straipsnio 1 dalies 4 punkto, 59 straipsnio 1 dalis: A judge must recuse themselves from a case where they hold another judicial position that could compromise their impartiality.
Keywords
AI generatedCited Legislation
AI generatedFull text
?KlaipÄdos rajono apylinkÄs teismo teisÄja EAdministracinio nusižengimo byla Nr. II-126-586/2021 Teisminio proceso Nr. 4-68-3-00069-2021-1 Procesinio sprendimo kategorija: 21.2.2. (S) KLAIPÄDOS APYLINKÄS TEISMAS N U T A R T I S 2021 m. sausio 27 d. Gargždai KlaipÄdos apylinkÄs teismo KlaipÄdos rajono rÅ«mų teisÄjas Vandalinas Vainius, raÅ¡ytinio proceso tvarka sprendÄ skundo priÄmimo klausimÄ dÄl 2020-12-09 Lietuvos Kelių policijos tarnybos nutarimo, administracinio nusižengimo byloje Nr. 39-ANR_N-11873-2020 (ROIK: 20124330679), n u s t a t Ä:
KlaipÄdos apylinkÄs teismo KlaipÄdos rajono rÅ«muose gautas administracinÄn atsakomybÄn patraukto asmens E. L. skundas dÄl 2020-12-09 Lietuvos Kelių policijos tarnybos nutarimo, administracinio nusižengimo byloje Nr. 39-ANR_N-11873-2020 panaikinimo ir pripažinimo įvykdytu administracinį nurodymÄ . Su administracinÄn atsakomybÄn patrauktu asmeniu esame dirbÄ KlaipÄdos rajono apylinkÄs teisme, be to E. L. dirba KlaipÄdos apygardos teismo baudžiamųjų bylų skyriaus teisÄja, o aÅ¡ apylinkÄs teismo teisÄju baudžiamųjų bylų skyriuje ir ji apeliacine tvarka nagrinÄja mano iÅ¡nagrinÄtas bylas.
Esant tokioms aplinkybÄms teisÄjas nusiÅ¡alina, kadangi kitiems proceso dalyviams gali kilti pagrįstų abejonių dÄl teisÄjo neÅ¡aliÅ¡kumo (Lietuvos Respublikos BPK 58 straipsnio 1 dalies 4 punkto, 59 straipsnio 1 dalis). Vadovaudamasis Lietuvos Respublikos ANK 576 straipsnio 2 dalimi teisÄjas, n u t a r i a : nusiÅ¡alinti nuo administracinio nusižengimo bylos, kurioje administracinÄn atsakomybÄn patraukta E. L., nagrinÄjimo ir bylÄ perduoti KlaipÄdos apylinkÄs teismo pirmininkui. TeisÄjas Vandalinas Vainius