Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
VakO 18.10.1982/5235:81 AI generated

Insurance court dismissed pension claim where beneficiary sold land violating surrender pension conditions.

Case Number VakO 18.10.1982/5235:81
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Finland (FI)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Insurance Court dismissed the claim for a reduced surrender pension after the beneficiary sold land in violation of a binding commitment. The beneficiary had pledged not to transfer the remaining forest land to anyone other than the Forest Administration, a municipality, or a specific private farmer, yet sold it to a non-farming relative. The court upheld the decision to stop the pension payments, ruling that the breach of the commitment invalidated the entitlement to the reduced benefit.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

s. 10 of the Insurance Act 1975; s. 11 of the Insurance Act 1975: A surrender pension granted under a reduced rate is contingent upon strict adherence to the surrender conditions; violation of a binding commitment to restrict land transfers invalidates the continued entitlement to the pension.

Keywords

AI generated
surrender pension binding commitment land transfer restriction insurance contract breach pension entitlement Forest Administration reduced rate

Cited Legislation

AI generated
s. 10 of the Insurance Act 1975
s. 11 of the Insurance Act 1975
AI generated
insurance_1993_8358-1992
Insurance court partially allowed insurer's claim for return of one-quarter of pension paid to heirs.
insurance_1977_6009-1976
Insurance court dismissed pension claim due to premature payment based on draft documents rather than final sale.
insurance_1983_2317-1982
Insurance court dismissed pension claim due to early farm control transfer before official ownership change.
insurance_1984_2402-1982
Insurance court upheld insurer's right to recover pension capital from daughter who breached farm succession agreement.
insurance_1986_5847-1985
Social security board's decision to withhold pension due to means-tested support is final and binding on pension authority.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

Luopujalle oli myönnetty vähennetty luopumiseläke 1.5.1975 alkaen hänen myytyään osan omistamastaan tilaosuudesta. Hakemuksen yhteydessä hän oli allekirjoittanut sitoumuksen ettei luovuta omistukseensa jäänyttä metsätai joutomaata muulle kuin metsähallitukselle, kunnalle tai tarkoituksenmukaiseksi lisäalueeksi yksityiselle viljelijälle. Tammikuussa 1980 luopuja myi osuutensa sitoumuksen alaisesta metsämaasta tyttärentyttärelleen ja tämän aviomiehelle, joista kumpikaan ei ollut maanviljelijöitä. MELA lakkautti luopumiseläkkeen 1.2.1980 lukien perien takaisin aiheettomaksi maksetut eläke-erät ajalta 1.2.-30.6.1980. Eläkelautakunnan päätöstä ei muutettu. III -jaosto