Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
VakO 4.11.1982/451:82 AI generated

Insurance court dismisses sister's claim for maintenance allowance after final ruling on deceased brother's case.

Case Number VakO 4.11.1982/451:82
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Finland (FI)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Insurance Court dismissed the sister's request for a maintenance allowance following her brother's death in the war. The court held that her right to the allowance had already been definitively determined by a final decision in 1951, which denied it because she was over 17 at the time of his death. Consequently, the court found no grounds to alter the established legal position regarding her status as an eligible heir.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Tapaturmavirastolaissa 1000/1951; KKK 13.12.1983: A final decision on an insurance claim regarding maintenance allowances for a deceased person's heirs is binding and cannot be challenged in subsequent proceedings.

Keywords

AI generated
maintenance allowance final decision heir eligibility res judicata war death insurance court claim dismissal

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Tapaturmavirastola 1000/1951
KKK 13.12.1983

Cited Case Law

AI generated
KKO 13.12.1983
KKO 13.12.1983: VAKO:n päätös siitä, onko henkilöä pidettävä sotilasvammalain 5 §:n 1 mom.
AI generated
insurance_1982_2271-1982
Insurance court denied maintenance allowance due to low income, but Supreme Court ordered payment citing expanded military injury law.
kko-other_2002_3169
Supreme Court allows appeal against lower court's refusal to permit amendment of trial arguments.
insurance_1970_179-1970
Insurance court rules death from heart attack following surgery for work injury is compensable accident consequence.
appeal_1974_helsinki__94
Tenant must vacate premises when rent arrears are deemed significant rather than negligible by court.
insurance_1983_1563-1982
Insurance court denied full disability pension due to insufficient medical evidence proving permanent work capacity loss.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

Tapaturmavirasto oli 10.11.1951 antamallaan päätöksellä evännyt sisarelta oikeuden saada huoltoeläkettä sodassa kuolleen veljensä jälkeen, koska hän veljensä kuollessa oli jo täyttänyt 17 vuotta. Sisar haki syyskuussa 1981 uudelleen huoltoeläkettä mainitun veljensä jälkeen. VAKO: Sisaren oikeus saada huoltoeläkettä oli jo lainvoimaisesti ratkaistu tapaturmaviraston 10.11.1951 antamalla päätöksellä eikä oikeuskäytännössä korvaukseen oikeutettujen omaisten osalta tältä osin ole tapahtunut muutosta. KKO 13.12.1983: VAKO:n päätös siitä, onko henkilöä pidettävä sotilasvammalain 5 §:n 1 mom. 3 kohdassa tarkoitettuna omaisena, on lopullinen eikä siihen saa hakea muutosta. Etsi SOVL.5.1