Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
Vaasan HAO 07.06.2019 19/0132/2 AI generated

Permanent usage right granted for boat dock area exceeding applicant's proportional share of common water area.

Case Number Vaasan HAO 07.06.2019 19/0132/2
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Finland (FI)
Decision Date
Outcome Allowed / Granted
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Administrative Court upheld the Regional State Authority's decision granting a permanent usage right for a boat dock area of 4,826 m². The applicant argued this area exceeded their proportional share of the 1,083.3-hectare common water area under the Water Act. The court ruled that the dock area was not significantly larger than the applicant's proportional share, thus validating the authority's decision.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Water Act s. 2; Water Act s. 13 (1): The Regional State Authority may grant a permanent usage right for a portion of a common water area if the area is not significantly larger than the applicant's proportional share.

Keywords

AI generated
permanent usage right common water area proportional share boat dock area Water Act administrative discretion significant difference

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Water Act s. 2
Water Act s. 13 (1)
AI generated
kko-precedent_2001_81
Supreme Court dismisses shared water area partition claim due to lack of special purpose and significant harm to other owners.
admin_1989_water-superior__50
Administrative court quashes water authority decision for lack of specific property identification and compensation.
kko-precedent_2001_82
Supreme Court dismisses partition claim where splitting a small shared water area causes significant inconvenience to remaining co-owners.
kko-precedent_2001_84
Supreme Court dismisses partition claim on shared water area due to significant inconvenience to other owners.
admin_1993_water-superior__79
Administrative court dismissed permit request for boat dock due to lack of property rights and disproportionate public harm.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

Aluehallintovirasto oli myöntänyt A:lle pysyvän käyttöoikeuden pienvenesataman laiturirakenteita varten tarvittavaan noin 4 826 m2:n suuruiseen alueeseen kalastusosakaskunnan hallinnoimasta yhteisestä vesialueesta. Aluehallintoviraston päätöksen perusteluiden mukaan yhteisen vesialueen koko pinta-ala oli 1 083,3 hehtaaria. A:lla oli yhteensä pinta-alaa 3 611 m2 vastaava vesilain 2 luvun 13 §:n 1 momentin mukainen osuus yhteisestä vesialueesta. Perusteluiden mukaan laiturirakenteita varten tarvittava käyttöoikeuspinta-ala 4 826 m2 ei ollut sanottavasti suurempi hakijan osuutta vastaavaa osaa yhteisestä vesialueesta.

Lainvoimainen.