Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
Helsingin HAO 17.03.2014 14/0188/2 AI generated

Residence right persists until deportation order takes effect; social aid denial based on lack of permit is invalid.

Case Number Helsingin HAO 17.03.2014 14/0188/2
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Finland (FI)
Decision Date
Outcome Allowed / Granted
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Administrative Court ruled that an individual without a valid residence permit retains the right to reside in Finland until a deportation decision becomes legally binding. The court found that the applicant's stay was neither short-term nor random, making the denial of social assistance based solely on the missing permit unlawful. Consequently, the social aid application could not be rejected on the grounds of the invalid residence permit.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Laki toimeentulotuesta 2 § 1 mom; 14 § 1 ja 3 mom: A person without a valid residence permit has the right to reside until a deportation decision acquires legal force, and social aid cannot be denied if the stay is not short-term or random.

Keywords

AI generated
residence permit validity deportation order effect social aid eligibility administrative residence right toimeentulotuki law

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Laki toimeentulotuesta 2 § 1 mom
Laki toimeentulotuesta 2 § 1 mom ja 14 § 1 ja 3 mom
Laki toimeentulotuesta 14 § 1
Laki toimeentulotuesta 14 § 3 mom
AI generated
kho-precedent_2007_6
Supreme Administrative Court dismisses appeal for temporary residence permit due to lack of special grounds under foreigner's act.
admin_2017_turku__569
Administrative court dismissed social assistance claim against illegal resident due to lack of permanent residence status.
ECLI:FI:KHO:2023:27
Supreme Administrative Court allows deportation decision after lower court wrongly revoked it based on mistaken residence permit status.
admin_2015_hameenlinna__359
Family residence permit revoked due to ended marriage and suspicion of marriage fraud under Alien Act.
admin_1996_uusimaa-county__744
Social assistance claim dismissed due to lack of residence/work permits; court quashed decision for procedural error.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

Vaikka henkilöllä ei ollut voimassaolevaa oleskelulupaa Suomessa, hänellä oli oikeus oleskella Suomessa siihen saakka, kunnes karkotuspäätös saa lainvoiman. Henkilön oleskelua asuinkunnassaan ei hänen maassa viettämäänsä aikaan nähden myöskään voitu pitää hyvin lyhytaikaisena tai satunnaisena. Näin ollen toimeentulotukihakemusta ei ollut voitu hylätä sillä perusteella, ettei henkilöllä ollut voimassaolevaa oleskelulupaa.

Laki toimeentulotuesta 2 § 1 mom ja 14 § 1 ja 3 mom

Asian ovat ratkaisseet hallinto-oikeuden jäsenet Anja Sahla ja Jaana Hemminki (t).

Asian esittelijä Anna Mähönen.