Legislator Case Law & Legislation
Hämeen LO 14.2.1991 179/1 AI generated

Administrative court dismissed tax claim on incentive money paid to mentally ill person under mental health law.

Case Number Hämeen LO 14.2.1991 179/1
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Finland (FI)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Administrative Court of Finland dismissed the tax authority's claim that incentive money paid to a mentally ill person was taxable income. Although the lower court ruled the payment taxable, it ignored the fact that the recipient had no legal right to receive the funds. The court held that the payment was based on medical care considerations rather than a contractual or statutory entitlement, thus excluding it from taxable income.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Mielisairaslain 55 §; Verolaki 1994: 1 §: Incentive money paid to a mentally ill person under mental health law without legal entitlement is not taxable income as it stems from medical care considerations.

Keywords

AI generated
incentive money taxability mentally ill persons medical care considerations no legal entitlement administrative court ruling

Cited Legislation

AI generated
TVL 19 § 1 mom

Cited Case Law

AI generated
KHO B 582
Kilpi DL 1989 ss. 201 - 203
Kilpi DL 1989 ss. 201 - 203
AI generated

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

Kuntainliitto oli maksanut verovelvolliselle mielisairaslain 55 §:ssä mainittua kehoitusrahaa 2 890 markkaa verovuonna 1987. Lääninoikeus katsoi, että kehoitusraha on hänen veronalaista tuloaan. Asiaan ei vaikuttanut, ettei sairaalla henkilöllä ole lain mukaan oikeutta saada kehoitusrahaa, vaan sen maksaminen perustuu sairaanhoidollisiin näkökohtiin.

Verovuosi 1987.

Äänestys 2 - 1.

TVL 19 § 1 mom

Vrt. KHO B 582

Kilpi DL 1989 ss. 201 - 203