Legislator Swiss Legal AI Agent Case Law & Legislation
1-08-2794\4 AI generated

1-08-2794\4 · 1-08-2794\4 · Pärnu Maakohus Pärnu kohtumaja Kuninga tänaval

Case Number 1-08-2794\4
Court / Authority
Decision Date
Jurisdiction Estonia · Case Law (EE)

Summary

AI generated

                  !!"#$ %       & !'()) &!&         *+   ,# -.%/'      !0( //1/      !)/% , %--0(%. % "#"" )/''/1//.) %/% ! 2  ),  ' 3 2  ),  ' 3 2  ),  '  4! 2 5 4,(     !( /(%!!          %(" "##0 67( %-(!/,8 +...

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full Text of the Judgment · 1-08-2794\4



 



              !!"#$ %    

  & !'()) &!&  

      *+   ,# -.%/'      !0( //1/  

   !)/% , %--0(%. % "#"" )/''/1//.) %/% ! 2  ),  ' 3 2  ),  ' 3 2  ),  '  4! 2 5 4,(     !( /(%!!          %(" "##0 67( %-(!/,8 ++

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



  6!:!/% &*&5&!& 7"/0  /) "#$!%. )!$" 1(%/ "//)0 "#$!)0!. 0 !)/% , % $./% &5&*&!&    !06#"!!. -# ##%1!!  !" = $(0 0/%  2 ;  4,(         # #$%& $'&     (     )   *               # $%+   $ ' &       (       &

    *          #$,-    (     )  *         #&./ $'$    (     0

   *

 #)0 $ #)/ &     

     

  (       0

   *

! 2  ), ; + !) %/) 4..! "!(%. % .(/)(" ). .(,(1 %)(" ). .(.1(%/)/ '>>!1!.! " ( !)/% , /( '!/ + !!%.!%/ "(. 1(%"#.#))(,! "!.%/!4! 4##"% ) .#(1/ . .!$.)("" " (./, 4! .(0!: ! 2 5 %./%.!. 0 "#.#))7 0/(0 4! "#$ %. %(&

! 2 * ),  !) %/) ) ,/0! //)6!,(%. %/% 6((:(. 0 !/, &&*&!& " ( &5&*&!& %&#& +* '/6! "!(%. %/ "!01(%/ !4! $ )"!&   2 5 !) %/) 6)4! 17(%.! !)/% ,<). 1//.) %" ) 08 !"##.()(%/ !(/ /"%'/.((%

/"%'/.((%(!". &**?++  5 "##(& @ /"%'/.((% /"%'/.((%(!". &* *?+ 9   "##(&

!$ )0!0! .%(6(()$!,( 4! 6)4! 17(%.! !)/% ,<). *+ "##( =&  "!% "%&

7"/0 9 /) "#$!%. )!$" 1(%/ "//)0 .-$(%.!0! "#$. #.% %/ 47 %. 1(%/)& !(%. %/ "!01(%/ !4! !), %. !6!.! !)!./% &&!

)4! 17(%.! !)/% ,<). .!% ((,( 7(, %!:( //%. /)( . $!. "#)1%!0! "!$/"%!"-11/0 + "##( 4! 5 %/.( (,  2  ),  '  !) %/) % 0!$!  5 "-11/ . $!. "!$/"%!%!0! %/(.%/"-11/0 6((% "##( ((,(. ) 0/%%/&

1 (   9 /"%'/.((%()/ %!!0/. 0 !"##.()(/ !(/ !1A/.!1(( 9 4..! !))(! #$. /"%'/.((%( 4! (1(!)(%.("! "/%" %%/ !) %8 %(%/1((%.( 1 %  ; &&5&!& -$4!0 1((,('' "()/"#.(0

'!"/0    " ) 6!0 $6(.!1(%/)/&

!)/% ,<) .!% 0! 6)4!17(%./. 0 % 11!0 !$!0 %1((%.//( 1( !6/)0 %!6/)/ +  !,!% 67( +** !%!'!,!%& !"%/"#!)0 %/)/ 1"(0! 6((./ 1:/ ** (, %/),(. %8 B!)/% , ; ((,( 7(, %!:(C; B!)/% ,  ; % 0!$!C& ((,( 7(, %!:( .!% 4! % 0!$! .!% 0! + '/6! 4##"% ) "/%#)/6! "#$. #.% %/ 47 %. 1(%/%. !6!./%& ( !$!)(%/0 7 0/0 '#)/ .(/% )!. %/% .(0/. 0 % !.!"%/ 7 0/0 .(./1//.) %/ ):(6((1(%/"% "#$. .(. ()/ .(./1//.) %/ %/!0 %.(" % %./%.!. 0 "#!%&



+       

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



  2 ((             ' 

2        '    '          '      2 '       # $%&   $ ' &     3       *

!1 .( ./1!; (%(" !; "/% # 6!/1 .#(1/ '! 0 6!, %/ 4! #1!%.!1(%/; #))/% %!! 0 +&&*&!& =&  6((1!%/  (.//.('!,! %!)!%7! 4! '!##)("##0(0; /%(.!% &&*&!&  % =&  (1/) !6/)0 %!6/ (.//.('!,! "! 0 )!/ .!#.) %/ %1%)!/ A(1!%%/ D   % 11!% + "##(& !%. (1/.!. % 11! )!/" 1(%. =& !6/)0 %!6/)/ "!0(% !)/% , %/))/ %!1!) '/6!) /0!%( /0! !6/)0 %"#.#)/&



  2        



            (      

2  '2    '        2'    # $%+ $'&   3       *

!1 .( ./1!; #))/% !0 0 %-,(%/) *&!& .'%/). . 6!%.!1!.! " '/6!)  % =& )!/ 5 "##(; 7 0(% 6((1!%/). &&&!& "/))! *&5 '!("  )(!% !/"-)!% & E 4 /% !% 6!% '!")!% 5 "##(; $6!0!0/% 6((1!%. A--%()(%/ 6,(6!))!,!; '/!)/ 1(0! =& !0(% !)/% ,()/ 5 "##(&



 2     (    

     2      

  

2'    #$,-   3       *

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



  2                   

2   

      

2        '    '         '     

   2'    #&./ $'$   3       *



     ' '(  

 #" >( !:( .!#.)/% !)/% ,<( %--0( . (%.!1(%. ! 2  ),  '  4,( (, 17(%.! "!(%. %/"% * " 0 6!,(%. %.& --0( . (%.!0! !)/% , ! 2  ),  '  4,( (, 17(%.! "!(%. %/"%  !!%.! 6!,(%. %.& --0( . (%.!0! !)/% , ! 2 5 4,( (, 17(%.! "!(%. %/"% * " 0 6!,(%. %.& --0( . (%.!0! !)/% , ! 2  ),  '  4,( (, 17(%.! "!(%. %/"% + !!%.!. 6!,(%. %.& ! 2 *+ ),  4! 2 * ),  !) %/) ) ,/0! "/,/1!0 "!(%. %/0 "!/. "% !%"/1!,! 4! 17(%.! )((."!(%. %/"% + !!%.!. 6!,(%. %.; 1())(/ 4..! ! 2  ), ; + !) %/) .(/)(" ). .(,(1 %)(" ). .(.1(%/)/ '>>!1!.! " ( !)/% , /( '!/ + !!%.!%/ "(. 1(%"#.#))(,! "!.%/!4! 4##"% ) .#(1/ . .!$.)("" " (./, 4! .(0!: ! 2 5 %./%.!. 0 "#.#))7 0/(0 4! "#$ %. %(& ! 2 * ),  !) %/) ) ,/0! "!. "% //)6!,(%. %/% 6((:(. 0 !/, &&*&!& " ( &5&*&!& %&#& +* '/6!&  2 5 !) %/) 6)4! 17(%.! !)/% ,<). 1//.) %" ) 08 !"##.()(%/ !(/ /"%'/.((%

/"%'/.((%(!". &**?++  5 "##(& @ /"%'/.((% /"%'/.((%(!". &* *?+ 9   "##(&

%(.7/0(0 9 /"%'/.((%()/ %!!0/. 0 !"##.()(/ !(/ !1A/.!1(( 9 4..! !))(! #$. /"%'/.((%( 4! (1(!)(%.("! "/%" %%/ !) %8 %(%/1((%.( 1 %  ; &&5&!& -$4!0 1((,(' "()/"#.(0 '!"/0    "(1(!!)!%4! 4 /% " ) 6!0 $6(.!1(%/)/& )4! 17(%.! !)/% ,<). .%(6(()$!,( =&  "!% "% % 11!% *+ "##(& 7"/0 9 /) "#$!%. )!$" 1(%/ "//)0 0/% (6(%/), % $./% .-$(%.!0! "#$. #.% %/ 47 %. 1(%/)& !(.%4! 4( %7)1(. 0 "#"" )/''/ 4 0/ 4! '!) % %/))/ "((.!0!&  4

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

,# -.%/' #$. ("