Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
1-05-602\15 AI generated

1-05-602\15 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 1-05-602\15
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

+//+! !! ,/+= 061. +, 5+//,!!, + 6 ,. ! !+//+  ! ! 0+1 0/0++,/!$!+!6,,+1!.!!!!++,$!+=$+ ,,!!+ ,++0!+" 0! - =  ! ,6 +/+5 !+//+/+. +, ,1 /, 3/+ ""  ,!,/. 3/+/0!+ 6! %/1, 58 ,,/!+ /!+/ +1+ ++/0!+/,13,/!+1,%!,0!+!+!+%1++%!"  !  !+! /. +, 0 !. -6,,+! ,!- ,,/!+ ,,+ +!, %6/-,!0!+! /10,.+10/0++,/!$!+!6,,+1!+//!+/,.+,!++ /+!,1!+=$+ ,,!!+,++0!+" %$,%/,/+= !.+,,1- /+/+/!,6610,%1+510!+!,  ,,!!+!.5+0+/+,!-$!,1 ,5/,,110,%1+!!/!+/,"  6/-1+! +!,,1 5+//,! 51+!,. +!,! ,!- ,,/!+ "+ ,0+,!/+ 0$!,+,1 !,!+++10!+!"!,%/, 4''/'/+1= !0/!- ,0!+ 5+.  /0+= 0/0++,/!$!+ //+ 0+%$ 0,+/$!+ +=$+ /10+.0//+!331!,,%/1!+1,1" "+ ,0+,!/+ !,!+ 0$!,0!+/   ! - 11   4!  !6,+!,,1 !,!+ 0$!,0!+ 5$ 0$,+,+!,  !,1 ,+1  /!+ %!,!+"  ! + ,%!,1 !,!+ 0$!,0!+/ 0,+/$!+ +=$+,  /10!,. 0!,$,, !+//+! !! ,/+=-6,, ,,!!0,0,"  6+1%/,  //+ 061. +, ,/++%/, 0/!- 0,+-/1+!,.  "+ ,0+,! %+0!,,1 // ,"" ,,!!+ 4<<-6(/!+ %!,!+"   4 (< / ..' /!+/ 066,  +!+/+ 10!+/+ ' 1 %!,!, - 3/+-661 < 1 %!,!, -6+, ,6,0!+/+ 5880, ' !,!+ ,!+-   !,, ,+1,6,0 4!(+,,+6 ,1,//$1+1",1,!!+-61! "+ ,0+,!' /!+ %!,!+ /,+! ""  ")""   !  0 ,!!+ -6,1 4/!6,,+1 /10," ,/51=%$0/! "+ ,0+,!/+   4  /  /!+/ /,!,!, 0$!,.  !+//+ /%++! !331!,,% /1" !,%!!/!,5+//,!+/++!,,1" !- =,6 +/+5!+//+/+.+, 0 ,,!!+0$!,+,1!,!+!,&1%!,!,* "+ ,0+,!611 0,,+  1.  !1! ,!- 0 !$%$,!  ,!. %1 %6 +0" /,+! ""  ")" 1! "+ ,0+,!  ' /!, %!,!, //  , "",!!+/!+/0+,,1-% +06+!/+% ,,!!+/!+/0$!,+,1

Legislator headnote

AI generated

1-05-602\15 · Viru Ringkonnakohus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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

     

       !    

   ""#$ %  

     &'()*   ++!!,-!./0+1+%+%- /10 2/      # !!  

   +/+ ,0+,!!3310$!,0!+! 4'5-6      ,("(",!!          

331!,,% +/+ ,0+,!,!-+!  +0     +/ + ,0+,!. !1 '7 ++!,/+.  1.%///+.3//5++,%1+/+.+! 1!.+/ , %++ 88!,!+('.,88 , 9/,%+" +0 ,5/,!,,1:*)"7"))(66+ 5/,4')/5..';)(/54/-6  1 %!,!, ,0! ,!+-  !,  1" * )"<")))66+5/,4')/-6 1,0!%!,!!,!+,!+-'*<")"< 66+5/,4'/-6 /+!,!  . <* "" //  5/,  4 << -6'1%!,!," $+1  % !,0+ /,+! )"" !331!,!+!   4'5-6"    +!  

   

  

 (""   

   &*      

 

 !" !"# $%  &          '    

       

 "      (                   !             

  "     (     (                              )       '     (       

"   

         

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

++ "+ ,0+,!.1+!%6%/1!,1+!%/1.5,0+ 4'5 -6%/>,!++,%,+"  )" 1 ,!,6!,1,$+1+1+1+0!./+1!0 !.+,$,! !0, $,! +!+. ! / 30+1 5+/,%,-1  %/  ,.  !  /566! /01,+/ !,+/. +! 5/+ $!- !//, !+,1" 0, /+1!  !. +, !,+ % ,$0+ !+ - ,+!+ ! 5+!0+ !,+ - -/1+ 5/+!$/! 0++ 3 !! !,1 0/!+,+ !,+ % +/!,+ ! +,+  +, !+//!+ 6,0!+3,1%/1,,+,+%!,"

=-+,%!+!, 3/-+!, ++/1= %/  !+ 0+ , ,/!," "+ ,0+,! ,+1!. +, %==  % +! %/!  !  +, ,+!,+ !,+ 310+ - +/+ + %!,!,+ ,+,0+ 5/+ !$/! $!" ,0, !+//+/+ 5 , ,0+ ,+0/+ 0++,%1 ,+1. 0!,$,,  ! /+1!. +, , ,+,!+! ,!+!+ , ,/!+" !/+=%. %!,50,,+!,%,5+!0!,-/1+65/+1%$0/6!,/+1 0% +/!+!0,!+/ +10!+%$++!+,!+"  !/+1!.+, "+ ,0+,!,++%!+$!%!,!!,-!331%6/!,%1!-/151%1" !,!+0$!,0!+/%+!,! ! 4!6,,+1" "+ ,0+,!!,!,++1=!33 !/+ ,!,0+. ,+0 !,!, !+1%1 !-/1 51%1" "+ ,0+,!   ,

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

+//+! !! ,/+= 061. +, 5+//,!!, + 6 ,. ! !+//+  ! ! 0+1 0/0++,/!$!+!6,,+1!.!!!!++,$!+=$+ ,,!!+ ,++0!+" 0! - =  ! ,6 +/+5 !+//+/+. +, ,1 /, 3/+ ""  ,!,/. 3/+/0!+ 6! %/1, 58 ,,/!+ /!+/ +1+ ++/0!+/,13,/!+1,%!,0!+!+!+%1++%!"  !  !+! /. +, 0 !. -6,,+! ,!- ,,/!+ ,,+ +!, %6/-,!0!+! /10,.+10/0++,/!$!+!6,,+1!+//!+/,.+,!++ /+!,1!+=$+ ,,!!+,++0!+" %$,%/,/+= !.+,,1- /+/+/!,6610,%1+510!+!,  ,,!!+!.5+0+/+,!-$!,1 ,5/,,110,%1+!!/!+/,"  6/-1+! +!,,1 5+//,! 51+!,. +!,! ,!- ,,/!+ "+ ,0+,!/+ 0$!,+,1 !,!+++10!+!"!,%/, 4''/'/+1= !0/!- ,0!+ 5+.  /0+= 0/0++,/!$!+ //+ 0+%$ 0,+/$!+ +=$+ /10+.0//+!331!,,%/1!+1,1" "+ ,0+,!/+ !,!+ 0$!,0!+/   ! - 11   4!  !6,+!,,1 !,!+ 0$!,0!+ 5$ 0$,+,+!,  !,1 ,+1  /!+ %!,!+"  ! + ,%!,1 !,!+ 0$!,0!+/ 0,+/$!+ +=$+,  /10!,. 0!,$,, !+//+! !! ,/+=-6,, ,,!!0,0,"  6+1%/,  //+ 061. +, ,/++%/, 0/!- 0,+-/1+!,.  "+ ,0+,! %+0!,,1 // ,"" ,,!!+ 4<<-6(/!+ %!,!+"   4 (< / ..' /!+/ 066,  +!+/+ 10!+/+ ' 1 %!,!, - 3/+-661 < 1 %!,!, -6+, ,6,0!+/+ 5880, ' !,!+ ,!+-   !,, ,+1,6,0 4!(+,,+6 ,1,//$1+1",1,!!+-61! "+ ,0+,!' /!+ %!,!+ /,+! ""  ")""   !  0 ,!!+ -6,1 4/!6,,+1 /10," ,/51=%$0/! "+ ,0+,!/+   4  /  /!+/ /,!,!, 0$!,.  !+//+ /%++! !331!,,% /1" !,%!!/!,5+//,!+/++!,,1" !- =,6 +/+5!+//+/+.+, 0 ,,!!+0$!,+,1!,!+!,&1%!,!,* "+ ,0+,!611 0,,+  1.  !1! ,!- 0 !$%$,!  ,!. %1 %6 +0" /,+! ""  ")" 1! "+ ,0+,!  ' /!, %!,!, //  , "",!!+/!+/0+,,1-% +06+!/+% ,,!!+/!+/0$!,+,1

   &* !,!+ /+/"%+!,1+!)""!",$+1 /10!+!,,1!-! "" - /,+! ")"  "" !"  , ,!!+.  "+ ,0+,!/  /!+!, %!,!+!, ,1  1 -  56+% %!,!," /,+! ""-66=,/!,!,1(1-)56+%%!,!,"  6 ,1+!++/,1!,- 11+! 441+!,''(/5;'</'5;'<'/;'<<; '</.-6,= ! ,("(",!!+0,0,"     

  ++  , &,-.    /&