Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1-06-9735\3 AI generated

1-06-9735\3 · Pärnu Maakohus Pärnu kohtumaja Kuninga tänaval

Case Number 1-06-9735\3
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

1-06-9735\3 · Pärnu Maakohus Pärnu kohtumaja Kuninga tänaval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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

  



         

  !!"#$ %    

  &'( ! ) %* &( !  

        +%,%* -!  .# ,"+/,00 %+"+* 1, #02%3$4,2*  + ,00!#*%    !21#"!!*  *+0  

   %552,%* %+% ! 6 77 0) 8 7' 0)  /  -), "#"" 0+//+4++*0 %+%(

     

 9"+2 +, #0+ "#$!02!* 2   !"

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

 & 

/+00!*%,##,9,) %+ "!% *!4,%+ %##1,%* *+!*!2!  !!"#$* 0+ ",-!0," 0* %+,*%4+ /+1! -##"% 0( /+00!*%,## +%,*!*!"%+ "#$* 0+ ",-!0," 0*  /+1! -##"% 0 !0!*+% /+1!%*8 4,0 "#$* 4++*0 %+ /##0+0 # 19,4!0," * *1 2! "#$* #*% %+)!(

     # 

  

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



!1#  $!4!! * ,%*!% +2 %552, *,+% 4!$ %( #" < -! %552,%*!*!1 "!,*%-! - +%#0+" 0 # %904, 2 "#"" 0+//+8 4,00+ "#$!%+0* /#" < 9 2,% "#$* %: %552, * ,%*!2! !1#  $!4!! !

6 7' 0)  /  -), -! 49,%*! *!00+ !$!0,+ "!,%* % & /+1!4! 0!* %+% %(#  "##,( ! 6 77 0)  !0 %+0 !$!0,+ "!,%* % ' /+1!4! 0!* %+% %(# 77 "##,( ! 6 7 0)  !0 %+0 49,%*! !1#  $!4!!0+ 0,,*"!,%* %+"% !%"+,4! 5"%,""!,%* %+#%!0,%+ % +2!4,%+ *++0 !$!0,+ "!,%* % ' /+1!4! %(#  "##,(( 0-! 49,%*! !1#  $!4!!@0* % 2!$! ,,),* 0 2+%%+ 7 "##,(

  

   &

 

#$ % 0+,2,%8 +* %552,%*!*!1! %552,* ,%*!4,+ -! "#"" 0+//+ %904,4,+ # *+4! *9+0,%+ *!$*+ !1!02 %( ,4,!!0!%-! 4++*0+4,%+0 # -),* 2 "#"" 0+//+4++*0 %+ %+,2( ? $,2 2+%  6 &7' 0)  / 7 -), * 0+. ,%," %552, * ,%*!2! -! 49,%*! *!00+ "#"" 0+//+"#$!+ "!,%* %(

%,1,,0$!), +%,*!* 2 +, #0+( #$* " 0 2 * 0+. %,%%+ 9 2! %552,49,%*+* 0*(

 .# ,"+/,00 #$* ,"