Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1-06-7548\2 ECLI:EE:VMK:2006:1.06.7548.23794 AI generated

1-06-7548\2 · Viru Maakohus Narva kohtumaja

Case Number 1-06-7548\2
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus

Legislator summary

AI generated

+       ,  3(!%"! @ !$. , #,%9 $% #//# $$$/&::&(&,%/ & $""#  889! %#%,# &//& - &%  %&(# *++* $&//# + :#!$- #".#  #  (#)# ))"& - .#"#/! & $#  ##( & && (1"'!/- %&'&/!$& % # )#/9& % %&#9.#/% &0#@!'& &%%&$)% & /(! & %&&/- %&/&B,!$@,& %&'&(! & .#)#9 & &%%&$11,9&/ #!$#,,#%#, + %#:.!/%.!!(# &/&$/.#(0!!/%&/&B,!$!# *? $",!)# /#$  &//&'# 8,9( $#/%+&/&B,!$1 %# (#1"#,1'&(! &)1"'!+ (#%&'#:#,!3(!%"!@ !$.%!(&.#"#/! &$#  ##(! %%&'&/!$& %# )#/9& %%&#9.#/%&0#@!'& &%%&$)% &/(! &%&&/- +%+ #"<*=/'*:&%%&,1%9$"!%&+ 

Legislator headnote

AI generated

1-06-7548\2 · Viru Maakohus Narva kohtumaja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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

 

 

                                                                 

  !"##$  %  &%&'&(! &#&')#$% *+),!*+#-#".#

"!(!,##/# )#,(0&"   * * 

%$ &!      

%! %,'! &$"&%1" 2&/&,#3#4$&.!%4

"!(!,##/# !  

  

     5"$"6" 5"$"6"!#0!3&,! !,7#%. 889! %#%#.  

.#"&($%:/%$#"! %#%9; + *+*+*#".#!,,#$  #"<==/'*: )1"'! $9.#,'! % %$#% &##'### %#$9> *+ +*+*!"##$%:/% #"<*/'*?==/' *:)1"'!$9.#,'! % %$#% &#)#'#*## %#%++ @$&,9!%-&/$# %/#$(! &$&&/9-$#/9#%9#/#%&  ++*

#!% )# #,9&#9.$##%#/&,%!,##,)$ !"#$%""&   ,,! %#9#'%$ % (%") 889! #"<*=/'*:)1"'!)#(11"#%#%#//& $#"! % &$   8$ ## %#.#,'! % %+ 

#" < = #/ &/- 3(!%"! @ !$.!/& (@! %&%9 $#"! %  # &,9#9# 8/9$# /!$ %66'# *

&!% (& #)#$#&$8(,& %,,!/#% & + 11"#%#8/9$# /!$%66%&'&(! &%1%#)#$ *$9+

#" <  %/&,&.#/% $ %#9# 3(!%"! @ !$.! 8/9$# /!$ %66 %&'&(! & #)#/ )1"'!(# )1"'(! ! $,%"//,@9&!9; + &/#(#$%(11"#%9#/#/! & &/$# > *+ !/((# $"!(!,##//9#)# (11"#%9 #)#.#&(!$& )1"&/ $"!(!,##//9  #$,9# "&'! %"&&"!(! &/&> + #//(# $"!(!,##//9#)# $,%"//!/& (# &/$#  ,!,' & !%#(# %#//& #,9(&!9 (# $ % %&%1!%(! &)#&/#% .#&,9!%&$%#> + ##(# $"!(!,##//9 #(&%,!$/% &&/,&.# /# &/$# % /#$(! &$  $#&(#$  $! .!!&%&! %$8(,&$ :1&.#$ > + ##(#$"!(!,##//9 #(&%,!$/%&&/,&.#/#&/-%66.@!@::!(! $#.#&%#(! &$ +

 

 *

 11"#%#3(!%"!@ !$.A %&'&(! &#)#$ !"##$%$"!(!,##//9  #$,,#)#%#)# (11"#%#.#$"!(!,##//9 #(&%,!$)1"&/&.#/.&#//#+  @$&,9?&/$# %/#$(! &$&&/9?%8! %#9#$%%  &)@ %(! &/+  )* +    

  $",! , %#,%!, %#:.! &/$%# #".#  $# $ % !.!!/#'!$#%%&$ +  )* +    

   

     , ,9"## ,&/!%#%.!! #9# $",!-  -* $",! $#!% )#%#  :"$"#%"!   )# $%! %,'!/ #9.$##% #/&,%!,# #,)$ :/%  %#%9@!' #0!&& %=+$",!+ +  &,&%/ $/9 %/&0  %# 9# ##,9 (!,! %&&"!(! #".&/9 $,%/& ,"     & %!A! :#,'# -.@!#".&/9 $,%/&*  #, #:#,'# -.!!%&,(0&"* ==+ &,&%/ $/9 .@!0 .#0#%#%/!$ %1!%(! & $""#/ %# 9#  $ )$ / $%%  & )@ %(! & &%$& %- (1"$!9&  %# (! & 9$(&,9!/& $"!(!,##/# )# ,(0"! )# $&  .@! $&//& && % , (&,&%/ $/9%# ,9+ #$ &$.!!%,'%/&0& !%#9#!"##$%#".#$%(#)#$#,% &/&! &+ 

%%   ##9&%#$ &$%%1!%"!/&%1!%(! &$  :1&.#(669(! &/$%%  &)@ %(! & %- $! 889/#,&&!/&"!!'!,@9&9.#0#%#%/!$%1!%(! &#)#)$ /%# ,9+  !  -  

%%  &/& .@!0 & !%#9# #:&//#% !,$#&0 &  :1&.# )$ / !" !,'$,,#$%/& #".# $%(#)# $#9 .1!9&%#.#%& (&,&%/ ,"(!9& "!$$(! &/& $%(&,&%/ & - %&#%#9&  $%/& $!")#/!$/%$#&0 && !%#(! &$#.#%  & %:1&.#)$ /$%%  &$/%#(! & %+  

+       ,  3(!%"! @ !$. , #,%9 $% #//# $$$/&::&(&,%/ & $""#  889! %#%,# &//& - &%  %&(# *++* $&//# + :#!$- #".#  #  (#)# ))"& - .#"#/! & $#  ##( & && (1"'!/- %&'&/!$& % # )#/9& % %&#9.#/% &0#@!'& &%%&$)% & /(! & %&&/- %&/&B,!$@,& %&'&(! & .#)#9 & &%%&$11,9&/ #!$#,,#%#, + %#:.!/%.!!(# &/&$/.#(0!!/%&/&B,!$!# *? $",!)# /#$  &//&'# 8,9( $#/%+&/&B,!$1 %# (#1"#,1'&(! &)1"'!+ (#%&'#:#,!3(!%"!@ !$.%!(&.#"#/! &$#  ##(! %%&'&/!$& %# )#/9& %%&#9.#/%&0#@!'& &%%&$)% &/(! &%&&/- +%+ #"<*=/'*:&%%&,1%9$"!%&+ 

 $@/#  3(!%"! @ !$.!- %&(# $#!% )#  #/!,# 4&/,$.# )# :"$"6"! #0! 3&,!  !,7#%.! .#&/ ++* @/(!%9 $$$/&::&'# ,@#0 :"$"6" $%  3(!%"! @ !$.!/& $#"! % &$ 

#"*=/'*:&%%&,1%9$"!%&%!(&:#,&(! &&& %## %#.#,'! % %+ #"<=/'#/ &/ # &,9#9#(@! %&%9$#"! % %8/9$# /!$%66'#*%,,!/#% & + 

%! %,'!/ 889! %#%#. #.#/9# - &% ##0 #" @/(!%9 $$$/&::& %- ,@ %0 &//&'#- #,9!  .#0#%#%/!$/%,@ /&$$$$/&::&(&,&%/ &$#/9#(! &$ -$$$/&::& @/(!(! &/#.#/9# (# %@&/! %%#&%+  5"$"6")#$#!% )#%&%#.#9 @/(!%9$$$/&:&%+ 

 



 )#$%/!$#"%#(! &:@)#/%&'!$ )1"&/9 &-&%3(!%"!@ !$.!-%&(#$#!% )#)#:"$"6"! .#&/ , @/(!%9 $$$/&:&- )1"'!9&  " <9& * =* 1%%&!9+     , .&&,9( &/- &% 3(!%"!@ !$., @/(!,9$$$/&::&(#%@&/! &%#%&$# &/%+  1%9& &&/%9 %%/&0 889! %#%#.3(!%"!@ !$. 889!%,,! %#9# #"<*=/'*:)1"'! ,!,'(@! %#%#//&$#"! % .# %#.#/%$$$/&::&/&+ 

 %&&0$%%  &%'!,&9& &&/%9/&)#)!,99&  "<9& %* *=+      /&$ &!#.". $!

%,!$