Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
1-06-5179\2 ECLI:EE:VMK:2006:1.06.5179.19465 AI generated

1-06-5179\2 · Viru Maakohus Narva kohtumaja

Case Number 1-06-5179\2
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

  

Legislator headnote

AI generated

1-06-5179\2 · Viru Maakohus Narva kohtumaja:   

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

  

                                                       !""#

$%$%&%' %"%&("#$ )*+'" ,)+"-"!." ! ' /"","("/'0%!  )   $#%       $ $/& %#!%$1! "! /"' !/." ! ' /"","  "2%32" ",& /"442 $% "!56 ,&)7-)(1!& (" ,%#"/2! 8"/.  442 $% "! 5 6  ,& ) 7 ) (1!&  ###,%77%'%/%$,% 8!#!9! ! "("2%7!#!9! ",'%! "# 442 $"$".    



"!"%'#"! $"$:720 ;#%/2<% ,%#",2"$2+ " $(" "/2%"2.#""$", /"=%,/#."+ 442 $"$".

  



"!"%'#"! $"$:720+ ;#%/2% ,%#",2"$2+ " $(" "/2%"2.#""$,"2 ' !&,# +  

  // $"2""2%32" ",& /"442  "!56 ,&)7-)(1!& ("'11!"$"$",,%#"! $%#* #,' ""$"$."/& $$+  "!5*,&-*",%,% 799!"$"'; $%$2."/& $$$1 %, #,$$1 $' %,%-# "2%32" ",& /" % 7"/%*""$"%)#, %#"$%"("(#,$ '%$$"$, ###! $%&+  // $"2",%#"/2!8"/.442  "!56 ,&)7)(1!& ("'11!"$"$",,%#"! $%#* #,' ""$"$."/& $$+

  )

 "!5 ,&-*",%,% 799!"$"'; $%$2."/& $$$1 %, #,$$1 $' %,%-# ,%#"/2!8"/. % 7"/%6#, %#"$%"("(#,$ '%$$"$, ###! $%&("$1 2"0$",,% "!51$%$"$2 #1 $' #/$!,, "("#7"/22#/$!,,/;2% 2:   %,"'"#$'11!"$2",", %%,#"""2!% , "("#" - ,,"'1%> )  ,''" #! ' /"",,2"(" '11!"$2 "("."%' #% (1!%, #! ' /"",,2"#/2" !%& $!%%! ' %,%> * ",,'"#! ' /"",,2"("#/$!,, ,%'"%,#"/ /&% $"'"$",,%"/2'% 2'"#$$% $1 $' %("%,"$."%/2 $%#$">

  ""'" #! ' /"",,2"'%$/ #,$ %%,/%." ," %,#"$ ,"#' %# #"%'"# #  . %$% $#4'/%#71%."#>  ""'"#! ' /"",,2"'%$/ #,$%%,/%.","%,-$99.; ;77 ' #"."%$"' %#+  1,(" '; $" "2%32" ",& /",$ ! & $,2%% /2!""  % $%  $"$  . "2"  #!/  (" #$#,2 < #" $(" +=%,/#."  7,$ %%,! ' %, ; &"0  $"' % %%$  4# $"$ #"2" 4%#"#4''%/2 4%#"  #!/  ) %/$  (" #$#,2 #$'%/%$,% $"$2 ; &"0 %%$* 4#$"$. "2"4%#"#4''%/2#,' #!/ +  1,(" '; $" ?%.&%/  8".,. ,$ ! & $,2%% /2!""  % $%$"$  . "2"  #!/  (" #$#,2 < #" $("  +&,#   7,$ %%,! ' %, ; &"0  $"' % %%$  4# $"$ #"2" 4%#"#4''%/2 4%#"  #!/  ) %/$   (" #$#,2 #$'%/%$,% $"$2 ; &"0 %%$7,$* 4#$"$. "2"4%#"#4''%/2#,' #!/ +  1,("'; $%$2 #$#,2 (" /2!"" #"/2" ""/2' / $%%! '  "!.%,2#/$,% /! ))* 6  %$  @ 7"/&"- .;  "!.%,2#/$,% )))*6 "/"7"/&"- . $%/'0%!)6 + $#,2("/2!"".; 0."0"$"$, #$1 $' %#!!",$"2"# (#, #$$% (;$' % %$#%$- '1!# 2% $"' % 2#'%/2 ,%- %$ $%&%' $ / #" #$#,2% .;  /2!"" $"' %&"- "'$  #! ' /"","(" /'0!  (" #% .;  #%,,% %%$ / #$#,2.; /2!""$"/2+   & /;%$%$"' %'"#%#. $/& 2$,%0% $"2" !""#$"!."#$'"("#"/$%,% %+  $$""2%$"#%#$$1 $! ,%$1 $' %#*71%."'992' %,#$$%(;$' %$- #  442,"/%% ,%! & /;2%2."0"$"$, #$1 $' %"("(#,$"/2+  2" #"%0"' %#!2  $$%,% .; 0 % $"2" "7%,,"$ /#"%0%  71%." (#,  !  /&#//"#$,% "!." #$'"(" #"2 .1 2%$"."$% '%/%$,/!' 2% ! ##' %,% #$'%/%$,%- $%"$"2% #$,% # !(", #,$#"%0%% $"' %#"."$%$71%."(#,#$$%#,$"' %$+  ("#$, #,"!$"' %,#$."$":  "2%32" ",& /" / "/$2 #$ ",," ###,%77%'%/$,% #!!" 442 $"$/" %,,%- %$  '1!$  ",&%),%77 ###,"2 ' ! "'%/# &"-%$$""##"0.;$'" "'%/# ,$%2" '44' %# &!"'' #"7""'A%$"' / -!%", %%! 0/ '%$"$2#"0"(""//"0""22!"","2 ' ! "'%/# ,%+ %,,% %%$ "  ",& /" '44242 #"0" 7%",$ ""22  ''"$ $%"$2 ."%,$#"+  %, '%, $%&$%2%" "2%32" ",& /","2 ' ! "'%/# ,$"("."%' #'1!$(/ )#!2.",$   /"!#$ , $ " /%$ !% #&%  &!"'' - ' 2" '44  ,,"'1% , //" %! /%."$%,% /"!#;,$,"$%$$"!0 ("$%,% /"&"*#!/ &!"'' %%$+

  *

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

 

     ,%#%  .",%/# $/ #