Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Court Decisions Legislation Analyze in Legislator
1-06-2187\6 ECLI:EE:PMK:2006:1.06.2187.17856 AI generated

1-06-2187\6 · Pärnu Maakohus Pärnu kohtumaja Kuninga tänaval

Case Number 1-06-2187\6
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia · Case Law (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

                      !!"#$ %       &'!(&!          )**    #$+ (" ,-. +% %      !(.(#//-,      0#$!-%-1!-%223(%+ %-% !4,5/64**,5/ 66 647,5/85(,2$('--+, %-"#!%  (%+(-!''     ...

Legislator headnote

Placeholder

Keywords

Placeholder

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

        

             !!"#$ %    

  &'!(&!   

      )**    #$+ (" ,-. +% %      !(.(#//-,  

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

 )  .+ %-5!"##(6$!1-'-!8!'(%!/!!!3(! .+ %-5!)"##(6 "%-"-,,!.+ %-5!  "##(6 .!(+#!.-+(,!!+#( .+ %-5!  "##(6 7) !!%+! .! %- /!+% %- "#8!"( .+ %-5!  "##(6 /!?22'( -3 D## .+ %-5! 7 "##(6 8"! 3-5! "!'/% ( .+ %-5!7"##(6+#(3 !(-3.+ %-%"##(8!0!A"#!,3 ++'!C(.!,3 %-%#,-.!%+ 5!!!E(1#"%(%+7!% "#$!5! 6!,,(!'+8!,5!++!(%,(--5!+-.+ %-5! "##(6 +-"(+!3-% .!5 %-5! 0!A" #!,3 ++'!C(,- .!!,(%+ "!$8  "#""  )) "##( %  %-% % ''!%&

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

,-. +% % #$+ ("