Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1-08-14243\6 AI generated

1-08-14243\6 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus

Case Number 1-08-14243\6
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia · Case Law (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

                       !"#$!        %&' '(' )!"#$ !*        + , - .   (#      /&#        0# " 11& ! 2  34 5,*63 1$'' ! '   '*''" 7         "!"##&89 ,995'!"#$ :...

Legislator headnote

Placeholder

Keywords

Placeholder

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

  

                    !"#$!     

 

%&' '(' )!"#$ !*  

    

+ , - .   (#      /&#    

   0# " 11& ! 2  34 5,*63 1$'' ! '   '*''" 7    

    "!"##&89 ,995'!"#$ ::::::::::::::::::::: ::::; <<"#$ 4!!&!(5"  ! "! !!&    =&'&=#"   !"#         $%&% '(%)*         +,  -

   .  /$'01 '          %20             *,-

   .   $*1 %       

      

3+4%%.3*.'331)0(           (         5 , -

  %% , -    '6 ,    -(   .   )      )     /$4%03 5        

        

 .            %1.%%.'331.

 7            ')5 ( 

      )  %3165 ,               -   ,

 

      

2  %3''330&1333%68)    '1333&+16&-.  /$%13 %             %%635,          -   *3   ) (        ,%63395533  - 6'33 ,      -      (   *+,    - 53  ,

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

  ' "! $ '=  '  '3 !3!1$'&! ' ! '=63=3* 6 " ! &'  " ! ' !& 5 '   ' #!& =)'' = !4! # !   "! 4## 5"' #=' #'4!&=63  '%

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

 8%  !=' 3&'  " !3   =##& 5 ! '&' !44 11&  = 3 11&  = ! ! *' 4'' * $""  '& $  ' % ! * )' !  $  (''&5"!& 11&  =*6=''3" *"   '!!"## " !33)' *46 =6*!  ' *6" # !44%  #$!  # ' !"#$5 '  "#$ !'' '  '' ! '  "#3! !& )'& '  ' #' !  "$'&% 63 '#"! '3!5'4!$!' ")= '& ! *&4!!&!=&%=' &'  "#$ !4 1$$###3 ''" 4'  "   !& '##! ! " !"#$ 5 #"## ")  ! * '%%5%%*%%1 ! '35 !'( !& ' !"#$'5' " !1 ! '&# ! &! =66 '&%  #' 3  !  = 5 ' 

 ' 1&!"  !"  =( $ "!  !3!1$'&! ' '' ##   "! '3% 1'"###3 ' 6(= ! ' !=  5 '  8% ,%  " ! !4' =)' !&4##= '&!  '''""'3' " !#= ' #!& "#&!=  !3!1$ ' % !1 ! '3# )'& !&5' ' "#& ' =$'"#& !&'  $#&  11&  =" ! "*$ ' # 11&  =" != !4!$ !!!&" >11  '*)!3=)" ! &' 6#  ' !& 3 6 " =!! # '' % 11&  =#" ! !$ ' " ! !&=63=& '&=)&"!=)& ''##!&=*" " ! = !4! 1'  '" %  ! 1 ! '  6$ !(5 '  11&  = 4'  "#&!=  #'" !=63  5# '&"# '#"'' ! ' %11&  =#<'!& " !'5'  * " !'"!=(4# ' '% !'%%## 1 ! '  +  -

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

#$!  ''(# ! '*!$&!&' 2 &'  35

5 * %  #$ !"