Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
1-07-15618\4 AI generated

1-07-15618\4 · Pärnu Maakohus Pärnu kohtumaja Kuninga tänaval

Case Number 1-07-15618\4
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

          

Legislator headnote

AI generated

1-07-15618\4 · Pärnu Maakohus Pärnu kohtumaja Kuninga tänaval:           

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

          

         !"    

  #$%&"'(#$ ')&* !&%+  

        !&' ,,& (*' ,,&,(' (+(   '+, &    *,-."/* %  

   .  ,*'&0 + . (,',  (,11,%,,&(","  2 3()#1/#+)'$      .  ,*'&0/ '"' . 4/ *,%  !&('(& '%'( "'"&&.$#4$$#$() !&1 (&  23()#1+)'"&",*5.", &",)&')'%'"' "&",&",+ !(.%'",)$$ #$#$#$# $ ()  !& 1 (&   2 #4 ()  +)' 4 ('",*5.", &",)$ 4$$$#$,6' !&1 (&  2()+2 3()#1/#/4/3+)'"&+('",*5.", &",)$ 3$#$#$#$ & !&1 (&  2()#+247()# 1/#/4+)'+#1,*",*5.", &",)$ $$#$#$ & !&1 (& 2#()/#+277() #13+)'+#1,*",*)'"&",)&')'%'"'('", &",+ !(.%'",)$ . (,',/ '"' . 344/ *,%  !&('(&

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

 4 (&,"1,*"&%'(1 (&,( *:'%(' !& &"",)&&*.$ !  >    C (',"'&&."99.'"&"",((,"/,&&,%.'"$$#$/,,('%'",) &*"&%&,((+( &('"/D,&*(,5",."('(&$$,."' &'('"&',& >"'"(.*&A"&"B&5(,&&'/%'"*"&*(&? &'('"&,+1"9!! & 1",&,',&,+,., (!&,',&,",.",@+ &"'(%''"&'$%'#$%",(,$4(*. &'('"&,+ 1"9!! & 1",&, ',&,  '%,'+ + %'(('",  )", 1!(  &,),%'"& ? &'('"&, + 1"9!! & 1",&,',&,'),.,(!&,',&,",.",@24E()4 !",(&", )",)$ %&' &,%/ %." $$# $ ,(( $3 +( (('"/ 5,"&' &$ 4 "* ,%' +!((' &) "*( "&,,( ,5",."('(& $ $ 7  &'('"& ',& > "'"(.*& A"&"B &5(,&&'/ %'" *"&*(& ? &'('"&, + 1"9!! & 1",&, ',&, + ,., (!&,',&, ",.",@ +  &"'(%''"&' $ %' # $ %",(, $ 4 (5  &'('"&, + 1"9!! & 1",&, ',&,  '%,'+ + %'(('",  )", 1!(  &,),%'"& ? &'('", + 1"9!! & 1",&,',&,'),.,(!&,',&,",.",@24E()4 !",(&&,),%'"&", )",) +%'.&" *'")1'" ". (,',)& '%,&./'.%'((', )"$$#$ ,((#$+(%(/,*(("/,"(". ,*'&0'1 (&+!'&*"":'.& "FF/ ,)$$FF/%'((,"*''5'"'.. (,',+(,(', $ $/, ('&",'1,G,&'&==&+&, 1 (&(5' &"'%'",(*"&&'$

%,,(& ..&,),*",)'". ,*'&0? &'('"&,+1"9!! & 1",&,',&,') ,.,(!&,',&,",.",@24()"&&,'.$ >  (' ,"'&&. "99.'"&" ",((,"/ ,& &,% .'" +*!,%'( # $ %&"'"& 1'((''/,,('%'",)&1",(&&*"&%&1,*.,("/,.,( !"FF/*!,%(&!,(  (,5",."('(&/*',"," )","//)1,."' &'('"&',&,1'&/!')4$  ')%%-$ $$ %&' &,%/ .'" +*!,%'" # $ %&"'"& 1'((''/ ,,('%'",) &1",(& &*"&%& 1,*.,( "/ ,. ,( !" FF/ *!,%(& !,9%,(  ( ,5",."('(&/ *',","  )","/)%%'1,."' &'('"&',&,1'&!')4 ')%%$ $$ %&' &,%/ .'" ,5",."('(& # $ %&"'"& 1'((''/ ,,('%'",) &1",(& &*"&%& 1,*.,("/,.,( !"FF/*!,%(&!,( (/*',"," )","//)1,."'  &'('"&',&,1'&!')4 ')%%$ $$ %&' &,%/ &, "&" '"'&, )1'"  " .  ,*'&0') ","  )","  &'('", ', A"&"B *,. (('"& "",/ %'((',  &'(', ',  )"," 7 &5(,&&'/ %'" *"&*(& ? &'('"&,+1"9!! & 1",&,',&,+,.,(!&,',&,",.",@+ &"'(%''"&'$%' # $ %",(, $ 4 (5  &'('"&, + 1"9!! & 1",&, ',&,  '%,'+ + %'(('",  )",1!( &,),%'"&? &'('"&,+1"9!! & 1",&,',&,'),.,(!&,',&,",.",@ 24E()4 !",(&", )",)/*"&&'$$#$,((#$+(, ('&",'1,G,&' &==&+&, 1 (& %(/ , *(("/ , "(" '' 1,,&. .  ,*'&0' 1 (& +!'&. ":'.& FF/,)$$FF&)'"&%,(".'(, &'"&$ '%,&&. &,),*",) '" . (,', ? &'('"&, + 1"9!! & 1",&, ',&, ') ,., (!&,',&,",.",@24()"&&,'.$ ,,). ,*'&0 &'('",',"," )",",5",."(' %.%'",/*(.%'",+ ,."'.%'",)/ ' ",,  & '%, 1.. )1' 1 (&/ '"'/ ,"  *,% & '%, 1.  &'('",',,5",."(''&(,%'",/1'& '%, 23()#1/#+)'*('G'&",,'&* '&, $

 3 . (,',  &'('", ', ","  )"," ,5",."(' '&(,%'",/ *(.%'", + ,."'.%'",)/ ' ",,  & '%, 1.. )1' 1 (&/ '"'/ ,"  *,% & '%, 1.  &'('",',,5",."(''&(,%'",/1'& '%, 23()#1/#+)'*('G'&",,'&* '&, $    "    "+  !&(' %,,&(", ')" ":(%'"'. "99.'"&&*./ ,., '&"+. ') 1 =  (,11,%,,&(", " (,11,$ 99.'"&&*&,/ ,., '&"+&, + 1 =' *!,( ":(%'&.  (,11,  !",(&  .  ,*'&0'(, !(.&*"'"&"," 23()#1/#+)'4"&+(',*)'"&"$  2  () # (",( (5 '%,&&. '"&" ",.%'",(, &  !& $#$# $ &"",)%:'"&,&..%&'"&",+#1,*",*)'"&",*:')(''&'"&", (5 !(.%'",(,4"&&.+#1,**)'"&"&$ . (,',(, !(.&*"'"&","  23()#1/#+)'4"&,*5.", &" 23()+4(",(&',"(&",&')'%'"'4"&",&",+ !(.%'",)/%'((,"&(5 %!*%'",(,. (,',($$$$#$,,(*)'"&","*''5'&.41,*$ . ,*'&0+. (,',&'"&"'. !&'"&)'(,."99.'"&"," 23()#1/# +)'&',('(&"99.'++'.":(%'&. (,1,&,+.,$ #

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