Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
1-08-3154\2 AI generated

1-08-3154\2 · Viru Maakohus Narva kohtumaja

Case Number 1-08-3154\2
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated



Legislator headnote

AI generated

1-08-3154\2 · Viru Maakohus Narva kohtumaja: 

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text





 













               

      









 !"

 

 





#$%&"'(#)* !&$+

 





  

 ,-(



 

'.". *'./ 

 



 

..'./ *"001"&"." 2-'3 2('3)(

+%3%"$./.&'". "#

 







 

  







' !&  444 4444)  444)  " 1 5(()

&66 !&444)! '1"71.#



".$"&&"891:#

7./1;.' !"&'!$"...'1#



 





//"&1..'./ *"001 2-'32('3)(+%3+$7"&"&"."

!'/. "&"   '$0$$./1

 9%.*$%% '&"." '%!&*'& . .'./ *

9%.*""".&'."& ':  !'1$".'. 9%.*$%% ((  /

) "# #  55  &!&

""1 '$0$$./1

 /#



!'/.

"&"

&"1





+ "'

 !& &"".

+7"&$".

!.&."&

!/1"$/"&..$ *.'1"*.'. / ((,-5  ."& <!"9/3" *7

*.'1"*.'. / (((,,55

/"9/3"# ". '1".'. $%1 *&./$:.

55 //3 ".'3&"8 =. .'./ *) ) !'/. "&">#  !'/.

"&"9 '.&%."'&"."&%!&.3".'&&"&1"/&"./7.&%&.$./.&'".'%:*$"."

 !&&%&'.&%&.$./.&'".".1"&""%&."&&1 "#



..'./ *"!&."*'&1&7./1;.' !"&'!$"...'1&0!"&1 !& &"".

+7"&$".'#



"&7./1185#(#(,..'./ *'&%*7.&15"3.&&= .3!&">)$""*1





( 

1"+& ''."".& ''' "1.""'?.&.:&..)* /@"..1+

!%*&1 !& &"".".1"''+7"&$".'#



7"& . .'./ *'& 3&'1."". *%'+ $./.&'"'18 "/1! 5( " &!&

*""1 "0$$./1 *"

  /) $%%&1 &"+ '.3  A'+ * 9 '&   !&..'"."

$./.&'"." 73": "&$". .."& $"&1 &" -( 0" &!& 0!.""1

!."0$$./1 "

  /  "./& +  $/'& $ BC9'1'.  9 &.3.$".

'1, ".&".

 /#



./.&'"'1&"1!/1"$/"&..$*.'1"*.'./((,."&

<!"9/3" *7 *.'1"*.'. / (((,,55

/"9/3") *&./$:. (--#

./.&'"'1 / *7$' &"1 *:&!&''&  9%.* + "' *&."  !& &"".

+7"&$"."&# !'".1/71.19 '.&%."'&"."&%!&.3".'&&"&1"/&"./71.1

&%&.$./.&'".'%:*$"." !&&%&'.&%&.$./.&'".".1"&""%&."&&1 "#





 



 !

001$7"&.&' / 73"  !& &"". %&&."$".'. +%3/.*"& 9%.*"&  9%.* + "'

& &'.1) .&  !" &" $/'"+ 0'1 "#  /$.&&1 &%!&+ + "'  !&'.

".''"&& &'"&.."&&)+7"&:%." '.* &""#



"





!



..'./ *"001"&&".".''.").&&.$) ''."").''."!&."(#,#(,"+

 ''$.&1 $" + & ''."".$.&/ !'1"0'1$./.&'"./5D, "

"&"&(#5#(,& $.9/11*%%&. .."&)$" /.&&./%!&1:".1".21.,'3

()'3)' ! ')&:+0&".&""".1".2,'3//3 ''".1".2,'3

+%35 /"".!&!*/% ')".''. !&).&(#5#(,.''(80'.&1."."&

:3 9 * $/&.. & ''99/&  1) '1." ./. E61.&" /"& 

&.& $'. $661 +'%+&. ''":) 9 9"" /& '''. +%3/.* & '' /& ''

%3") 1.'..1." "'".'&  (  &0  ./.$ .1"91 E

 9%& ' ./.$

&""$%1.3@'&3"3.&&.FC9.'3!&"#/&..'./ *"/&&%./1*'.

& '''%:*&".'.)$''.%3"*"&&*..')E9%& './.$&""$%1.3@'&3

5"3.&& .3!&")("3.&&FC9.'3!&"+"3.&& .E'&.")$"

'1 9.1.&1 &.$ .&. ''# ..3 */1&1 &.3 '79'. * //3 *%'+ *

& '' /& ''&" /"& 1.'..&*& + & '' /& '' .."& *+&1 9 . .'./ *' .

7//."&/1&.$"&"7'&$&&.'97!+"&.'#."3(,#,#(, /!&!*5 /.

.'./ *9 '&&"&1#



/&) . .'./ *) &") 5#(#(,  .'' 8 ":1." ./. E61.&" /"& ."&

:) * $/&.. & ''99/& 1) $661 +'%+&. ''": 1.'.."

"'".'&("3.&& .3!&"#/&& '' /& ''%3"'.&& '' /& ''.."&*+&'&

..'./ *%. &&9.1.&'&"3.&& .3!&"//3.&.''9.1.&'&'""

( "3.&&  . 3!&"# 71.' "3.&9./1&.' '1 ./.$ &""$%31# /&1

@& !& "&""+ ''$.&1$"+& ''."".& ''/"9.&$.&/

5#(#(,  @00"'". " *%%&. 9 &  '' / 5D, *"&*'&   2'. , '3 

//3 ''".1".2'.,'3#



  2 , '3  '".' / *%!.$'&  "& */".' ."+' ':&1 *%'+"&9 '& <

&.& $ 0!. 9%.* + "' ."$ 1".' ."&"". ":$".' $&&.%'".' .."$%3'

"&$"." &""*:'& & $.&1 ."&"".  " &.$3 '*" 93"" &:& &.1

$&&.  !.$  ( "3.&& *7  "3'' & *7  "3& *7 ( 3$$

"&".&$"&:&*7(3$$/%$"&:&#

 ''".1".2,'3(+2,'3('".')."+93"" '.*: 3"0'.&:."&





 

$"".1".3

.!&."&&1

$"*:

 3".'"&

9)

&'.:

."&1

+'

& ''1.'&" / *7 ."+ 1.'&" / *"&*'& : & ''&.& $'. & $.&$".

.."$%3'.#



 $.&1." 0'.& ''95"3.&&0'. ""%&."&&1$"*: 3".)/.1

9.&."+1.'..$&+%&&.")9/..'./ *& $. ''".1".2,'3"%&."&&1

*%%&. ) "#  1.'..&* : & $.&$/. 0!./1"*%'"."& 3"& ."&"".) :

1.'..$&+%&&."#



$ &!&' &.3.*".3 9/..'./ *& $. 2-'32('3)(+%3

*'@&"..&*&. ".. /)1.'..&*:0'. 9<!./1".& ''&.& $

9& $.&$".&".& '' /& ''"&7*'.! 11.")".''.1.'..$&+%&&.") ''."")

.''.'. /"$&. .."& !'1&1*%%&. "&"&#



##( "&&1"001"&"& !".'&&.3/3 //9 &*/.$9 6

""?  9./ .&&.9/."&1..'./ * 2-'3;2('3)(

.&&./%!&1 &.  & $.9/.$". .."& !'". "&".3  9%.*$%%  '&".") "# )

'%!&1." . .'./ * ."$". 9%.*""".&'. ""."&  ((  /) "$$" 55

 /#



"



8



/1 !&'.."&&1&7./1.1)'.: !").&..'./ *"00 2-'32

('3)(+%3 /&7./1&1"001"&&*0&'"&.3)."+"'."+1.+."+'%:*&".

&3 ,(#D(D() @00"'". " *%%&. 9 &  ''3 / 5D,) 0'1$./.&'".

&"" *%%&. "+" / 5D,) '.$"&. *%'+&0) ."+ "'. "+1. + ."+

'%:*&".&3/5D)@00"'"."*%%&. 9 &  ''3/5D,)"&7./1

*&'"9 &  ''3)!&'"&&*0'.'$".9 &  ''3)"$&$/'"+" 3&1

+'.&7./1&.3#



001"&&*&.3*'@&"..&73."& 2-'32('3)(+%3#



"&". $7"&$".' *7&:  !" *."". "00&.  ".' $ + "&"& .3./1*1 +

"./1*1"+ '"1)"$&9 6*$"&"&". ""#



!"&..: !& &"".&3/.1."..'& 1'.++!/11." 21."&('3)('3

+(#



'.". *'./ 

!&/