Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Court Decisions Legislation Analyze in Legislator
4-07-6241\5 AI generated

4-07-6241\5 · 4-07-6241\5 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Põlvas

Case Number 4-07-6241\5
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia · Case Law (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Summary

AI generated

                                           ! " #   $ %  & " '! ( " ")* !   '! ! #! )    $ %  +!!, -  " ,  .        *! ! + ...

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full Text of the Judgment · 4-07-6241\5

                      

                    ! " #   $ %  & " '! ( " ")* !  

'! ! #! )

   $ %  +!!, -  " ,  .        *! ! +    "&! -  . /)( $"! !* 0  +  1)  (.   '!  2+  .        !  $ %  & "  '! ( " ")* !    '! ! #! )

  '

 "  (!(# '! ( "  '!  2 '!   ( 33456+ $"! !* 0  !     #  (     ''    &! 6  (! !()!(.   (  33454 +$)"&     6   #   ")!# !!   (      )!    &!    (! !()!(.'

")*    '' )!#!"( " "! "'

 !          ''  * " &)!  *'&  "- &  *'&  - !" ''   !   & !"

&    ''       ! &)! *!!      - !   ''      "$)"&     

  + .  "#$ %$    $%( "! ( & "+ "5.-!""* "")*    '! ! #!

)

 '! ( "  $"! !* 0  !     #  (    ''   &! 6  (!       6   #  (    )!    &!  (!()          '!  2( "! ( !  "!! + " .-!"""! -  $%      '! !(!" #(-(   '!  ( ( !

'!  ((7  88!  ) !  '! ( "$"! !* 0  !   (   '! !  &! 6 (!()$%( "#

59   "*'& "($%&'" 



'!  !"    '!  !&  &) "6 '!  !! ((  (' & "  ($%'!(  '!  !&  &) "6  '! ( "     6       '! !   &!    (! () $%    ( "#

  6   $%  ( 5    

'!  !"   '!  !&  &) "  1  & "    :  "#  ")*

 '! ( "  &! #! )

- !  &!!"!()  !   !:9' 

 '  " (! 54   !(   : 9 "#  * 5   !(!  "  !     

'!  - !   ) !  "! 88( 7   &''        ) !   !   !( ! " '   :9 '!&!!! #!-! *)!(  !     & "! !  !"   : 9 ")!  ( ' 

 #! ' #  "#! "# 1''  *"    '! ! #! ' # "#   &'"! ( "  *"     !  ) !" &)!    ) !"   '! ! #!( ")*  "   !  #"! '!&!!! " !#    '!  !!(# #!# 

! "-   #! '   " " 7( "   '! ( "  ( ( !!#! 94  " (!( 55    ""!((  !(#((   5 " (!(  (! 54   !(   : 6 '     '!  ! ! "# !!(#

'! ( " :6"# "     '!  *'   '! ( " "# !  &)"#(!"   !"    '!  ! &  &) " (!(#  &)"#(!" 

* (

'! (!&   "! '! !;  '!   !# $%(   ''   ! ! '! &!!  (( 7   88!   &'"! ( "    ) ! (!(#  '!  !!(# #!# ")  '! ! #!( #  ("!$%!  '! ! #! " !&)! "!  

!()     *! !(! (!  "!! + "4.-!""  "   *" "   $%  & "       6     "" &''    (   3 "#

 '! ( " ")* !   '! ! #!

)

 "  "  1  & "  ""!((  !(#((  6 '' ( 

  5+ . 69!

! " #  '! !( 9"#*5 "  !   &''         '!  - !   ) !  ( 88( 9  !(#((  ()  ''   !  # -   (!  '   " )"#(   ""!" -   #! '   " " 7( "   ( '! !  %!!#" ! " "     ''   &!!  !!#!   """#!! 94  " (!55 &'"(  !!#! ! ' #!    $%   ! !   (  

 ( '! !"   (!(#

'! ( "( "#

&)"#(! 6  # (   



'! !" #! '   " (!(# &  & "   ""!((  !(#((   6  ''  (   69 !

 ! "   '! ! #!( ")*  "   !  #"! '!&!!! " !#   ! )

 )( "  ""!((  !(#((   '' -   " (! '! !" *88 !( !( 7( ) ( " (!  !  !   '! & "  "- ! #  ! '(  #  ""  "

'!&!!! "#  9"#*'

 " *   '! ! #!(  - !" !! ! ) & "  "   !   (!  &)! !  ( 

'! ( "'!#( '! & ((!(#  '!  2&)"#(!  " (  !(& ! # "  !()!-!"""&)"#(!  # !(!"-( !( ) & " "  !  !   /)( $"! !* 0  ( "! (!  "!! + "9.-!"" " (

"   $ %  & " '! ( " ")* ! '

  "     $%  ")!# !!  (*88  '! !"< :55' 

 '  "

# ( '! ( " "# !(  '! ! !( "!"   :9"#*5 " )"#(  ""!" - -  #! '  " " "   7(( '! ! -!  $% '!    " !# (    1'' ( "  !+1 .:5"#4'  - " (! !*88  '! !" #  '! - ! ( 88(   : 9 "#  * 5 ' 

 ' #    &'"! ( "  &)!   '! !"*88 ! !" !"7  $"! ! ( ! "     :  "#   " - !  &!  &!(  '' 

' *'& !  &)!! 

  &! ! ' # !' #!    &!

'! ! ' # !"*!( (!(#&)"#(!"!"& -!"""!() *88 -      '!   !()   "" & "  &! ( !  !#  &  & "  :' 

";"   "(& " "! /)( $"! !* 0  - $ % *  "   :'

!   %  #     %$    1 :"#'  - '"& * 7! #" ! 7!(!(#  &'"!( " " (!&)! " (! '! !"!"(&   "  "# " (  " (! !(  &)!  &'"!( ( "  &)! " (!  &)!  " (! 

'! !" *88 (  &'"!( ( "  &)!     (!   '' #  ( " "!!   !  "!( "  :"#'  -   &! '! ! #! )

 '! ( "")* ! " (   '!  ! &)! &)"#(! & " " ( !"   '! ! (! ''    !(( (#" ( $%   & " *" #!    :  "#  ' 



  + . & "# - !"" " ( !( ( &)! "! !  "! ( " 1  :  "#  ' 

    ( *

 !!! =    '!  !    '!    !() 

 &! (!

 & " (!(# (((!"&)! " !  & " !  '"&    *  " &)! " " (   /)(  $"! !* 0  ! !  "! ! !



* (  :'   " ! :"# "      &! ( !(  !#   '!  ! & " ""'"&   !" #! ""! & "" ( !#   1 !"&)! &" &"  !!  ! + ".  '!  !!  (' & " + " 9.(  '!  2( " '!   , . (  33456-  '! ( " ( "#

 59       '! & (( *" $"! !* 0  !   (   ""$%  &! 6  (! () 59   ( $ %  &'" 

 '!   !"    '!  ! &  &) " 6   '!  !! ( 6     (( - !"" " $%!"&)! "! &!  -(>># *!!(& "!!  "   . (  33454-  '! ( " ( "#

 6       '! & ((  *"      6    &''    (    ""  &!    (! () 5   ( $ %  &'" 

 '!   !"    '!  !&  &) "  ;    '!   "  '!    &'"  !  (! &  !" &)! &" &"  !!  ! !(!5 ")"  '!    !(&")(

'!  !!(#- '!  !!  !(' # *" " & " (   '!    $%   ")!# !!     

#!  "  !(  ")!# !!    ! +< . : 55  "  ! "(  " ! 

'! !"-! !" '! !"*88 """" #!*'&   &   (! 54   !(   : 5"#   "  '! ( " "#

 !()  & " (!(# """ "!  '! (! ""  )"  '!   

'! ( " " !*'&   "(-  &'"!( "     ( '! !"*88 < :55' 

 '  "'!    !#  $%  "   '!    &    #"! '!&!!!  """  "  !( :6"# " "! '!   !(&)"#(!"   '!  !

!!(#* " '! ( " "# ! $%*"  & "! ( -  

'! ( "  " ! "!  "!$ "#!('  '!   33456 !! -   '!  ($%  ("!"  ( ""!(  6 ) !&'' ( "  !  !   !1 :5"#4 '  - " (! !*88  '! !"#  '! -!(88( :9"#*5 ' 

 ' #  &'"!( "  &)!   '! !"*88 ! ! " !"7    :  "#   "  ")*

 '! ( " &''       &'"! ( "  &)!   ""''   &!!() '! ! #!

)

-!  &!!"!()  !   !:9' 

 '  " 1!! (( !"  ( ((!54  !( :# 9  :9"#*5+(!4  !(   !(.'  -   !  

  4+ .

'!  -!&''  ) ! (88(7   !&  :9"#*5  " !     '!  -!&''     ) ! (88(   !   2 &  $%   ! ! # - " &''   '! ! #!    "   (! 4    :9 "# *5 ' 

 7   

' #  !#!  (!!  $"! !* 0  !          " *&   ((() ! -&)!"  - () ! !   < :  6"#' 

 '  88!";  *" '! ( " " !   ) (-*"#!( " "!  &'! (   "! -     : 9 "#  * 5 " )"#(   ""!" -     " ' 

 '   + ( "!!7   "  ) ! ." " "  &''   

   '! ! !  #"! '!&!!! ( "

 :9"#*5 ' 

 '  "-!!  '! !((  # !    &  *!! *  !  + !""  "   #! ! "  ! " ""!( !

 '! ( " " !(-& !  #"!")*"&!!!(.(  " !    & "   )!# ((! ( ! "-  ' 

  '! ! #! '   " "7( "  ( '! ! -( & "  ((!!  !(#((  !  ""!((  !(#((  + &   ""!((  !(#((   5  ''  &''   ( ? ""!((  !(#((  9  '' &''    69?   !(#((   5   ''  &''    (  6?   !(#((  5 ''  !!( "  ( 54.!     *  !  + &  &!!   ""!((  !(#((   " (!.  "  ( &''     " &  !!#!  """#!!94     ( 55  !( !&)"   !()! #! 7! & "  ! - !""  "  #! '  " "7( "  ( '! !   (   $%   &''     ( (!!     6    !  $"! !* 0  !        '! !  ( "

   : 9 "#  * 5 ' 

 '  "-!!!"((   '! !( #((!(# '! ( " ")* !* "  '!  !"&)!

! * !!&   '! !"+ '!   *" !    " !( 7 #! '!  !!(# .- !  ! " "  

'! ! #! )

 '! ( "")* !"   ! ()      *! ! ! # - !""  "  $%  ( !() & " !  (!      '! !(" )

  :9"#* ""* ( :9"#* " * &''  

   '! ! #!(  -!"!!!) & " "" "  !   (!  &)! !     "! -   &!   ' !(    "(&  &   "! ! '   " &)!   '!  ! *"  (  '    ! " & " &  '! ! ) & "!!(  :9"#* '(  '!   * " '!   !  !"!   " !(7 #! !!(#  &! !()! !!#!  """#!    ( 554 ! "-   &! ! ) & "!!(! !( 7( &!  &   "! !

 !- & ! "" "" " )!  77"   !!&  #& - !

&)!   '!  !" '! ( "  !' 

 !   '!    &)!  &'"! ( "      &! '   !

 !  " (

  + .   '!  !" &)! "!     ""   ! ' 

  !-   *88  !()&)"#(!& "&)!  "    &! ( !   !#   '!  !"(  ' #!()( '! ! & !)!#- #       

"(& ! ! " -' #!*' "  )!# #"    '"&      '!      '! (!"