Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
1-07-11867\7 AI generated

1-07-11867\7 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 1-07-11867\7
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

 &"-'"&,) D!&&%&-"&,&&"- ( "!-&"%&&,2+"-/) " '- & ,& D!&& E"C"-&&' %&&, &"-" +"-'-& -&"- '"& +"," ,"&"$ - - % " "2 " %+(  !" ' !- '55"& 2/& ," /  4/% / %5-&/) '"4-% /%& -  &"-'""&) 4+!,&25&,/"%& - &"-'"&!-  +&$ !",& ()&-64  " 7,&,% %  )'&,-%& - 8&$ '5 >: &"--"& /",,-$  %%&&"-  (  C!&" 4  /  , -&" $' "- #?$  $ &"-  (  2  -& ,'&"/& C!&'"-'"-&""& 87!&'",&4 4  /  -&, 9)   ) #$9$#?) 9) : , """& 2- -/) &- ,'&"/ 4& % / C!&'  -& -/ %&-"/& "&,,&", D!&& &/"%&-"$ D!&& &/"%&-"2+"-"&"-"!-&"#$"&4-&'(,#$ "- ,)"&"-&"-&" -#$2,#$ "- ,4 +4,-%5,2 -""#J?J784 / & - 2 1J?)$$#)+-""#$2#)D!&&E"C"-&&'5"-,&% -& D!&&  "5-&-& ! ,/ '"& !-  .&!!  ( ") &"-  ( ") 5-  ( ")    ( ") ,-   ( ") F,   ( ") ,%&&   ( " 2  ,%   ( ":) ',,& ! "&,- &/ ,'&"/ %+% / D!&& E"C"-&&' 8D!&&&"-E"C"-&&': &/ /  , -&"$"&4-&'("-#$ "- "-$ ' "& " / &"-  (   "C"-&&'  &/ /  , -&" $"&4-&'("- #$ ) "&"- % "- 4,/%+&-/&"-4+!'55"8D!&&E"C"-&&',&"- "- '&2  &"- 4/ '"& 4+!'55") #$"&4-&'(& #$ )  #?:) '"  %+&-/ % "- #$"&4-&'(,#$ "- ,"&,,&"- 2 "- &"- ( " &/ /$ %%&%&D!&&  &/"%&-" -,   ! "&,- -"- "& &"&'&/) '/   % 2 , &"-/ $ ,% /%  "- -/"+//)%  "- -//'&//2&$  "- -/ "+//," " /'&( ",& -/ !%"% !&,""&%  "- -/"+/-& /'&( " 8&/ "4/>:$ 64  " 7,&,%)/ " ' ,-%  "- -/%& - ),%  "- -/"+/-& &"-"  ""&"- -/  /'&( " 

Legislator headnote

AI generated

1-07-11867\7 · Viru Ringkonnakohus:  &"-'"&,) D!&&%&-"&,&&"- ( "!-&"%&&,2+"-/) " '- & ,& D!&& E"C"-&&' %&&, &"-" +"-'-& -&"- '"& +"," ,"&"$ - - % " "2 " %+(  !" ' !- '55"& 2/& ," /  4/% / %5-&/) '"4-% /%& -  &"-'""&) 4+!,&25&,/"%& - &"-'"&!-  +&$ !",& ()&-64  " 7,&,% %  )'&,-%& - 8&$ '5 >: &"--"& /",,-$  %%&&"-  (  C!&" 4  /  , -&" $' "- #?$  $ &"-  (  2  -& ,'&"/& C!&'"-'"-&""& 87!&'",&4 4  /  -&, 9)   ) #$9$#?) 9) : , """& 2- -/) &- ,'&"/ 4& % / C!&'  -& -/ %&-"/& "&,,&", D!&& &/"%&-"$ D!&& &/"%&-"2+"-"&"-"!-&"#$"&4-&'(,#$ "- ,)"&"-&"-&" -#$2,#$ "- ,4 +4,-%5,2 -""#J?J784 / & - 2 1J?)$$#)+-""#$2#)D!&&E"C"-&&'5"-,&% -& D!&&  "5-&-& ! ,/ '"& !-  .&!!  ( ") &"-  ( ") 5-  ( ")    ( ") ,-   ( ") F,   ( ") ,%&&   ( " 2  ,%   ( ":) ',,& ! "&,- &/ ,'&"/ %+% / D!&& E"C"-&&' 8D!&&&"-E"C"-&&': &/ /  , -&"$"&4-&'("-#$ "- "-$ ' "& " / &"-  (   "C"-&&'  &/ /  , -&" $"&4-&'("- #$ ) "&"- % "- 4,/%+&-/&"-4+!'55"8D!&&E"C"-&&',&"- "- '&2  &"- 4/ '"& 4+!'55") #$"&4-&'(& #$ )  #?:) '"  %+&-/ % "- #$"&4-&'(,#$ "- ,"&,,&"- 2 "- &"- ( " &/ /$ %%&%&D!&&  &/"%&-" -,   ! "&,- -"- "& &"&'&/) '/   % 2 , &"-/ $ ,% /%  "- -/"+//)%  "- -//'&//2&$  "- -/ "+//," " /'&( ",& -/ !%"% !&,""&%  "- -/"+/-& /'&( " 8&/ "4/>:$ 64  " 7,&,%)/ " ' ,-%  "- -/%& - ),%  "- -/"+/-& &"-"  ""&"- -/  /'&( " 

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

   

            !"   

    #$%&'(&#$ )*+!%         

!! ,'-. -%)&% &% ), /'0 ,       #1$-(&#$ )*+!%       !-  %  !-' 2  #3$ "&4-&'( #$  '55"%   &"-'"&!-        64  " 78&"-/93931) "!-&& # /:  % /& /% - '"       4 -  %  "    4;&- &<%  !"#$ %&    #     '(& )

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

!"%+--" %&""&)&-%& - &$'5 > &"-! ,/ '&-+&"- ( "&,,& %& - %++ / '"-    %5,"' ,& %   %5,2 /'"& C"'"& , !&/ '"&$ -,"&," -/' -&2 ,/&"-5!-()&-'&- -//' % - !%"% !&,"&,-

-  -"- %  %  "- -/ "+/ D!&& E"C"-&&'  / 2  ,"&,-  - &"-&&-/ ,, /"8&-!&, /":&$'5 F>*$

     8?: # 

      1& !- % !-' 2 #3$"&4-&'(#$ '55"&4& ,&&"- "64  " 7

8 ,,2 "- " &"/ 2  % /& /% -   '": '55" &("&) ',,&" 4 ,( ' !- '55" -C!"- /  2  -&!  " '55") ',,&  25--  4; %   &"-'"& - -,"  !,/ ' - )%& - % ,/" / %%- ' -,-C,&64  " 7,&$  (& 55" &("&&"- 2 ,& ()&-%   &"-'"&"4/("& /", ,"$

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

55"&"%/ -/D!&&E"C"-&&'&,&&"-,&"/%$D!&&%&-"&,& &"- ( "!-&"%&&,2+"-/$

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

 &"-'"&,) D!&&%&-"&,&&"- ( "!-&"%&&,2+"-/) " '- & ,& D!&& E"C"-&&' %&&, &"-" +"-'-& -&"- '"& +"," ,"&"$ - - % " "2 " %+(  !" ' !- '55"& 2/& ," /  4/% / %5-&/) '"4-% /%& -  &"-'""&) 4+!,&25&,/"%& - &"-'"&!-  +&$ !",& ()&-64  " 7,&,% %  )'&,-%& - 8&$ '5 >: &"--"& /",,-$  %%&&"-  (  C!&" 4  /  , -&" $' "- #?$  $ &"-  (  2  -& ,'&"/& C!&'"-'"-&""& 87!&'",&4 4  /  -&, 9)   ) #$9$#?) 9) : , """& 2- -/) &- ,'&"/ 4& % / C!&'  -& -/ %&-"/& "&,,&", D!&& &/"%&-"$ D!&& &/"%&-"2+"-"&"-"!-&"#$"&4-&'(,#$ "- ,)"&"-&"-&" -#$2,#$ "- ,4 +4,-%5,2 -""#J?J784 / & - 2 1J?)$$#)+-""#$2#)D!&&E"C"-&&'5"-,&% -& D!&&  "5-&-& ! ,/ '"& !-  .&!!  ( ") &"-  ( ") 5-  ( ")    ( ") ,-   ( ") F,   ( ") ,%&&   ( " 2  ,%   ( ":) ',,& ! "&,- &/ ,'&"/ %+% / D!&& E"C"-&&' 8D!&&&"-E"C"-&&': &/ /  , -&"$"&4-&'("-#$ "- "-$ ' "& " / &"-  (   "C"-&&'  &/ /  , -&" $"&4-&'("- #$ ) "&"- % "- 4,/%+&-/&"-4+!'55"8D!&&E"C"-&&',&"- "- '&2  &"- 4/ '"& 4+!'55") #$"&4-&'(& #$ )  #?:) '"  %+&-/ % "- #$"&4-&'(,#$ "- ,"&,,&"- 2 "- &"- ( " &/ /$ %%&%&D!&&  &/"%&-" -,   ! "&,- -"- "& &"&'&/) '/   % 2 , &"-/ $ ,% /%  "- -/"+//)%  "- -//'&//2&$  "- -/ "+//," " /'&( ",& -/ !%"% !&,""&%  "- -/"+/-& /'&( " 8&/ "4/>:$ 64  " 7,&,%)/ " ' ,-%  "- -/%& - ),%  "- -/"+/-& &"-"  ""&"- -/  /'&( " 

-  -"- % "+/$ D!&&  &/"%&-" -,! "&,--,&(%  "- -/"+/4/ / $  "- -/ "+/-&4/ '"& ,"&">2  /'&( "/&"""& &$

     8?: ? ,&&% ,- B?,3"5--&"-&/ ",C ' --&,2!-/&,%+(%5,"- -,"&,%   &"-/  %+ -&!  ,5(-"'"& && %   %5,2 /'"& - -,"& " '"-$  !- "-,  -% "- -/) &- - -," %   %5,2 /'"&"- 5&",&% " 2 " %5,""- 4,& " //$  )    /, ,- -% "- -/) &- %  "- -/ %  ) '&,- %& -   ,- -/  -&4,    D!&& E"C"-&&' 8>:  /  !%"% !&,"&,-

-  -"- % ") "" "&, 2!, "& /" /2  ,( ( C, ,'&- -/ %   &"-/  && %   %5,2 /'"&- -,"&" '"-%  %++ / '"&-+&"- '"&&&"'5,$ &&2&"%  %5,2 /'"&- -,"%+(,, &"- -/  45 "-"&/ )-& / )',,"&" %5,""-&&,,-%  "- -/%   "($  %'&"2 ,)&-%& - ' 4,& ,/"+/%++ / '"-)&   ,"-"&,,& &"- ,- % ( "- '"&")   &"-  (   %+-/ &/ ,&  !%"% !&,"& !"-"& %  "- -/&"&'&/-  "- / %5,",&$7, ,'&- -/"+/%  "- -/%5,""- 4,&  %5,"- -/ "2 ,) &- "+/ &"-  ( " &"-&&-/ '  "%( 45 "- -& / " '"-)&-"+/%  "- -/)"&/ %++ / / $ 7!-, " -,&( ",' " 4/ / ) &- "+/%55-"%+("&,,& "- '"&,%5!&&/ %+!4" "-"'-/  "-"+,(' -")5-&""&,,& -'(,,"+&-"$ %'&%&&"- ( "&!-(D!&& &/"%&-"" ,"&,- , -&"$' "-#?$ $ & - 4&&-##$"&4-&'(,#$ "- ,)2( &!-"E"C"-&&'-5&"- "& /",,-$ / "2&" -,&( '5/ ) &- %  "- -/ "+/&/ -"- "&   -&4,   ,-& /)&-"&4,&"%& -4/ '"&!&-&,&!-/)-,&"&"-  ( "4/ / -&4,-& -"& ,"&,$  %0&HB13! "&,-&-&!& ""&-% ,/"-)"&&,5/' - !-&% "- "&,- -&' % ,/"&"-%5,2 $ %& - " ' ,-%  "- -/)&-&/64  " 7, !& ""&-% ,/"- "2  C,&$ 64  " 7,&,% %& -  &,&+"% "- "&,- &"--/)"&,,&",/"& /",/ ,"&/$  % ,/ 2 ,+" !2/&!C%- '"&" 4;;// !-""&"% "-)&,,&,-%  ' / -$  5!-/&" &&,-/"- 2  2!//&"   BB/&"- 91 2  91 25- (  !" 

!-  %  !-' 2  #3$"&4-&'( #$  '55"& %   &"-'"& !-  '-' -  '55" &("& !,/ ' - $          

!! ,'-. -%   &% &%    , /'0 ,  !-     !-   !-