Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1-07-7024\6 AI generated

1-07-7024\6 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 1-07-7024\6
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

   

Legislator headnote

AI generated

1-07-7024\6 · Viru Ringkonnakohus:    

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

   

            !"   

    #$%$ &'(!)      *+   

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

     *+  %&(& !". -". .,"0 ! "0,.   !.,"." .(05 .5 '0,0  3% ""  A.,".0 %  ;!."A5 -,A,0"."."0  " !.,". . ) .0A.,".0 .-.00"05". ) .0 .A. , ".0) !05 -"0!. ,0.50,0 ! 00".;50) ,.,-0 ". %",$ %&(&%&1:."-"0, ,0.  !.,". . )  0,! ". 9 9999  ) ". ;"..." ) !05 -"0,0). ) 50"0-05$ !.,"."0 ,"0"," " ".(055B 0". :  ! ;AA) .,";.,,C .0".0 !.,". . ) .0;5 -"0;.,,5C ,1:."-".0;.,,5C .". % '$ $A.,"05&-,,0! "0,.. .00,0:;"..." &" 50"05 ,0.. " D*" 5 )"A--05+,05;,.) !05 % ,0- ".56D".".$00  .10, ," !.,". 5 '0,0 3% "" . ?@2,;%1) ,<."00. ) .0 .-0; 0-"0"$  (& ;7 = ,,0;0 -1") !". -". .,"0"&0.'0,0 3% "" A,, ) 0- ". - . &5.05  !.,". . "00"-0"0 ".-0.0.-0; 0-"0"&-,,000".  ". . "0"AA5-(".-"0 ,6 ". "0) "."0 $ (&%&'0,0 3% "" .00)","A".00-0& "00.5% ; % ,0&-""0"0",,50 % ."0"% .00)"0 ,5 -"0".00,,.00," 55 ! ; % ,"0"" -"0"%  % . -"0"$ 00   ,". ) . & 0. ) : 5"0" ):50" )(:  !.,". . ) '0,0  3% ""  %1. . .050.-0; 0-".&-!, "-(%. 5 .". % 5)(!1). 5 .(0505$ (&(& -.  '0,0  3% ""  5 5""0. & .77.& ) ,, ,0& 0,,0, ;5) 5 0".  : "A, ,;00. ) 5. 0, :A"$ . - . 0,! - -"0,0&;5) 5. ,0".  :   "5) 5 !"."05& -".(..  ,". 00,5 5 & 0. ) ".."0". %   "."0". ) : 0-"000"-1,)(:. *'0,0 3% "" + "5 0 ".) % - & "05 50")(-.0" )(- ."!.00,"0-00.,"0%1. -"0)(!.-00.,"0$00 .,0:'0,0 3% ""  ) !". 5 &0.. 0" "%1.) ,..0"5.-0;  &"0 ,!, "-(%. 5 .". % 5%  !1). 5 &-. )()(,."5 .(0505% ; - $  -&!."., *- !."+ .0. "  ;7 -  . .,".  ; ,"  !.,". . ) '0,0 3% "" ) !". 5 . .,"0".55;(!%05".0,*,$+$ -&%& !.,". . ) 0 ,5 ("  ;7 . .,"0 & ; ," %1..  05 ) : 5""0$ 0,0. "& 0. .   ) ,5 2 8 .77)(-0."0 & . ,  ! ,: .0)"& -0,. 10",0) , % , , !.010,-5$ -&(&& ."%  ; ," %1..  . .,"  !,5 - . &    !.,". . )  ! 0 -00& ) 0- - , " ". - . & ;7)1.05- ) 5,0. . ) ."0,-$  )& !" 5" -  $% $ ".  ) !". -"-11"0  *,$+  ,   !.,". . )  '0,0 3% "" ) !". -"0"$ )&%& !" .) ". "& 0. '0,0  3% "" .  !.,". . "0 0"-0"0  "" ".-0 .0 .-0; 0-"0"&-,,000"."0 5"0! "0,.0..01!.56 ". .) ".".&. *'0,0  3% "" +  5 5""0.  "& .77.& 0, : A"$ '0,0  3% ""  .00)" , "A".00-0&  "00.5 %  ; % ,0& -" "0"0" ,,50 % ."0" %  .00)"0  ,5 -"0"  .00,,.00," 55 ! ; % ,"0"" -"0"% % . -"0"$ 00 - !. ) .0" ;" ) ,. ,". ) . &0.'0,0 3% "" )(:) : 5""0%1150" %1. .  .050 .-0; 0-". %  !55  () ,0 !.00,"0". -"0". %  !.".& -!, "-(%. 5 .". % 5 "5 .(0505!1). - &-.- )()(,."- $ 

     

     *+ 6 .& !.  )  !.- %  $% $  ) !". -"-11"0 ;0 ,0 0". "  !.,". . )'0,0 3% "" -11" 0:"0&-,,0"; ,:) : ". 5 . ) ! ,.$ 1:&0. .  2 8 , ."0" .77)(-0.$ ". .5  !.,"."0 ! "0,. .". " .  05 "AA5 .10" , ."0"$  0-  - , "  ". - . $: :". 5  :- ,-00.,"0"%  ,-5 ."0.0;0 ,0-00.,0% %50$ 0 ) ."0!.00,"0".-"0".() ,0!55 &  . ,,0- "50,0,!.$  /& !. "., %1  ;7

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

     *+  .55 "% ,5*28.77)(-0. .".% )150. )) ,-",0 , % ,-00.,0% %50 ,-5 +$

11" 0:"0" 0". .5 )1.05 '0,0  3% ""  .0)", "0"5 %  ;5 -"!  .-".0 A,0 ;,0 10",0) , %!, "% ! "05   .(05 ) , " " "% ""0 -..0;.) 5$ '0,0  3% ""  .0)", "0"5 ! ,)00-". .0) 5 )(- ,5 ;:,00-5, !05 :;5 -"!  5-". ."$ 0,.5. )0". 50". .,"'0,0 3% "" "!.0") ,.5.(05.A!". -"0" ,"0.$  1!.50" 00,.5". %  %!550"   ??50". 6# %  6# %1. :  !" ) !". -"-11"0-.- . -11" 0:"0 !,5 - . $     

!! ,-./ .)  0) 0)    

 " !.    !.    !.