Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
1-06-6345\9 AI generated

1-06-6345\9 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 1-06-6345\9
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

  +' ! "#)11,5'88#!0;#0'!10.!/50!)'88#!0;#0,85010!)/05#) 01'88#!0;# 7+".05!'!1.!!"/5!'#0/00/&  1'88#!0;#0 '!10.!/50#1 8"1;) 01  "# 1?"#1!# '! &'! $&!  "1 1##0! 880 !! "1 (&501#0'; $&! .!   ! "1 %& 1 ; $&!  "1 1##05 #!/#0/1) '0/1 #??5'+#101 ! '!#0 #??51#1!'#0#.!!#1!'#0#,!  >750)(.8/1!#1#0'+#1'#0#& ?"#1!15 #!# / '!!/!# #!!5015 0# !1!'#0#  !! "1 !,00  "1'!.!/0& C"1/!# 1?"#1!1 180//1 ! 880 !! "1 %&.!!! $&!  "1'88#/1!#1#0'+#1'#0#!'!#0/0& !'!#0#??51#1!'#0#  >/$750)$.!.8.!10'!!#1!'#0# 0 !!#1!#0 ,!#1#0! .811#  "# 880 !! "1  (&501#0'; $&! .!  ! "1%& 1 ;$&! 1##05'1'!1!)#0018"05!;)01?/!/'01!15 1##05.85.+##0& !  "1 1##0!  1?"#1!15 ! 880 !! "1 %&.!!! $&!  "1'88# /1!#1#0 '+#1'#0# ! '!#0/0) ## 10# / 5) # ! '!#!!;!#!#1#1!"0 1##0 "!#0/1)#& & !.!! "1$3&#0710';$&! 1##0.8/1!#1#0! !#1##0!5#1-05!#75 !2>/$!/#0/0/!!#1!10/ 5 .! ?# 780,! ,!#1#1) !#1#!.! !/#0! $3&#0710';0 $&! .! 880 !! "1(&501#0';$&! 1##0 "!#0/1  >/$750)$.!.8'+#1015 0!!#1!##0,!#1#0!& 001+11 ' 5#1!# '!! "# '! !/! ."1 ! 1! 1/#0 !/#0/  ."550# '!!/'001/#0#0!5#1-05!#75 2>>.!+5'#0#1#??5'+#101/0 !'!#0/00/1!#1#0)#& #!!#1!1,!#1#1-/&$2  2' !1#.!,!50!5, !!1 '!#/7,850)01."/)!'!#080# /0,!/!.!/ 00  "1 1##0 100'#1 !!; 8! '88#0# 1 55 !#1#0 #!) #1 # !!#1!1 !/!10# (&#0710';#1$&!.! "#/0!;!/#010'!#??51#1!'#0#!  >750.!( .8) '+#10# #!'!##0 !#1#0 ?''0 !!#1!1 ,!;!5#0! 1#1) !/!; 10'! .! # !#1#!.!/0'0 "1 1##0100'#0#1)#10 /0,+'!/ !>/01108"15 !#1#0/1'0.!!'!#18",!5!;0!!/0,+'!/#,;5!,!#1#0#?''0 !!#1!!#0'0/#10#1!!#1!1)  /01#& ! 1/00; '88#!0;#0 '!10.!/50#1 ,!5/#1!#5 !1#.!5,!50!5, !!55 !   '! .! '!# /7 !70//!1#  .! !##!1#   !# '!! "1 .!  ! "1 1##05& !! "1 .!  ! "1 1##05  1?"#1!15  "1 1##0! !1#.!10 !##!1# 50!/#0/& 2'&'8"150# >/.!#81010#10,+78!#1 1##101?"#1!'#1+0'! "1

Legislator headnote

AI generated

1-06-6345\9 · Viru Ringkonnakohus:   +' ! "#)11,5'88#!0;#0'!10.!/50!)'88#!0;#0,85010!)/05#) 01'88#!0;# 7+".05!'!1.!!"/5!'#0/00/&  1'88#!0;#0 '!10.!/50#1 8"1;) 01  "# 1?"#1!# '! &'! $&!  "1 1##0! 880 !! "1 (&501#0'; $&! .!   ! "1 %& 1 ; $&!  "1 1##05 #!/#0/1) '0/1 #??5'+#101 ! '!#0 #??51#1!'#0#.!!#1!'#0#,!  >750)(.8/1!#1#0'+#1'#0#& ?"#1!15 #!# / '!!/!# #!!5015 0# !1!'#0#  !! "1 !,00  "1'!.!/0& C"1/!# 1?"#1!1 180//1 ! 880 !! "1 %&.!!! $&!  "1'88#/1!#1#0'+#1'#0#!'!#0/0& !'!#0#??51#1!'#0#  >/$750)$.!.8.!10'!!#1!'#0# 0 !!#1!#0 ,!#1#0! .811#  "# 880 !! "1  (&501#0'; $&! .!  ! "1%& 1 ;$&! 1##05'1'!1!)#0018"05!;)01?/!/'01!15 1##05.85.+##0& !  "1 1##0!  1?"#1!15 ! 880 !! "1 %&.!!! $&!  "1'88# /1!#1#0 '+#1'#0# ! '!#0/0) ## 10# / 5) # ! '!#!!;!#!#1#1!"0 1##0 "!#0/1)#& & !.!! "1$3&#0710';$&! 1##0.8/1!#1#0! !#1##0!5#1-05!#75 !2>/$!/#0/0/!!#1!10/ 5 .! ?# 780,! ,!#1#1) !#1#!.! !/#0! $3&#0710';0 $&! .! 880 !! "1(&501#0';$&! 1##0 "!#0/1  >/$750)$.!.8'+#1015 0!!#1!##0,!#1#0!& 001+11 ' 5#1!# '!! "# '! !/! ."1 ! 1! 1/#0 !/#0/  ."550# '!!/'001/#0#0!5#1-05!#75 2>>.!+5'#0#1#??5'+#101/0 !'!#0/00/1!#1#0)#& #!!#1!1,!#1#1-/&$2  2' !1#.!,!50!5, !!1 '!#/7,850)01."/)!'!#080# /0,!/!.!/ 00  "1 1##0 100'#1 !!; 8! '88#0# 1 55 !#1#0 #!) #1 # !!#1!1 !/!10# (&#0710';#1$&!.! "#/0!;!/#010'!#??51#1!'#0#!  >750.!( .8) '+#10# #!'!##0 !#1#0 ?''0 !!#1!1 ,!;!5#0! 1#1) !/!; 10'! .! # !#1#!.!/0'0 "1 1##0100'#0#1)#10 /0,+'!/ !>/01108"15 !#1#0/1'0.!!'!#18",!5!;0!!/0,+'!/#,;5!,!#1#0#?''0 !!#1!!#0'0/#10#1!!#1!1)  /01#& ! 1/00; '88#!0;#0 '!10.!/50#1 ,!5/#1!#5 !1#.!5,!50!5, !!55 !   '! .! '!# /7 !70//!1#  .! !##!1#   !# '!! "1 .!  ! "1 1##05& !! "1 .!  ! "1 1##05  1?"#1!15  "1 1##0! !1#.!10 !##!1# 50!/#0/& 2'&'8"150# >/.!#81010#10,+78!#1 1##101?"#1!'#1+0'! "1

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

  

            ! "#  

     

    $%&'!$(&!)*+",-.!/'001/#2          $3&'!$(&!)*+",           ""!/ '14!1 ,)0,!0,!)/!5' 6!/!        !! "1 !,00  "1'!.! &!7// $(&! '88# ! '!#0/0 /1!#1#0 ' 5#1!'#0  "1!   ! '!#  # 5 ($($) 0/ "1 99999) 9999 : -80# /0,!/ !.!/ ,;; 75!'# "!#2  

     !'!#0!1#.!,!50!5, !!1 '!#/7  !"#$% &'         ()'   *))+'      &),,(-.   /           0  

      '  5!#!0;!'#0 5             

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

     -2     



  +' ! "#)11,5'88#!0;#0'!10.!/50!)'88#!0;#0,85010!)/05#) 01'88#!0;# 7+".05!'!1.!!"/5!'#0/00/&  1'88#!0;#0 '!10.!/50#1 8"1;) 01  "# 1?"#1!# '! &'! $&!  "1 1##0! 880 !! "1 (&501#0'; $&! .!   ! "1 %& 1 ; $&!  "1 1##05 #!/#0/1) '0/1 #??5'+#101 ! '!#0 #??51#1!'#0#.!!#1!'#0#,!  >750)(.8/1!#1#0'+#1'#0#& ?"#1!15 #!# / '!!/!# #!!5015 0# !1!'#0#  !! "1 !,00  "1'!.!/0& C"1/!# 1?"#1!1 180//1 ! 880 !! "1 %&.!!! $&!  "1'88#/1!#1#0'+#1'#0#!'!#0/0& !'!#0#??51#1!'#0#  >/$750)$.!.8.!10'!!#1!'#0# 0 !!#1!#0 ,!#1#0! .811#  "# 880 !! "1  (&501#0'; $&! .!  ! "1%& 1 ;$&! 1##05'1'!1!)#0018"05!;)01?/!/'01!15 1##05.85.+##0& !  "1 1##0!  1?"#1!15 ! 880 !! "1 %&.!!! $&!  "1'88# /1!#1#0 '+#1'#0# ! '!#0/0) ## 10# / 5) # ! '!#!!;!#!#1#1!"0 1##0 "!#0/1)#& & !.!! "1$3&#0710';$&! 1##0.8/1!#1#0! !#1##0!5#1-05!#75 !2>/$!/#0/0/!!#1!10/ 5 .! ?# 780,! ,!#1#1) !#1#!.! !/#0! $3&#0710';0 $&! .! 880 !! "1(&501#0';$&! 1##0 "!#0/1  >/$750)$.!.8'+#1015 0!!#1!##0,!#1#0!& 001+11 ' 5#1!# '!! "# '! !/! ."1 ! 1! 1/#0 !/#0/  ."550# '!!/'001/#0#0!5#1-05!#75 2>>.!+5'#0#1#??5'+#101/0 !'!#0/00/1!#1#0)#& #!!#1!1,!#1#1-/&$2  2' !1#.!,!50!5, !!1 '!#/7,850)01."/)!'!#080# /0,!/!.!/ 00  "1 1##0 100'#1 !!; 8! '88#0# 1 55 !#1#0 #!) #1 # !!#1!1 !/!10# (&#0710';#1$&!.! "#/0!;!/#010'!#??51#1!'#0#!  >750.!( .8) '+#10# #!'!##0 !#1#0 ?''0 !!#1!1 ,!;!5#0! 1#1) !/!; 10'! .! # !#1#!.!/0'0 "1 1##0100'#0#1)#10 /0,+'!/ !>/01108"15 !#1#0/1'0.!!'!#18",!5!;0!!/0,+'!/#,;5!,!#1#0#?''0 !!#1!!#0'0/#10#1!!#1!1)  /01#& ! 1/00; '88#!0;#0 '!10.!/50#1 ,!5/#1!#5 !1#.!5,!50!5, !!55 !   '! .! '!# /7 !70//!1#  .! !##!1#   !# '!! "1 .!  ! "1 1##05& !! "1 .!  ! "1 1##05  1?"#1!15  "1 1##0! !1#.!10 !##!1# 50!/#0/& 2'&'8"150# >/.!#81010#10,+78!#1 1##101?"#1!'#1+0'! "1

7 /1 '!!/!#.! 0/ !1!'#0/ 0#'0#0 !#1'0  "# '+#1! #??5#1!1!,!/0 !#0'!1 !#1#1)  #00) '# / '+#1015 1?"#1!15 0#'0#0 !#1'0  "1 1##0!& !'! +0 0"1;!/1!#1#0' 5#1!'#0 "1!10"1!,!'88#07"/&  &)'!! "1 &!7// $(&! '88#0 0# /1, #!# -/&2  '815) 01 ! '!#0/0 !>/$.!/!/#0/' 5#1!15-880!! "1(&501#0'; $&! "1 1##0!!#1##!!#1!1,!#1#1.! !.!! "1$3&#0710';$&!  "1 1##0!/1!#1#0/!!#1!1)0/5.!?#780,,!#1#12/1!#1#0!0# !!#1!1,!#1#1/0;(&#0710';#1$&!&

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