Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
1-07-5025\3 AI generated

1-07-5025\3 · Pärnu Maakohus Pärnu kohtumaja Kuninga tänaval

Case Number 1-07-5025\3
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

        

Legislator headnote

AI generated

1-07-5025\3 · Pärnu Maakohus Pärnu kohtumaja Kuninga tänaval:         

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

        

           !"#    

  $%&$ !"'%(  

        !"'& )! & *+&,, #* *'-&!,.#/"%&.' '0, 1*, -,.& 

2,,& * #     -.*.-! ' !!%#* * -.*.-! '&*&#  

   22.&#'#*# 345,6+7(389,6+(6&(

345,6+(389,6+(6& ! ,*++*%**',#*#          7&#&  !!. &%&, !# &#''.*&!,*$

0 *.-"&#'%&* !",.'.8$$:$       

   &#&  !!. 4997 &%&, !# &#''.*&!,*$

0 *.-"&#'%&* !",.'.8$$:$   !"  ;"&..*# 354,6+(359(6&7 !"#!'##'#  22.&'&#'.     (%0&#'',,* &#'#* #<

345,6+7(6&8 !,% #''(4 "* #  .-6&#'#'=

389,6+(6&8 !,% #''-6&#'#'$

 3 :8 ,6  ( :5 ,6  ,#*, ,6*. *6*% &#'# *' # # *% &#'#*6 ( ,&&' &#'#* #%0&#'8 !,% #''(4 "* #  .-6&#'#'$$ #'-,'  3 5 ,6  ,) ,&# &#'#* !",.%&#*,* &&6&#' -,(#'%&* !!# #&##*#0&. ,6-&&* # #' #$ #'-,' 3:4,6,6*.,-6&#'#*#-&&)&'.*6,'*#4$$:$ &$$$$ &#'#(", $

  

&#'#(,6#'-''*%,,'*#4$$:$$

0 *.-"&#'%&*'2"&#'. !"'!'##*(0#'%&#*,$  22.&'&#'.  

  (%0&#'',,* &#'#* #<

345,6+(6&8 !,% #''(: #  .-6&#'#'=

389,6+(6&  # #''-6&#'#'$

 3 :8 ,6  ( 3 :5 ,6  ,#*, ,6*. *6*% &#'# *' # # *% &#'#*6 ( ,&&' &#'#* #%0&#'8 !,% #'': .-6&#'#'$ #'-,'  3 5 ,6  ,) ,&# &#'#* !",.%&#*,* &&6&#' -,(#'%&* !!# #&##*#0&. ,6-&&* # #' #$ #'-,' 3:4,6,6*.,-6&#'#*#-&&)&'.*6,'*#4$$: &$$$$  &#'#(", $

&#'#(,6#'-''*%,,'*#4$$:$

0 *.-"&#'%&*'2"&#'. !"'!'##*(0#'%&#*,$  ,(%0&#' *&(# ''& #>*,' (&.6#!&#?*,' %%,' &&&6&',.*##*#." 9 !!&( !!+&'*'*6*%&#*'#7 !!&$ ,(%0&#'*&(#''& #>*,'(&.6#!&#?*,'#!,&.#*,'&&6&',.*##*<  $  !!'&,&#*&** #+*'&&#8:5$ !!& $ @* #+*'&&#55$ !!& 8$ 0%*(,( #+*'&&#$ !!&  ,(%0&#'*&(#''& #*,'&&6&',.*##*&&6&0&6#)&#'7: !!&$ ,(%0&#'&.6#!&#*,'&&6&',.*##*&&6&0&6#)&#'8487 !!&$ 

0, * ,. !6#%%#8$ !!&(''&&6& .$ %%. '#. 8 +*- (!! #, ".#%&&#'&%& -*,.#-*,* 854  *#'&A"&#+6#7-0& #+6#84::-&&'*%)*459:9:#*,6&'#B&%& %**',# ,.C$

& ",&#*. 0.*. +!,* '"'*6#*,' '#'. #' #* 0.*. '&'*%**',#* ,)&-&&%&#* # !"''&'&,*'&'*%**',#*,#'%&#* ##*.#'& ##'*#''. !#$ #'-,' 389,65(348,65 ,)-#''. !!'&,&*&*%##&656%%&7  6%%& (  6%%&7 %&# ! "!&, !"'* #+*'&&#& ( &%&,&#'&  *# #*#7 !D&# &%&#*,*$ 

&%&,#((*##-.(6%&#*.#&'0*.&.< $  '4989548+ *.  $ %!)&&,'*,*D!! & !!.&68:8458:47%&,,*# ' 4988954+ *.          8$  '498958988+ *.    E@+,' '&.*(%!)&&,'*,*D!&-',#*.%*'*6+ *.    

 

*# &%&,+!,&'#*&#&'0*.&'*"!&.,##-.(6%&#*.#&'0*.&.< $ ,6*&&.*'2  $ !"*,&*D,&&#+,,!-* 8$ 0,& #' 5$ !,%+,#'+.*,&'

 0&.'!*' !,*.!*6:87%&##) *# &%&,+!,&'#*& #'#*#!,*-#-,-*6

 8  + ,#7'*"&,&#*+##&!&6&,#)+ *.&#     

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

 5  #%6&,(38,68#''*&.7%&,,* !"#*,'!# !6# !!'&,&#*-0&+#2""!'!!+#*&* !6#7 %&,,*#' +&&#)  !(!!)* '* &'%&#* # -"*%,' 2%*,* &&%*#*,*$ #'-,' *#'& )&&6& #!'#&,%&&#'& 4$$ %#*  8 B  !!'&,&#'* ( +#2""!'!!+#*'* &*'* %*.&'#&&&,&#*,('*.#,& ,#%6&, &',*%&#*&6#*,,*,#*-*#'#*(.,#*'&6&%#*. ( !. &6  !!'&,&#'* ( +#2""!'!!+#*'* &*'* &%* &(.C ,&# ,* ,) %D*'%&&  !!'&,&#'*(+#2""!'!!+#*'*&*'*&%* &($  

           

                 

                                          !      "   #        

              

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

          '(        !        % %&  

  *&(# ''& # ( &.6# !&# '&#'#&. *#' #22.& '&*# %"#$ ! F ( #22.&#''-. &'#('* (*#!,* , ! #0,%&. ! ,*++*7 %&,,* !"#*,' +! F 0.&# !"'#< #22.& '&#'. *&(# ''& #    3 45 ,6  + 7   (6& (   %0&#' ',,* &#'#* #8 !,% #''(4 "* # .-6&#'#'( 389,6+(6&8 !,%  #''-6&#'#'$

 3 :8 ,6  ( :5 ,6  ,#*, ,6*. *6*% &#'# *' # # *% &#'#*6 ( ,&&' &#'#* #%0&#'8 !,% #''(4 .-6&#'#'$$ #'-,'  3 5 ,6  ,) ,&# &#'#* !",.%&#*,* &&6&#' -,(#'%&* !!# #&##*#0&. ,6-&&# #' #$ #'-,'  3 :4 ,6  ,6*. ,-6&#'#*# -&&)&'. *6 #$! ,'*# &#&  "',#''- &&+&.%&#*#'4$$:$ & !"'!'##* ,'%&#*& &#'#(", $

&#'#* .%&#* ,6#' -*#'. ,'*# &#&  "',#''- &&+&.%&#*#'7 #$! ,'*# 4$$:$ #'-,' 348,6 ,) !D&# &%&#*,**&(#''& #(*#' &&+&.%&#*, -0*'. ( *#'&'. "  *!' 897: !!& =  ,''&  574 !!& =  ,&''& 578 !!& ! 547*,&'"'2 ##. "* # 2%%*.2 # !!&(#*'&  22.&'&#'.  

   345,6+(6&*''*"'. &'*!'!&%*+*%&#* #'  8  !,%  #'' :  .   -6&#'#' (  3 89 ,6  +  (6& *''*"'. &'*! '!&%*+*%&#*#'  # #''-6&#'#'$

 3 :8 ,6  ( 3 :5 ,6  ,#*, ,6*. *6*% &#'# *' # # *% &#'#*6 (

   ,&&' &#'#* #%0&#'8 !,% #'': .-6&#'#'$ #'-,' 35,6 ,)&#& '*,*,&# &#'#* !",.%&#*,*&&6&#'-,(#'%&* !!# #&##*#0&. ,6-&&* # #' #$ #'-,' # 3 :4 ,6  ,6*. ,-6&#'#*# -&&)&'. *67 #$!$ ,'*# &#&  "',#''- &&+&.%&#*#'4$$: & !"'!'##* ,'%&#*& &#'#(", $

&#'#* .%&#* ,6#' -*#'. ,'*#  &#&  "',#''- &&+&.%&#*#'7 #$!$ ,'*# 4$$:$ #'-,' 389,65(348,65 ,)-#''. !!'&,&*&*%##&656%%&7  6%%& (  6%%&7 %&# ! "!&, !"'* #+*'&&#& ( &%&,&#'&  *# #*#7 !D&# &%&#*,*$ ,(%0&#'*&(#''& #*,'(&.6#!&#*,' %%,' &#."&&6&',.*##* 9 !!&(%**',# ,.$0&.'!(%!)&&,'*,*D! ,-.'6#'%&#*,*!%& *,*$  

  

!"#,*&.&#7*'#22.&#''-'*#22.&'&#'%&*( ! ,*++*#0,%&%&*!*.*'0*,&#*'"'* -,.#$ &%&,#(%**',*%&#*,!(6&'. ! ,*++*%**',#*#''*&.$;"&..*# 3 54,6+(6&',*)&#& .#22.&'&#'.(%0&#'*&,* ! ,*++* !"* &#'#$

#&-&&,"6&*#&''.*&!,*$ !"' ,.',*)#&##*0.#22.&%0&#'*''*,'$     )! & *+&,,

!"'&