Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1-06-7681\17 AI generated

1-06-7681\17 · Pärnu Maakohus Rapla kohtumaja

Case Number 1-06-7681\17
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

 %     //"%  5    %/     %   %     %  "$ "   %  "    $ %  ""   %"& $  &"/ %"&  &"    /   " ++" %%"$%   + &  66   % &&   %    %   7   &     ""  &/"1   $  ++" %%    % " 2""%"%        #++" %$ &"   "5           $  %   %/     "  +    " %    &/    +"    %/"$   > )"  "  &  /"   & "" /""   %"    "    $   %    

Legislator headnote

AI generated

1-06-7681\17 · Pärnu Maakohus Rapla kohtumaja:  %     //"%  5    %/     %   %     %  "$ "   %  "    $ %  ""   %"& $  &"/ %"&  &"    /   " ++" %%"$%   + &  66   % &&   %    %   7   &     ""  &/"1   $  ++" %%    % " 2""%"%        #++" %$ &"   "5           $  %   %/     "  +    " %    &/    +"    %/"$   > )"  "  &  /"   & "" /""   %"    "    $   %    

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

                                

     



 !"#$ % " &' ( $     )%    &       * & $  %  &

*   

  %       &$    ++" %   

 $,*

-$ +""...$"$/  " $    $ " %  $ "  --     0 ,-    $&, & 12  %"    12    &$ % 

  3/%  0,-    &, &%"   1,2" + 12   &&    

4     #0     $    

    ""%  +1 2%5   & 

  %  "5 

++"    # 0  , &      %/ "   6 )   &  & % "% 7 #%% ) &        "  8   9 "  &" ++"     $&%    &  

- & 

      %  &  ...   ... /  +      %  "+  3 & & 66 %/" % 

/ %"5 / %      66 "     " % 

  $ / & "  / % & " % $   && 3       9  % : "     #0, "      9     " ++" &  &    ++"   / &"   9  +   $3& /""%"$%    " 

  "&    / "   & 

  &/"    *  , 66 &&   &    & 1%" 2 " &     5  66       "$ "   $ "         %" 5     & "  "5  $ "9 5  "   " $ %" % &  5  "  " " 5 "&%" "% 5     &

   "5 9   " "   $      %   5 9    "  / 5+  "   + &%  $+    % 5

     /9   $     &%"%  5 66     9   $ 66&&  "% &    %/5   "%   % &5  &     $     " $ "9  $+   5& "   , -

 %  5  %"   9  % &"5   "5    ," %&  & 5 ""5% $  &$&"  /   "&  "5       $       %/  5   

  " 9   % &&   " & /"  $  "  %"$  "%   5  $ $  5  &  &$ "  "$   &" %  "5     & 9 $" $   +  $ " $+ %/" $$    & %/  "5  %/ %  $ "9 5%"$ %5+  /    9   & & &" 

 5     

$9  $  ""% "5&   %/"+  "59 $&  /"    &"5 %// 

& &5&&    % & $ "5"   $   9   $%/  " 5% 

    &%  "$   %   5    /  " &  9 && + " % %/$ /  &    $  &  "  

  5        

     %"   $     "         

  /% $  $   & 5

- &   "9     && & 5  " "5

"%$%   /" $ "%" $ "  "&& "$ "  % &  ;< $   "%&" 5 " " " 5%"  +" %" "$  " % 5 "  "$ "   5 "    "  "

  + $ " 9     5 66  

- &  """5/   "$ +  $ "% &%& " :5   "$%   /" 5 % 9 $ "      & /" $"

   " $  "      /   & "5   "  &  "$ " 9  $      

$"     $  "5    "    "5      " "&""   /  & 5+   +  +  :$   "

$     

 %  % & %        5 9    + $     &&1...2$ ")  %&%   :+ "$  & "      $ "   $        : + "$  &&  "5   "& &"%" /" &    % %" $ " "  &      $ ++" %+ " % %   

 / "$"%  +"  %  % " & " &        & "     #+"   %      " "  $  /  " %   "" " " " /% &%   %" &  & /" " " "%"+    $ &"   $ %"   " %         %  "    " "  " /    &    % %5%"%    /" % %     "   5    /"     " %       %

 , ""&%    % % #++" %%/ $    / %    +       9 /%   %  66   66  "   +  & # $     & 

   " %   " " "5  " &  /"  "  %     "" "5   "  + "    %%  "   + 5 66  " "&   "  &      "  " "" %       =7)    $%"  "% $/ " $%" % $  66  " +  %/"%"    " %"$    "=7): " %"   3  =7) %/" %  " =7)  :     & 1%" 2 /"  "      %    "   1%  :    2$    %     ""  %  $ 1  -2   " %        "   "  %&%"  "%=7)  =7)    &  & %     %" "      % "             $% % / % %&"

% / %    %   &  / &      % $  %     &

 %     //"%  5    %/     %   %     %  "$ "   %  "    $ %  ""   %"& $  &"/ %"&  &"    /   " ++" %%"$%   + &  66   % &&   %    %   7   &     ""  &/"1   $  ++" %%    % " 2""%"%        #++" %$ &"   "5           $  %   %/     "  +    " %    &/    +"    %/"$   > )"  "  &  /"   & "" /""   %"    "    $   %    

++" % &  ++" % "/ & " " #++" % %"   $    % 

- &     /  1  2     ""  &;< $  / "   3 9+       %  & 

    

 , $  "

" /   ...  7" "+   "$"  " 9  ... ?  "    &   & %% % &  /  &  &$    / $+  &  ""5

  ""5       %% + $ &   &  "5 %           &" 66 &   $      5  /    "& : % "5&     

   

%$"    "& " $ "  66"   #+"   %     66   " + "       " "  & "     &"5   "  /   5  ""$ 66  & >@5 /      "5  "   &  "  9  +             &  

    &  /  & "   & &     % $ +"      &+   )"&  +  " %$  + "  "  "  "  &"   /      "  % 

    + " %/" "/ "" & "   "  + "  ++" %  "%""%+ 5  " + "  /  +  &      66  %/"  +      %$ " ++" %  

 "    $   &+  $   "+ "  "  "66"$/  "&" "" & "   " +"  %   & 1%" 2% 

& +    $   %/" "   ++" %$ &           & & &  #++" % %"  /   #++" %+    " %   "  $&         ""  +"     %" +    &  

     % " +   $  & 

   

 " "

 & "%" %  & &  $ 9  "& %  $   /$/  %" + $  " %  #  66" 9  &%"%"     #+     %"   &  " +  &    % & )     + $      &$ "9   #& "9   %         &  &  "$        "     "   / $ 9    " " 

  #&  &"  / %   9  &"  &"%" /& 9 "& "  %   $" "% 

  $     &/" &   # &  "   %" $&5  

;< /%   &  $ &     & & &/ #"9 $ %     & %$/  %" $ "  %5  /     &    

 &  +    ;<

  &   9  "  &  &" "  A   "  ;< /"     &  "  7" 

 " &$"%    5  &&/""%   %5+  & +  $  $/&" " " &     *  

  "+  9 "+ 

%    & +  $   +"&%"%" $ & "+  "& 66" $ "  & 66" 5 & %/"  &% ""& % & 7    9   +    "   

 % &  "" & /" 5   "  &    5  "% 5  &  "&$""$  % "$ " "&9  "" % #&  "/" 5 %   " 66"5  &  % 5%    " "5 " /   & &  """"/" 

 6 "% $   /    " "% 

 $/      "      #++" %   66  %" &+ "$ "  $   9     % +" $%"""&3

"" 

- & 

  /   ... /& && % &    9  $  $  %& /&& %5  "% B"#&%& & 5 9  &&  " 

 5   $ 9   /%  $

  

&%" /"  &+   5+     & %   $ 9         5 /   /$"/ " "/   $    

  $       "  &           ""  :

 *   

5 9   :+ "          " +   7    $   9   $        &   %  

  "   9 & +  %" &+ "$ "  $   9     &  &  "    & $       

5 3   "" 

- &/  

   "& "%"$"   $  +  $/%   &+  $" 5+   

 "  5 &   ""& % &59 & "  & $  "& "5 &9  &  "5 % %"  " $""   9     "&%//"9  

 "59  % 

      $       5       "  5&  $     "  

&"            "+    " +     &    $ 9  "%&"   &%    & "+    9 & + %" &+ "$  9      + 9 &+   $ ...$  /% ...    9   4 * &   & 9  $  & 9  %   % + "&  "%  " 5+ "/ & " "%"&+ " &  ""%   & 5" + "   5 " ":++   "$ +   "66"  

5""9   %& 5  "& %  , 4%5  

% 

- & 

    &   %  & 5      &  "    %  %/  % 5 %   "  "% 5 &/%   &   5

- &   /       "   &"$ %         "$ 4

*

  &&" &% $  &   

   "&   5 %&"  & &  %                " + $   %"    " + $" "    $   & 

   &"$  "& &%% "$66 & 5     $   & &   /" 5

- & 

   

  &  "$

- & 

   -

 &"  9 $        "    $  + " 5 9    & $  & "  9     :$"% "+ " 5         9 &"  &

% &5  &  & " $9   %   " %&"   +        "$     "    *

 $     ""53 %$  %    $ & %     5    &    5 &$ "  9  &   "$   " &/" $ "   $  "   "   "   9 &+   $ 9 %   $3" $ " "   & 

  $ "   & "&%/&5 %              9  $   

 " "     $      $     " &5  "" &   

+%$&  "C $)D$"&) & "$   " 

  "  ""%5%&  )D5"" %$

   9 %& &%   $ +%& %/ 5   /   -



 9 "  +    " +   "$9  

- &   59    &" %    "$    "$ "     +"     5 +%      " 

- &  /  $     ( 9 66"     &   $    %   /  +      &%&  5( 9"  5( 9"$   5  "   &9   $ &  "    9 &+   $   ...    & &$  9  %  9  +  %    )#$  +% * & )  

    /  ) #...& 5%     & '  /  

  &  

-

    9  &+  )$"  "&+  $)& "9 )  $

  & "   9 &)D    "&   % ""+   $3  %   9  && & 5

- &

  /   & ... ) +% " $ %      % &  &    % &   $   +  $      %&5"  $ "6 "5  /  &   

+% 5  &  9 &  %& &5"    "5   &   "$     " & 9  &    

 %""5   %  $9 & " +  "59  "  %5 $""%  "" " &/  "   /" &"%"$ 9 %& 

- &/  

      #     " & +  $ 9   &   %  %   #++  %"   "     66  &    %    / &   9  %   "/"   9 & ( 9   9          + "      "  & +  "      9+   $ +& 9     & $ "  "   7"     +  %  5  +        9   %  $  &

      

   9 66 & % 9 "  "566   9   /  $ & " &  566 % 

- &

   9   % 5

- & 

   



  &9   $%"$ %  66 %/5

  % 5+  / "5   5 " $/   5 

 % % $" " "5  %   

  9    %  +/  $ /" 

"5 9     5   4

      9     %    ++ $  /& "   " +  8 %&%/ 5 &    "9  & $   >$ &  % $% "5

 /    4   &  $ 

"         5 %   &5

+  $  5+   & $  9   /" $ + " "&  $+    & $+  & ""$  & "5   " 6 "$" " % 5    %  &  /% &5+     &  +& & ...5  &  &+  $  %

 ++% 5+&   /  ...5+  &+  $ 

  &"  5

- & +" & 66" 5 &   %      +   % &5 % %    

 5  & $   

- & ++% %/5 $  +  %  9    %/5+  "+ "  &%  5      +      " +   5 3   &  

- &   "   $ "    

   5  

4      +  9   ... " 

5  

* 

  %     9     /  &+  5 & %     $  " &%/+   5 /        !   %   +"  % "&         &+ " #"%   ++" %+   +    $       % "  &      9    , 4 % 

- & 

   +& $  9   &5   %/  &     %/%% % 

& 5  $  "& " $ %%&     53  %"/" 5  

 &  "&+    & 5 & "$     " %5 " "   %   %" &" & &   "5   "  / $    &  "  &/" % &&5          "%  5& /"%/  &  5

- &   &   &$    % "5    +   &5 %"       $  "      /"    $  "   & + " " &  $& /"    

 " 6 "5      &     "$   %        "5 

1%" 2%%% 

    &    + "  5   " %%      5  &   5+    $    

5     5   "  &5

- & &/  %& $ %& 5  &"

- &  $ "   +    / " &/"   & %  & $     &  & 9  +          3    &   %  % &       " + " "      & 

  "+    "$   9  " &

- &  & " $ " 

   "$ " " &/" $"/  " %" 5 &  ""/ "" & -

&   $ "   " /"   #  %   +        & $     3 /  %" $  " / %" 9 $   %

- &

    "  "5 % /  "  5   "    "  "$  "     5 "    + "

  + &   $ "5 $"  " " / " & "$% $ +  66  66 &"  "   +   %& &"5+   "  &%%%&" %  " "/5

$   + %/5%/"  %"   &  5    % 

%" %/ 9 %" % /  %$"      %    %  " &  " $

"     %   " +& $  "   % 

 9  

  #%  "  ""  " &"$ " &5$ %   $/ ""   "  

  =7)    $ 9  %  " /++:"  %/" %       & $ +    5% 

""=7):   9  %/" % %/"%$ "  3 %/" %" %/"%"5   "   %  "3    &        % 5 9  %  %"  ++:"  %/" %  % &     %    &  +    & %  "   &        %   $      "& " "/" "  $    9       " "  % "  3       "  3   % "    &     +         +            9   %/3  66     3  : "    "          % $   3  %  "      %   %         &     " 

- &  

   %    9       &% E"/"" %"  "    $ 9  /

3 %   +  &+ / & " "   "  "%        66      "  / % &          " "

   )% "   & $          " / %     $   + "" %     & 66 " + $  "    $  9  /3 & %   + &       "     %/  #"    :$    %     "  3%/ 9 "  % %&  % & /"        "" /" $/ %""    9 ""

   & "  "       "      # 0  , / /   ++" %

  ""   "    $ 9     ++ "   #0  4/  

    + /&" $/"  &"%/  66&&     #++"/ % 

%  %" & " 9  %   & ++

  /  ""   "  %   /"     "%"   "%" & " 9  %   " 9  ++ ""    $     " %   9 %        "  "$    %      %       9 

++  %"  &&         7  / &     $  %   % #00,  %/4  & "&  %/ &    "   %  %   & $     / &  %   +  &    &   $/  & 9    ++" %    +  "$   / %          # 0 ,     " %   +     9 " %    " +%     *  7// &""&   "      ++" % % &/    "

  "  -

 $  & 66  4 , 5  "           "   "    =7)      -  $    4, &       *  

 - 3 "" #00,$-   $   $, $, -  ,$,,&,*$      8  #++" " 9 #0,&& ""%    12    9/" %   &   &       % "   % " %    & 

     &/  9    "

-

 " $,-4*             "   "    & 4 ,    & 66  +%   &/ " "%/  "+ &    

 &/    "        

,4

   '   $ %

4--%/   , A   %      "  

/   "      &/  9   9

 *"   & +%    ) /"   "    && 5 + 5  & "$ /  "$66&" " %"  

&/      

  %/       "    9      )  /     %    "   % &   %   

      )    "   % + %  &   %  % $          %/   

    %"   #++" %  &   %"  &"  

  "  &% %    !"#       ' (       %     %