Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1-05-1056\1 ECLI:EE:VMK:2006:1.05.1056.21081 AI generated

1-05-1056\1 · Viru Maakohus Narva kohtumaja

Case Number 1-05-1056\1
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus

Legislator summary

AI generated

                                     

Legislator headnote

AI generated

1-05-1056\1 · Viru Maakohus Narva kohtumaja:                                      

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

                                     

   

      !    "#  $   ! %   !

&# ' ( (   )*  ! +,-    (  !    " .  !"   " !  /  !       % $  !       0  1              0         "

   2 - "  3 "  "       4  "      "   )     1 ,,   5      1    !    5366 &&   +  2 0   +76&  

   "     8  " 133       ++

 6 "      1      !   "#$%&' (%)"%$%&' ($)*    0  



 +&   "

   2 - "  3 "  "   "  "     4  "      "   )     1 ,,   ,, 

  5      1    !    26 0   +7262+ & 

 8 "      8  "2     ++

 6 "      1      !   "#$%&' (%)"%$%&' ($)*   0   ,  -  "

  2- "  3"  "   "  "    4  "   +   "  )     1,,  ,, 5      6661 0   +73+& 

 8 "    9 % 26 0   +7262+ & 5

 8 "    !4  533 

&&   8  "  &    "  +&         6 "      1      !   "#$%&' (%)"%$%&' ($)*   0       "

   2- "   3"  "      4  "   +   "  )     1,,   5        6 "    

"     !   "#$%&' (%)*   0   . . &  "

   2- "   3"  "      4  "      "  )     1,,   5        6 "    

"     !   "#$%&' (%)*    

    ../ 

 2    "'  .8 !-. :  

 ;+ 8  "          <   & 

 &  "

"   !  "

 %    # 8 !%    "  +  .8 ! . :    ;+   " "          "    

 <   =>   ?@  " "" # 8 !    + !   AA "   0  3  

   + B  ""   "  "& " " !  " ".8 !. :  ;+ !  "    ""  " 3    8  # 8   

    AA  + " !  & .8 ! . :    ;+  & " "     0    " "  +

   " " # 8  "     

   !    " "  # 8     " !.8  " # 8     & " # 8      # 8  AA"       "       0             !     3  

   1 !  "  0      + A+    "  7 2   & "!  0  + -. :  !

 ;+  !%   ! "   +   

 

           <   

     & 

 !     A   8

 &     %  .8 ! . :    ;+  

" A     AA

  &  

           "    <   ! " "

 "  " "     "+     " $C! 25)!  $C!   2 ! " "      <    "

AA

   ! # 8    +     & "+   "     <      "  "

 0      "   "   " !   "  ! # 8    +   ! "        !      " !      &"     " +&     3  

    <     +    +    ! "   " "    AA 0      <       +    !   AA

   >  ?! 

""  &  " !  " " .8 !. :  ;+ 9  . . &            & 2" 

 <     !  "  !   A   8

  !  &   ! "   " "    AA 0     !

  AA

   >  ?!  ""  &  " !  " "  .8 !. :  ;+ 9  ) 1   "  8  2+&  3  

  53   <     



  ! "  "  "     AA  0     !   AA

   >  ?    !  ""  &  " !  " " .8 !. :  ;+            !              

      & & ( & (     & " #$ )*  *2   (     " #$  % &'  (% )*  *2       ! !     + "  !+ -. :   

  ;+  ! " "    3    8             "  0    !     "     ! %     # 8       A "

 

    )  " "  # 8     A " !   



 3 63  # 8    +&  +  "!       & "  # 8   0

!   5 -B!  & +

   "        5  ! #     "& " & "

  A "            !     *)&

  (          * ( & (     & (

  "%$%&' ($)*  *2     ,  -  AA"      !   3  

 1 !  " 0    + A+    " 72 & "! 0   +  '   .8  ! 

  ;+  ! %    !  "   +     

  

            <        & 

 !   A   8

 &   %  .8 ! . :    ;+  

" A     AA

  &  

 

          "      <   !  " "  "  " "     "+     " $C! 25)! $C!  2! " "    <   "

AA

  !# 8    +     & "+   "     <      "  "

 0      "   "   " !   "  ! # 8      +   ! "        !      " !      &"     " +&     3  

    <     +    +    ! "   " "    AA 0      <       +    !   AA

   >  ?! 

""  &  " !  " " .8 !. :  ;+ 9  . . &            & 2" 

 <     !  "  !   A   8

  !  &   ! "   " "    AA 0     !

  AA

   >  ?!  ""  &  " !  " "  .8 !. :  ;+ 9  ) 1   "  8  2+&  3  

  53   <     



  ! "  "  "     AA  0     !   AA

   >  ?      '8   !   ""    &   " !   "  "  .8 ! . :  ;+   ,   -     !              

      & & ( & (     & " #$ )*  *2   (     " #$  % &'  (% )*  *2       ! !     + "  !+ '  .8   

  ;+  ! " "    3    8             "  0    !     "     ! %     # 8       A "

 

    )  " "  # 8     A " !   

 63  # 8    +&  +  "!       & "  # 8   0

!   5 -B!  & +

   "        5  ! #     "& " & "

  A "  

  ,   -     !     *)&

  (          * ( & (     & (

  "%$%&' ($)*  *2    



 +&  AA"      !   3  

 1 !  " 0    + A+    " 72 & "! 0   +  - . :  ! '   .8  ! %    !  "   +     

  

            <        & 

 !   A   8

 &   %  .8 ! . :    ;+  

" A     AA

  &  

 

          "      <   !  " "  "  " "     "+     " $C! 25)! $C!  2! " "    <   "

AA

  !# 8    +     & "+   "     <      "  "

 0      "   "   " !   "  ! # 8      +   ! "        !      " !      &"     " +&     3  

    <     +    +    ! "   " "    AA 0      <       +    !   AA

   >  ?! 

""  &  " !  " " .8 !. :  ;+ 9  . . &            & 2" 

 <     !  "  !   A   8

  !  &   ! "   " "    AA 0     !

  AA

   >  ?!  ""  &  " !  " "  .8 !. :  ;+ 9  ) 1   "  8  2+&  3  

  53   <     



  ! "  "  "     AA  0     !   AA

   >  ?     '8   !   ""    &   " !   "  "  .8 ! . :  ;+  



  +&     !              

      & & ( & (     & " #$ )*  *2   (     " #$  % &'  (% )*  *2       ! !     + "  !+ '  .8   - . :  ! " "    3    8             "  0    !     "     ! %     # 8       A "

 

    )  " "  # 8     A " !   

 63  # 8    +&  +  "!       & "  # 8   0

!   5 -B!  & +

   "        5  ! #     "& " & "

  A "  



  +&     !     *)&

  (          * ( & (     & (

  "%$%&' ($)*  *2    

      AA"      !   3  

 1 !  " 0    + A+    " 72 & "! 0   +  '   .8  ! 

  ;+  ! - . :  !  "   +     

  

            <        & 

 !   A   8

 &   %  .8 ! . :    ;+  

" A     AA

  &  

 

          "      <   !  " "  "  " "     "+     " $C! 25)! $C!  2! " "    <   "

AA

  !# 8    +     & "+   "     <      "  "

 0      "   "   " !   "  ! # 8      +   ! "        !      " !      &"     " +&     3  

    <     +    +    ! "   " "    AA 0      <       +    !   AA

   >  ?! 

""  &  " !  " " .8 !. :  ;+ 9  . . &            & 2" 

 <     !  "  !   A   8

  !  &   ! "   " "    AA 0     !

  AA

   >  ?!  ""  &  " !  " "  .8 !. :  ;+ 9  ) 1   "  8  2+&  3  

  53   <     



  ! "  "  "     AA  0     !   AA

   >  ?     '8   !   ""    &   " !   "  "  .8 ! . :  ;+           !              

      & & ( & (     & " #$ )*  *2   (     " #$  % &'  (% )*  *2     .  . &&  AA"      !     3  

   1 !  "  0      + A+    "  7 2   & "!   0   +  '   .8  ! 

  ;+  ! %    ! - . :     

  

 

        

 <       & 

 !   A   8

 &     %  .8 ! . :    ;+  

" A     AA

  &  

            "    

 <   ! " "  "  " "     "+     "  $C!   25 )!   $C!   2 ! " "      <    "

AA

  !# 8    +     & "+   "      <      " "

0     "   "  " !   " !# 8    +   ! "        !

     " !      &"     " +&     3  

    <     +    +    ! "   " "    AA 0      <    

 1   +    !   AA

   >  ?! 

""  &  " !  " " .8 !. :  ;+ 9  . . &            & 2" 

 <     !  "  !   A   8

  !  &   ! "   " "    AA 0     !

  AA

   >  ?!  ""  &  " !  " "  .8 !. :  ;+ 9  ) 1   "  8  2+&  3  

  53   <     



  ! "  "  "     AA  0     !   AA

   >  ?     '8   !   ""    &   " !   "  "  .8 ! . :  ;+   .  . &     !              

      & & ( & (     & " #$ )*  *2   (     " #$  % &'  (% )*  *2     2        /  . . &( 

 AA"  " AA"   &      A !    3     +       

  AA      +    "     AA           <   8 ," ! < 8 "!   & "!       %      2" #  +8   0     +  !+   "+ 8

  "!     ! "&& !  8 "  "    A          +8    &  AA  +        %    "    D&& "  + 

 !       B  !     !    8 "   E "&"    && "   !      & $C%  ";+  . : .  ;+ -   

! " & 1 # 

    "! 



   !  "     &        8  "   &+ "  %   " + " " 

&  )  "  "   " "& 0"  "  +   +  0"  "! "   *

&    " !  AA       4   "A "! "  "  "  "   "  &     "   + +  !             " # 8   "! 8    AA   + "    BF + G% +      2"   ++   !  &" " +     

    <  "      "  "     ,, %AA"    A  "

 & ="!  323@   !      3       0"  " A"  

" " % ""  

 &  &"   +   $C 

 -AA"  >#  " ?%!- ;+   "  &      !  ! AA8     "+ +  +   .8 !-=# " @ ;+ !  " ! AA   "    %AA"      +     " A     !           + +     & + "    .8        & "  " +  A !

+&   "A  "      8  " 

 5   ! 

 AA"  " AA"   &      A !       

  +  # 8       AA   3     4    <     !     "   +   +&   AA

 .8 !;+  . :  "  &+ "   "     "!   D +&    .8       +   "    "  # 8   + 

!   # 8  +        " %  .8  !   + 

.  & 

 +     .8      !   # 8    "   # 8      ";&  " # 8   & "0   "    

;    AA   &    %" && "  "    "   "   "   +     ,,"  

   +      

   8     +       AA

     %   " !.8 !;+  . :   +"    AA

    0 " + "

   8 ,,    . :   "  &+ "  . :            " D " "  6 !       8   +& A  "

,,+&  ,,""    "    A "   ="!  622@!    +   !          

!         

  !          +

 ," ! "    4  



!    "'  .8    &&  

    D !

    "      ! "   ;+  . : AA"   H# " ?!    "             !   & !  "      4   

"  " "    "   <   8        +  8!  "++ ,," 23""     " !        .8       &     !

 " .8   A !    ! 8     AA   % 

  !    %  !  8  AA8   

 .8 &  .8 !;+  . :      " " "   ! 8  

.8 A

 ! "   "& "!       &8.8   "  !   "!+  & 8  " 

"     "     +      " " A

 "!  "  &8   AA AA

     "   "   !  "  ;+ !. :  .8 %  "  &"            !  ;8 +  " ! ," +      ;  

  ;8  <  & !," !   &  !  +  !

  "+   " "  1+   .   "  &  + % ""  +    

 "

# ! AA 2 &"   +    # !  AA  +&  3 +    ;    AA      !       +      2  AA     " !     .8 ! ;+  . : )  "     +   IA AA     ++ % # 8  " 

 ,, )     A  # 8 !  8+ "     

    " "   ;         %   8         "  &"   %   "  # 8    AA  &&& " +   " &  %  %   "       ;+  . :     AA 

"!  &  .8   63  

     + .8   "        4   A !        !   "  # 8   +   &  .8  A !  %    +  % " ; " + 

        .8   "       E  +   "& !  "    "4  # 8 A

!        & ! A

!   &    +  # 8       "  !    " " &   A

 !  "A "  "! AA"   A !A "  " 

 6     AA"  " AA"      "!A !   !      " # 8  )   ""  "     "+,,"   +         A # 8       " &  " # 8 &    %  " !   %  

  # 8   # 8   +             # 8 +    ")  !  # 8  

     " & "    " "    # 8       & " "!      " . :    ;+  # 8  "       "  

# 8  ;+  . :   "  %AA"   &  "  A +& . : +A  "

  !. :   ;+   "  ! # 8            +       &   %

&+   & !     8  ! "&    1       "  



  +& AA"   " AA"        "   A !      # 8    <  ! AA          -        8  A

 !       ! 

!  # 8  B

" . :  # 8  " "   BF + G

# 8  "     AA  <   -       " !    -       A"

. :   " !-   AA    # 8  B

"  +   " "# 8   "      + ;  "  &   + " A  &   !   " & "  +     " 0 "+ "" .8  

  %&  !

 . : # 8 

  !    AA" !       "   8!  # 8      "      " !# 8  .8     "              +"   +            A   "     "# 8  AA       + "

   +&  " %            A

 "" 0  

 & && &"  &&     !   

 # 8 -    

 

 1    8!# 8 

AA    +&   + "

   8!    +  

 !  "0  A +   &  "   A  AA"   A !.8   "    !

    +        ;        !     8   

 G       +     

&& !

    ". :   A  " !

    "*

&     A   " "  ,  -!  AA"  " AA"      " A !1 



  +  + +"    &8

    

 "     AA"    A   "# 8 A          # 8    -  "A  8   +     8 ;+  A         -  !      A"   &      # 8  ;&       "     # 8  &8  + "  AA"

 "   !       "  +   &    "   &"      +&  # 8  +

   &   

 %   "  " A

!   # 8    & "! A       +     <    "     +& 

   

!# 8  8    " !  +&       ;   A     ;&  "  # 8      & " -    "       +    &  # 8  # !        " "! + "  +    "   " "     "  " %AA"   ;+ A

 >  & "!  !     " .8  +    A  !  .8   "   J?

  . :   >%   .8   "   

        +    "  &    "

   ? ;+  "   +     +,, " &+ )    !

   + -   

 



      A "  )  3 ( A !3   + AA # 8  0

!        AA !

A   " + !    "  " "0"& "  & 

# 8      A !      "   +& +  "  

     !    !  

    

    "   & 8 "                &   ;&  "     && "   )  !   A !  

 &   "  +& " A "   !  # 8  "  +   "             .8    # 8    % 

 # 8   + 

!&8 

  

 "   " K   &  .8 ! &&  # 8  

 4

 .8  

     A !      # 8     " A

 

 .8 

!  +      "   4

  !A

     " " ";    "   "  !  "8 # 8   +    

+& K     !   8    "A

# 8 !     ! A !     & .8   +   A

     !

  "    ;       " "!  # 8 84  A !8   

AA   +   + " # 8 A !    A

   !

&   " 

"  " !   8  " 

"  

& 

 # 8  

   &  "    & "!# 8      " "

"  & # 8 3      +  !   )  # 8  6       #!     &  " !  "#    " "  "

  2+& 0 "  

& " 

 "%+& # 8   "        " 

 # 8 

 "    +;  A !# 8  " &     6 !    AA" 3  ;    ! # 8   !   " "  &        0 4 5 !   A !   +   +  &    

 BF + G!       "      ,,    0     & ! "      



  "   

B 

"  "  + 

&8       &  "+  +8  !             

 ! A !   + 

 A  !   "  +     # 8  + 

 A

!    

 !       #&

 +&      & + 

 # 8  A !            ;&  

   A  "

 ="!  222@!  63  +&  

  +   + 

  

     !   D !      +     "  # 8      + 8        + "   " A      " !          "     # 8   =  0

! 5 -B@        ;&  # 8  A

    

!A 

! " "     

!  !

A >  ! ?    #&

   & # 8  +  0   8&  "  &  & 

  0 "A     A !A "  "! &&    

   +    .  !   A !    # 8     B

      B

      8!     A      >    ?!  " 

    

# 8  1 "  # 8  & A "  .8      A !     8 0& .8    )   !  # 8     

 ;+    . :         8 D    && !    8      -    "       "   +   8 &+ "  

 "  

 # 8    

,," "   B

         # 8    && "!       8      A +  !    " +  ,,  "  " +A +& !A "!    8  & " B+  ,,  "A "!   8 "  A " .8   %  !     & "  +   + 0 " A "   > "A "!&"  ?  ,""    " A "# 8   .8  " " " .8       !             "     " 0    2 8   3  )

         +&    2   +& %        )

  

!   0       ! &      

 B

  " # 8  .8  & 2"   %   0  &  I3  A 0     .8   & "# 8 &&  !  .8 +& +8 "   .8 

 A  "    "   !  " A "!         

          " "     '8    A " =2"!  2@  !  3  A    

  >   ?% # 8 B

    &"    !  

  +    >4  ? 

   !  " !   +  

  AA   8 +   ! >  ?!



23+      +

     ++>  "?%

 ++  "# " !.8    0 "+ AA "   # 8   > ? 0 " 

       !     >  +? # 8  &&  !      AA ! ".8     "  " 

 " + "   &8  3 "  8  # 8 "!     A !    +  !>.8 ?+ 8    # 8       3  ,,""      A

 # 8 

! >.8 ?   !       8    %  

# 8 >  ?     +# 8   >.8 ?     8       & +   !  >.8 ?&  ";    & &

&  8 3 

   # 8  +

+!   +

  +    " " # 8     !"

   " >.8 ? &  I  !     !A   !+    

 + $C !  !  8 3  8    0& >.8 ?A   # "    !  "  ># " ?I   

    ! !  " " " 8 # 8         ! "   8   &+ !  >.8 ? 

 "        >.8 ?      +   & !    # 8  AA       > ? 

       " I %   "! +       "  %    !  &  > ?  &  +    !  8 + >  "?> ?   

!   # 8  "     " %     "  3  + 8     

&  > ?   +    !  !  !    &  $C! +   +  $C         

 > ?  A !        AA!,, 8     !  ,,  >  +?

  . 

 "    B

%       &"   3 

+ 8    +      >  ? 8," !  

 ;&  

  

 8 < 4 <   8 5  " ! >   ? 3  " !       )*     I     > ?   8    +   # 8  &&   !   8    .8  " &  .8  I.8 ! 8     +   D  " ! "  && # 8   8 A         % 7 6   A  "  AA      >  ?!   A !   <    

     # 8    &&   !   8    .8 # 8  &&      8    AA   .8    ;+       8   0& !  "  # 8    ;+ ! . :    .8  " 

 " # 8     !  & "  .   )6. 7  A !  " " 

="! 3@!    8    !   8 !>   ?! <    = A     @   "           AA   %    !  "   =  AA8  ! AA"  > ?@   %   AA"  >'  ?  &



     +& 23   4                        +& 2  3   2"  &"  %    3          &     > ?!>'  ? % (  AA "   +   B

 23 +     

   "     !    !23  <   0  "&& ">'  ? &  + "   BF + G! 

        

   +       )         8  +    "!    % (    "      " ! +

 )   8

      

   <  66 B

         >'    ?    

!    + "           "  )  "   BF + G % (  && < 3360& !  >'  ?          I ># " ?    -! '  .8         0& !   >'  ?      &  $C   %   " ># " ?   >.8 ?      %  "    &    !        -  "  "      AA "   

   "    0 "  "      +   "    

  

        "      "  "     "     "  "!       AA  8!># " ?!>.8 ?   +AA" ">'  ? +AA" 

  "    AA

 0 "  " "!       AA       

     "    %     +   +    "  " "!    >'  ? AA ">  ?>.8 ?&  8! .8 !># " ?     +  + +"!

  AA >  ?!

 &&& " +    "   +>'  ? 3  " !% ( 

       + L+

 + " ! .8 . &   8   % 8<& &  "    " ".8 !   ># " ? "       "% ( >M ?    " &     +    

+ 8

+       "        "%      >  ?!  % ( >M ?%   &       !% (      8 !  ," 0  "  "  "!   "  "  " &   ;

 <     !  " & &      & "  

        AA        &    I      

+ 8

 !     A    "   

    "    0   8!  "># " ?!.8      A 8    4    "     AA 0 " "  " "!  " ">  ?   >'  ?0   " AA !    8  % ( 0 "

 2

AA " >  ?;&  " !  "   + " !

>'  ?A !    " 8  "!   <      " "      "         

>4  ? 8 & ! ! "   2        )  1       ="!  1 15!116@!3 +

" A '  .8 !-. :  

 ;+        "  ,,  AA    3    8   + " 

     " "   A "!       ! " " 8

! A "



    0       &  ,,   "     &    



" I  - "3    8  23         " &   5  " "  " &      " !      %  ! "+  "" %   "  " + & " " N " " "  .&& "!    "   &    + "     &8 !  "     N " "     .&& " .8    ;+ ! . :   ! "     3 ;+  .8 & " ""  )  8

  0&   "     0 " ".8   !     ". :  ;+  ! ""  8 + "0 "  "   & 

 <  % F O+      5       "  ; +    A !      "    " 4  ;+ A !  "              0

  O ! 5 -B %   "         < .8 A !  "  <     !   

AA         AA       8  3  

         + "

  %        " " +&  +  "       0  " "& "   "0     

 "

!     I    "  "  & ! +,," >8(( ? +   ;  "   /  &"

0 "& "   <  8 !  &  "    +  "  .   "  I 56162!  +  "  I 21222 %  "

   < 60 " " " " ! !    !      " "    .   "       A !   

 8  !

 8

   

0 "    +>  ?

>  ?   23 "      " "   "      

!     

 4        +  "  "   AA" "  I $: ! -  .E ! %"  0 " 

"     !   +       + " !  

 

 +   >   ?%   8 

0     "!.8   " 8+  $C !  .8     2      25)     ". :  ;+     " ".8 8      <  +&  +  "4  .8  "      < % F! "   

" !  8 2  0" .8   " 

! "

!    "  "++       !          <          "    

; .8 A"   " " + "

+&         AA "!  " " +  "    AA ! " "   2   1      2   1 ="! 3@!     "  AA

 & ! + ! 

    &  +   >   ?;8     8 )"   + # 8 A !     " " '   .8 ! - . :    

  ;+    " +  AA        ,,   "  !        + " 0 "   " " 8

    N " " +      !        "     &       +&  +  " )"  # 8  

 A     8 =   @

 !  AA

 ! ""  A "

 

 3   " D   " " !     " !  < " 

!A "        1         %89$%99: 2     +&  # 8  + "

    "+      "  !   + "  !  "       A !     !  "   " +     & +8  ;&   +    +  +  +"  2       ) ) /  )  1          &    &   ;"!  23@!       "!   +   &  " 2 A  +      +    +  &" +8  9  1    ="!51@!   + 8       "'   .8 ! 

  ;+    - . :   !      3    8   "   8

 !       !+ "    

AA   N " " <AA   &   ! & " "   "    & ! &8  +     633 & " "  !  "  &       +&  +  "    6 9

&  "

 

+ "="!!253!25!253!53 629 2"!  226@!   P   "  '   .8  & !     # 8    "! %  

    "  &  %   !     +   63  # 8  !  AA    >  ? " & %  !



A     !    "    &   "   +      8  !     

!  "  &    '   .8 !           ># "  ?!   >    ?     >'  ?    !    "  &    ># " ?- . : !           .8      >    ?      >'  ?   !  "  &    %  >'  ?! %     # 8    >   ? AA !. : !;+  .8  "       " %     "  '   .8  &      AA

   !       ! "  +  " &   

 ;+ !   "   $C  -  !  

    "  "  "     AA 

""       '8     "  &  >.8 ? I '   .8 !  %  # 8  "    ! >.8 ?   + ""  '8     "  &  >  ? I %   !  

 3   !   %      "9  .      &    I +8   +  ! " # 8 ! "

8 < "!;+ !. : !    +   "="!15!21!5 53!9"!52!63@9  . )  * 

   &    ="!  5569 "!  @!     # 8  8&       !       633 & .8 !# 8  8&   +&  +  "!   "    63 9  <       &  (    # 8  A 

      + ="!6@!  A !3  

   +   "      >   ?.8 !;+  . : ++ " < 0 "A "!    " "

 + "0" " "

  I       "  & ! ;      "     !  &      " "

 8((  4 "     4  A

     +    .8     "  ;+  . & !     &! "       +  "   "  &  # 8  &  &    +  !  " .8 ! ;+    . :  & "     " A    +     + 8  4  "   # 8  &  !      !

 "   &";+ !.8   . : +;&   ;  &  &   &   !  "

 + &          0&  4  A

     A +    2!      " # 8  &    +  !    &  53     # 8  &  /D  %   1 .  &   !  

.8  +   63 9 

&    I 0 03Q51 ="!  @!       "!    "

 ++  !65

" 82R  <   !  +   <   !6 902="!2@90.3Q16="!22@9  *  &         )   ="!22!2139"! 1!25@9  )*  &  =2"!25@!     " ";+ !.8 !. :      " 8 < "9 

    &   #     .8   ="!  2@!   &8!  # 8      "A   & !A  "

  "  

 "   " &  AA"   "!    "!  "      !    8   !  AA"    .8 ! ;+ ! . : !       +  AA    " "  "    " "     4   .8 ! ;+    . :  A !    8   !  "      "!   & "     8   "  0 A8 AA"   .8 !# 8     8      ! "  "  # 8   + "

 !  

    

       %  A !# 8  "        8   .8  

    "     A !.8 !   " # 8       

  " ! && !  +    8 # 8   &8   "   

"     "      && "    A "    "          .8           # 8     %  

       + " " .8  &   I      # 8        " !     8  "   "  .8   8  "

+  +&  " !    8   "   .8        %      &    !    !  .8     "    AA

  # 8  + "    .8  A !

  ;+    . : A !.8     "      "      

 <  "  # 8     "  ! "  . :     ;+   + "      # 8  & "       &

   %    "  .8  A !     # 8      "!   8 !

 +     .8  # 8    ""     

 !

  # 8  +  " 

   +,, 8&+   ! 

   AA"   "  "  A   + 

&      "A   0  . :    

  A

  !  AA"      +  "      ;+ A     +& ;+   A

 !

   "  

"  ;+      !. :  " !  <      "    .8  +   ;&  "     " A    .8 !     "  <    

")

  " " <    ;+  ;  !  &8    " ".8 # 8 

+ ! 

 &   .8         &    

 <   # 8 

 !         & "

 

 "        # 8  +



"     " AA"   "     "A      8!  AA"    +   A  "       "

AA"       "     !# 8  8  " %AA"    .8 ! . :    ;+  A  &&  "   8 & "  8    "   "         

!# 8   "      A  !   8!  

 "A     AA "     !  AA"      +  " &  "!# 8  8 AA"   " # 8 A !     <    AA  .8 !;+  . :  %   A !.8 !;+  . :  " "   !& " " &   !    "

&  .8  

       +  "!

 & "     A  A    

 

.8      8!  # 8  A "   +& "       "!   " A "        "   0"   "    )      )A !

# 8      <    %" 8   " !   "   <  # 8  &         .8  A !  8    AA     .   )6. 7A !

  <      # 8  A  !  8   .8 # 8 && !  8    AA   .8    ;+       8   0& !  "  # 8 

 .8 !;+  . : " 

 " # 8     !  & "      "  "A   "      !     "   !  "     "   "   !  A

     "  "        "  )             !   "  A "     &   "  "    +

!    "    "   A  "+ 

++     "  "  &

   4      # 8  A     8  



  " !    A   "   A # 8 8 

  + "

+  + &&   !     8  "       !  # 8  "  A " .8 ! ;+    . :  !   &&"  8 "

!          "  0  &8   " " # 8  A  ! "     ! A "  

      AA           "   .8 ! ;+    . : !  "   1 )

 A

63     

 1 # 8       

 8  "        & 

 !  "       "   

  A  "

   .8 ! ;+    . :   1      8 "   % A 8 A 8   !  # 8  8 "   8   " +A  "

 .8 !;+  . :           " "   A  "

  4   AA"    &  "!# 8  " !&   & 

  "!    8   !         

     0  &8     # 8   !

    "      ! +    8  "       & 

         "    AA  <  ! # 8    "   " !      +       8            " A    !    "   "         "  AA"      !# 8 

  "!   !

     " !   AA"  " .8 !. :  ;+        &!   !   &&"   8 "

 %         "        "  "   # 8 A "  & "



 "   "   !   !.8 !. :  ;+  " "      A "

        "   "            ! & " "  "  +

    

"     0 " "  "     .8  &8 

+  ! &     " &  " # 8       !     +  !     +

     +&  +  " &  "

 +  !

      

  !   !   AA"    A    + & " &&  "  # 8     >  ?A   8  "         " A ! "   8 " " !    0 A   )6. 7( & ! # 8   . : !.8  ;+  " 

!+&  "       AA % 8   &" !           A "   "  # 8  # 8   A & " !         " ! & " .8 !. :  ;+ !  

  "  "   A "      8!  " A "    A   & " 0           >  ?! &   ! " # 8  8     %    

&    " & !   # 8    

  "  " 0  &8 # 8  A  !    "    .8 ! . :    ;+    & %

  8!     "" 

   # 8  A "!        +  AA "   ! "  "  .8 ! . :    ;+ !  " "      

 &  !         "  AA"       +  " A       AA"      A!      " AA   .8 ! . :  ;+ ! "     + # 8 A    AA

    >  ? A  !

      " " &     +   <  " &  !   &8!  . :  " 8 <      "      %    <   2    321  "    8 "      ! "  A "   !  +&  " !   

    AA !   & "  "    "          A+& 

 .8  A >   "

" !   

?  " !         ! &8!       

  .8             !           

 5  %AA"      +  A   &8!  "  A         AA  . :  ;+   )"      8!  # 8  + 

 &   " A "   +& "   "    + 8        AA"   +        <   

AA"  +!  8  "   &    !  + !.8 !. :   ;+  AA"     0  &8# 8 A  !.8 !. :  ;+  " "  AA     >   ?=  <   E    @ 0  &8# 8  + "

+   +  03Q51!  # 8   + "

 &  " !65 

 +8 !



"   <   !

 +   <   !6

    8      1661  &&  6!

  AA + "  "  !      !

    .

          <         ! 

        +    22   &      <   

   ! A "    !

 8 8

  !!!

 

! !!

 %    "!# 8  &  "  <           # 8 A .8 !. :  ;+  " "  AA  >  ?! 

 <      !   !        AA"      +  A    AA              AA !  "     % +8  +   "1    ! "   +  AA ! &  " ! &8  

   # 8 A  !    .8 !. :  ;+   "   ! " >    ?!   <    %"       # 8  

 <     <   &"   !  # 8 A   

 .8 !. :  ;+ 

  <     2 !  + 8    !    +   +  "     +8 !



" 

 <   !  &  ! ;    8    

    +   !

    "     8  "  & 

 + +     0    + A    "!   ! 8 +     

AA      "   !            

!

 &"8!  + + + "  A  + " " ! "  &  %     8!         " "      +  +    "

   

 AA"      !    +   "    AA  "

 <        8  "  !  AA"              <     "

   AA

 !  A     "!      

  + ! AA  3+      +& +       + + ""  

 &     8!  " "    AA  AA

 !  !     + !   "    "!       !   

 AA"   + & "

 6          A     !         "   "  +  <    AA       "! !  +  # 8  " "     "A .8 !. :  ;+ ! "      !

  8!  " +    8  "  &        " "  %  + 8 "  ! AA"   ".8 !. : !;+ !  ;+   " 8  "         <   ! & 

      !  " & 8   +      AA"    &  8  "     & 

!

 .8 !. :  ;+  AA"    &  " "

     + !

    + "  <           8!     " " AA"    .8 ! . :    ;+  AA    & +

   # 8 # 8 ++ "A  !

       ! 

  !      AA"      A  !

    "  "     "&  "

   +B   "!.8 ! . :    ;+     "       "  # 8       A "

!   )

  "  

"   &     "     A "

     "        %AA"   ;+  . : A "! "   " "    !

 .8 A "!  "  "  ! # 8     ! A 8A "  # 8 A  +    + 8     "    ;+  & !           "

      A      !  "     % ;+       +     "  "      A

 ;+   !       8   "  "  A "  !  %     # 8       AA   +&  .8 ! . :    ;+   + "

!

                # 8            0"  "   & ";+   " AA"       " ! "  

AA"     !   # 8      "+&   + "

    %       &;+     

  " AA"    %" !# 8  AA      "8 +& .8 !. :  ;+       ! &8     '8    A  ! "   + 

    " "     %   8!  " AA"   "   <  "   ! AA " " +  "       "  I    # 8 !     '8   !>  ?! !  !

    A  !&8 

!     &  "

 + " !  +  " !

  AA"          +  " A       )     (    /           "       "!      "     I +   !   " &&  ! ,,       "  +  9 



 +&      "!    "    >   ?!  " &&  9  ,  -      "!      "9

              "   !      "     >& 

& "?! " &&  9  .  . &        "   !      "     >& 

& "?! " &&    %AA"    .8 ! . :    ;+       " "     " "

  "   "  %AA"       +     "        AA&   

      0 "     " "   "   "      &&

 ! ""  %7& !  8  

   AA"   

AA       + " !  " 

  + "" "

!  "     " "   "     8  

  "  "        "  AA"   " 

AA" " + "  "  AA" + 

   &"  "  "  !    8   !  .8 ! . :    ;+      +    "!  " AA     0    AA

 + "   & ! 8 " 

    "     .8    "            '   .8 ! 

  ;++    - . :  + "    "  "!

  "  A  !  + ! + 8     8   &&                     %AA"   %   0   3     %7   +" 1!5! 7      7 21   &     "      % 7 13 &  "

      "      "! 3      +      =.8 !. :  ;+  " +"5  @   AA      >  ? A8      !    &       +

 +&    AA"     + "

!  " &+  +& !    

"     AA !  "   "  %           " &+ !     &     + 

       %     "  3     &

 +,,

  %      8  

!        +  ,, " &       ,, "  +      8  

!        "!        + 

    &     &     AA""     

     

 & "   "! + 8     &&           %713 & "

 !  +         %712

& "

  

    "  "!  "        &&

  "     ""  %7"222& !   ./    "   =>,0 AA"  %753+"! 73+"!3&   &" " + 

     "   %753+"!& 6=A @

    9  %73+"!3& 3=  @

          %7 3      '  .8       "A          "

9;  ?  

   "I   &             "    1

     "  

 ++  AA"  %753+"! 73+"!3&   &" " + 

     "   %753+"!& 5=  @

    9  %73+"!3& = @

         %73   

 ;+       "A          "

8;2 ?  

   "I   &             "    1

     " ,@,A  AA"  %753+"! 73+"!3&   &" " + 

     "   %753+"!& 5=  @

    9  %73+"!3& 3=  @

         %73   -. :       "A          "

5=  @  "        %7  " "   "   0   26     &   "          =  @ "  +&      +          ,  -  #; 2 ?  # ):&* 

   "I   &             "    1

     "   B5  AA"  %753+"!&  &"   + 

     " = @

                "    

     + 8     + 8  ! +& ! +         3=  @  " 5+&       " "  %713   "    +,,  &  &

!  C'     )  +      & " 8   %71 &   " "    && "     0  !   229

      

&& "    &  "   "   

9     "         

   "  "     &

    "  9 

 "

      

      +&  9 

  "

       

! ,,   ++

 



    "  

"A  "    

    " . .0,+  AA"  %753+"!&  &"   + 

     " 2

                "    +  

     + 8     + 8  ! +& ! +         =  @  " 5+&       " "  %712   "    +,,  &  &

!   +   + C'    )        "  

"A  "    

 

 "    !

   +    !&  " 

 " " I 8 < "!  " "   "  "!

  " AA"    .8 ! ;+ ! . : !     0 + !  

     0   +    !   "    

   .8 ! . :    ;+  A  "      

 "     ! <  " A   

"!

 "+ "" 



 " 

     AA"    '   .8 ! 

  ;+ ! - . : ! %     "  +   A &  2:99       AA"   -. :  &  + 

 %$9    @      *) 2  /        

  +  "  8  $%$#  !  

   " .  +  "  8  #C8          " + 

 $C#$9   



 +&   

  +  "  8  %$$9  !        " + 

 $C#$9    ,  -   

  +  "  8  %$$9  !        " + 

 $C#$9            

    +   "   8    :D  ! 

       +  "  8  #C8         " + 

 $C#$9   

 2 .  . &     

    +   "   8    #$8D9  !   

    %  $  +   "   8    #C8      + 

  

      /   (   + 899    &  " "    "    "  .  "

   +    2351%)$)  D +  !   8536551       

   "   0     

    +   8"     .  +& &   !      "  8 

     1+& &         

+& &  +&   )

         .   " #  $      

%                  4                         

 3