Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Court Decisions Legislation Analyze in Legislator
4-05-682\1 ECLI:EE:VMK:2006:4.05.682.21770 AI generated

4-05-682\1 · 4-05-682\1 · Viru Maakohus Narva kohtumaja

Case Number 4-05-682\1
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia · Case Law (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Summary

AI generated

                                    ! ! "     # $ %! %  "  &      !   ' !! "  &           (  ) * ! +!    ,  -( .  / 0   (   ( 1   ! ! "   !   2 ! 33 45  ! ...

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full Text of the Judgment · 4-05-682\1

                             

  

   ! ! "

    # $ %! %  "  &      !   ' !! "  &       

   (  ) * ! +!    ,  -( . 

/ 0   (   ( 1   ! ! " 

 !   2 ! 33 45  !   !  ' !!   &  / 



       -(  . 

/ 0   2 !  / 

      &  (  1   ! 33 

   44""33 !  ' !!  

( 66() 78  

 (!   5/ 5    

( !  !6   "

  55 4  9

   5  ("3 &  34!  ' !! !( (-(        2 !  &

  5 (     &

        )   ( 

"/    5) 78 

 (!    ) 

 

( &   &    5  "      345 (  " ( 5  &

    5   :  )   ( 

  (       6   (  &

 ;( 0$5  !"2 -% ! ") !  1 -  5 0! . & 5    5  / (   )   &      5  

  

( &  5  (" !  5 

 ( (      !

(' !!  66  ( 5   )   &     

" 33 34  &

5    ; 4/      / ( ;(  !  7  (&

 )  (    &

 5 0!   (&

"

(/ (  (  1

     :  )   )  :   (     :     2   ! "        "  

  / " (  !

"        :     5    / (   (  7  )      5    6  "   5        : 

  1

    -% !   5 

(  5()  !  ; !  /   " 5   ;(  !   .  /    1

   $5  ! )     ;(  ! /  " 5  5 0! /  6 (  )  / 

 (  6  " ' !!   (!  / ( 5 5(   : (   7 ! ( (  &

  )   (   ((

! 5 ()6 (  " 5  (& "  (

 5 "  (   (    ' !!  

! ("  ( "   ' !! 

66(    5    ((6 (           

      ! "  #$  ! #   %  !  &       &  ! 6  (6  "   &

 5   "5 !&/   <7(= 34"5( ! 5   !   5  5(; ! /      :  ! " !

  !    (   (        > !( 6  ("   :   ((/ (    "  #$   6   5 "     &

  5     "   

    : " 

 /  7    (' !! ";(  !  !6     !  ( ' !!   : 1

   -   ' !!      (  ( 

 )    : "      !  ' !!  6  "   ( ! (  ! 



      &   6   5 "      &

  5 (    1

 



( ' !! " ;(  ! " 5 0!  )6    "  (  2 ( !

("    ! 



1

      : )  &  ( )   5 /     ( ' !!     ( ! ( &

   ( .    ' !! /  (          '     " 6  "  33 5 &  ::

   !    5  ? &  



 6  "   &

 5    5  5  ' !! !  0 -    /! &

5   7(/   .   ; 4   (&

' !! " 5 0!  ;(  ! 5  &

 

1

    5  ' !! "   / " 5  6 5  /    5   !

 < ( /  ! 55   ("  =     &

 5 0! " /    /    (    !

 &

     ( ;(  !  

 / ' !!  5 0! /( ((&

 6      &

 ( 6  "    ! ( !

   6  "   5 :: 5        !  ; !  /    ) /(( ( ! ( 5 5      :    ' !!  5 0!  5  

 "  ( (5  

(  (  ! &"  (/  )

 (  &

      " !  &" ' !!     ( & ( 5 5(  

 ( (   .   ! &"    &  :    )    ! ( (    6  (" 5    ( !  5      %(  " 6  " 33  3/   &

5 (  ;  4 /    ( &

 ' !!  &    9

( 5   / ( )  :  )  6   / ("5/  ( ( (  ! 5 "!( (( 5  ( 

 &

   " ( (   5  / ( ' !!   5    5 

 (    ! @    )  ! 6  " 33 &

5 (   7(/      )    1

       "  (   ! (" 

 ( 

(  )    ! ( ( 2   $ !( ! " '   ) !    91 

!  6  ("  



( 6  "   ! ( ' !!     :  &

(  ! ( (   " ! "!

 

5   ) (    &     " 5   

 " / 

  (  "   ("  ( !    5   "     & ! 5 "  

    44""33 &  

 4     6 ( " !  ' !!  ( /(&) 78 

 ( !         &" !  ' !! / (33   &

 5     34   5  ("5    66 / (("!( ((&

       )   ( 

"  ' !! / ( 5  () 78 @      &"   ! 5     66 ( ( 6  "    

6(5    ("   ( 6  /   ("   ( &

      ( )   6  "   ' !!  !  ( " 5(    &

  $5  ! )(

  5   6 ($5  !6  " ' !!   &    

! 5  )  " !( ( ( 5  ( 

 &

    2( 6  (     

(  )  6         ' !!  66(  !  

5/ 5  @      &"      6  ("   ( 6  (    5     

5    A ) !(  1 " (  ;(  ! " 2  -% ! " -   5 0! " > !    > !"(   5 6(    &        !

(  // 5  "     )   ! 5        " ' !!  ( (!    (@     &" / 

 (  /( ("   6 (   ( (5

(  &

    

 (6  ( ( ! (" (  )   ( 6  (  "    ( &

 5     "5           (" !&

  ("   &

 ! )(&

 / ( 5 5( ! ( &

  (!(   :      .   

()  ! (" ' !!     !   &    (    & / 



  6 ( " 5   7 8 B  3 / 3   / (   C (  "(( 78(3434 "      "  *         )  +,-,.-.++/-     .00+!+/!+,+,++  !    12.3,*, 4* -  ) 

  !&   ( 

  &  ;  4 /!   

 

 ! 5 /!       (   

   5      /!  

   ! 5 /!     ! !  )          D