Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Court Decisions Legislation Analyze in Legislator
1-06-5044\7 ECLI:EE:PMK:2006:1.06.5044.19017 AI generated

1-06-5044\7 · Pärnu Maakohus Rapla kohtumaja

Case Number 1-06-5044\7
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia · Case Law (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

                                   !"                 !" #$%$& ' (!   "  !" #$%$&)##)#&   * +!     ...

Legislator headnote

Placeholder

Keywords

Placeholder

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

                    

              !"               

 !" #$%$& ' (!  

"  !" #$%$&)##)#&   * +!     #$ "%& %''%"   &

( )**+ ,, "- -.&/ /0  //  " & 0  )  12    ,   "  - -.&  %1 ,  1" & 0/) 1/*3 "- -./ " & 0 )  3 "     - - .         /  " &   , - '' &  / 3 " 0)/ 3 "- $ .&  , ""  0)// 3 " - $.&  , " "    1%"   " &&"4$" "    !  &5 %& &%'' %"   &  

()/13 "- -.&/ /0 /  /  " &     &6    0 )/3 "- -.& %/ %%/,1

 " & 0/)13 " - -.&1 %/ %%/,1 " & 0 ) 1/3 "- -..& ,/ %%/  " &        , 0 ) 1/ 3 "     - - .& /     %%/%    ,  1        "  0)/$ - -./ %%/ " & 1)*$ - -./  %%/      " &     /% "      " &&""3 &  ,   $66&  & # $ " - $ .     & % 1% * ,  , 7  /&" % &" &&- $./* 6   &"7

-  & &"   -   &  $66&  & !  & 5  - $ .     & % 1% * ,  , 7   &"   $66&  & !  & 5  - $ .      ,  , 7    &"   $66&  & !  & 5  - $ . *    ,  , 7    &"   - $./ ,  & /" % &" &&- $ ./* 6  &"7

-  &"   -    " " /    % " "  8  &     &    & * " "   -   &  27 &"  ,#$ ",!  &5     , 7#$ ",!  &5 &     +! ,!   , 7#$ "*   $"9, ":  , 7#$ "  $ , &  , 7#$ "  # $   , 7!  &5  %1  !  

 , 7!  &5 /        , 7 # $ "      &    & ; &      "& "

 / *1% "    *  < %    &  &   % %  

% 7& & )  , 7 !  & 5       &    & ; &      "& "

 / *1% "    *  < %    &  &   % %  

% 7& & )  , 7# $ " / %1     7      & ; &      "& "

 / *1% "    *  < %    &  &   % %  

% 7&,)  , 7!  &5 /%  7    & ; &      "& "

 / *1% "    *  < %    &  &   % %  

% 7&,)  , 7 !  & 5  /1        & ; &      "& "

 / *1% "    *  < %    &  &   % %  

% 7& )  , 7 # $ " *          ,& , &  &    & ; &      "& "  / *1% "    *  < %    &  &   %% % 7&)  , 7 !  & 5  *          ,& , &  &    & ; &      "& "  / *1% "    *  < %    &  &   %% % 7&)  , 7      " &&" 4 $" " '' 7    %/    , 7   " &&""3 &''7    %/    #7 &&6 ,&  &"&  # 7    "   &      ,  , 1 " ,%   "7  "  

 #  "7  &  , 2         ,&",%"%     "7 "&   $ & %7  % %   ,&, & & "7  &   ,7  6  , - &    & , , &% &   &   ''     - &"  7  "  "6 ",     $66&"&#$ "%  "      & "  , !5   ,"          &  7 -"- 6+!"= , " &>    &? @  9%   /  % >    &? @  9     1   %   #        %        # 

   *   % "   A !B       % ",A!B     %       % "       %   

  9C       %  6  6 C C         %  &  

      % 7        %  & 

      % 

     /   % 7   & 

      %     D 

  /  %      %    ,    &  ,         %  ,    "           %               %     ,      *   %   @      *  %,        %/,         1   % / ,            % ,         //   % 1,         /*   % ,         /*   % /,            %  ,      77&  

         %  ,      77&  

         %  ,      77&  

      /1   %  &     &       /1  %B&     %E 66"7 &      %'' &&;D  %   ,? @  9%  #% # )%         %2    

      % &,       %    

      % 1 &       /   % &        % &     1   % /          %         %"     %       % ''         %         %         %   , "     

   %  , "       % /           *   % /              %     %1     %         % &   1  %"7     /  %/             %          1  %,        %/ 6           % "&     /   %"       %  ,$ "%  &  ,   ,         % / &" ,        %66 ,     %  1

      %"&     %       &      /   %             %            % &     /   %  7       % *  &      1  %*"7  7          % /          %    & 

   /*   %   , &    1   %   ",&% /           11   %    ,

    %F     *  %         1   %    7        1/   %             *   %       &           %     :      *1   %      "          %       "          %     B     %    -,

     % ""         %    " &  &   /   % " >"

      % %  "    & & "&       %2G&  &   /  % 2&

    %   F"      % H?  $        +!I"  ,

/11    $66&" #$ "%  "      & " % ,"  /* /*/ "77 ",  "7    &        # " & 6   $"9, ":I"" ,,   "   "   "        %  "      %*          % 2  "  "7        %          7&      1   %        &      , 7 " "  %  "  6        7   /    # $ "" ,/  ,7       $66&" #$ "%   "      & " % ,"  *      **  *     "77  ",  "7   &    3 "3 "3   6        $ ,  &I " " ,,

  "           &       %

  

        %        % 7        % &        % ''"

      %  J" 6       % 7        %                    % ,  $        %

"     1   % "       %

@       %       /   % 7 "  "      %     &  ,7 ""& %" &&, "  "  "  "&% %  , & &   #$ "  " ,  %" , 7      $66&"&#$ "%"    &" %,!5  1*     & "77  ",  "7    &       7 "    &    -  "   & 6 " +  " ,    " &     &   "      %    " ,%   , 7 "    %&"     % ,    "      %   "      % ''     "      %  & , "    "     %, "    %" &"      % &%  % " ,"    %" 

 "    %  &"     % " && 6  "   /   %         7 "      %  "    % "     , "  ,&  &     " ,    $66&"#$ "%"    &" %," /*      &- "+6"#  $ I"    ''&&"    " ''    " "

       , &&  6  6, "    "        %"7  &,          "  , /    , 7       $66&"#$ "%"    &" %    ",  6 4   

   7 ",  "   D  -   7& F & C 

        11#>?    66&  " &   &  C "      % 7  9C "   1   % 7    2$  "    % J "         

   " & 7&    66& " &   " "    "     & &6  "  /   ;6  &/  )%" "  "    

 &     "    ;  &/   )%&" ,7" D-   7  $66&" !5 %   "      & " %       " ""  &       "    &  "7  6 !   "7      ,;/    "    *     ,      "      )% & !   ,        

     &

 &  &  , /        

 &

  , 1 ,    "" &  

 ,% ,       7,  $ 66&66&"&#$ ",!5 - $.  & %1%*, "@ "      $66&"!5 "& & 2 

        ,   &   && / , " &  %  1  7   "   &   ,   &     &&         &            , "7   D   " 

!5 "&.   %"&   &   %    ,   @ %./  

  "&@66 " 7     &  ,. % "7   &"&%  "   $ 66&66&"!5 - $. * , "@ "       $66&"!5 "& &  2      && 

 6 % &6"&, 1 

,6  6     & ", ,6 6   &&   & 7  , , "7&    D   "   !5  !7  ,& .      %   %    "&7  ,  7 7  ,  ,&   $ 66&66&"!5 - $.   , "@ "       $66&"#$ "   &66&  $66&"!5    &66&  -  %  66&" #$ " , !5   +!   "      7 & & &

 $6 & "  % & %@    "%-"- 6 +!  &  7   -  +! ,!    &6 %" &,&   ,  "%,"     7    & -  "  , "  7 66& && &  !     %   6 & ""7    % 7 & "   % @        "%#$ "&%#,"7 !  "& &(

 %&,%  &%& %7%    %  %   

 & &,  %&" &% & &%   , "%   %  &     & , "7  7  % &   %   %  % 6%     $66&"#$ ",!5 6 %6  

  % @      "%  66&"& ,"  &- "+! ,!    " &66&&& &  $66&" #$ " , !5      &&   7 """&,&&"&  $66&"&#$ ",!5  66"7 &,&"&  &66& ""&,&  -         66&"&  #$ " , !5   &    + , !  "  ,  /1    -     &  &" & &

/%1 -  & +3!"&66&"", 7&,

    ,7  &, $66&"&#$ ",!5  "  "  "&% & "7"&  %  &  "  &,7 &  &     && 

& $    66&" #$ ",!5 & ", 7      +! ,!   -  %  66&" !5   7    

  ,"      7 & & &  $6 & "  / %  %@    "%  7     &      ,% 

      & 7        &  &%/%, 

,"7          "%  7        !    -  !     &6  "%"        / 6  /  "   %    "  & &  % "7&/    % 7 &&  2 , -  6 % 6       / % @      "%  /    , 6 -& -& % ,  & 7  &   !  ,& "& ,

&"  -  -    , %   ,    2   ,     "  6 & 

  / % @  %

  ,"  */  "%-"7     ," */ ,1 ,    2 , -" = &  6     "%  /  &   , ''&2 ,"&  ,   2 ,          ", "& %   7 

"$C % &&   7,       K @& ,    &      1/     "%   , -= &   &   @& !5 %   &

''     "  6 & 

  // % 7 & "   / %","7  D /%    L   "% ,-= &   /  &    L!     7   %!5     2 , # &  + &   6     "%   "%  7  6        " %    "    ,,  ,  %    "&

  "7& &% , %  "   $66&"!5 6  "% "  

  &   &  7   

  ,%/   ,   7

  / % 7 & "    / %

   L% ""   7  "77  &     /  "%!5 "7   L, ""  7 "77  &   

$66&" !5      &&   7 " ""& ,&&"&  $66&"!5  66"7  ,&"& 66&""&,&  -         66&" !5   &    !   "  ,   %1    */    , 6 & ""7   "  1  %    & &

  ,%  /%     66& D< 36

       %        , 6 & ""7   "    %    & &   ,%  %    % %   &%1%  %1%/1 6& 66&D<36

     *1/%1   D< 36

 1    %  "

    "      ,  & 

  & /     & , & *1/%/     $   "   D< 36

  &  %1     $  ,    !     %1  &, "     -  !   66&"", 7 , & %1  $66&"!5 " ""&%"7  %    , &  %1  &, "  $    66&"  !5  ", 7   %1      !    -         66&" !5   &       ,  /         " 7      &         *1  KK  &    %*  ,  "   &     K  &  

  & % ML-        /  *1  KK  &          " &  , 

  & 

  %  ML  &   %  "  "&   &% %* %  ML  7 & %  &  "&

  & ,  

 & $     , 

 /     7      & % /% %     

 & & & & , &"&     -          7

 &# " "& &   7      & % /% %  , & ,&    %    7     &%/%% &   ,   ,

1 %  ", "& &.  &   *    *  1 ,  -         &, #" $     66&" ", 7  , /    $66&" !5  " ""&%"7  %   &   & , 

 /    $    66&"  !5  ", 7 /       -  %  66&" #$ "  $9, ": " , "       7 & & & 

$6 & "  /*%@   "% &  6 " $9, ": " ,,     & ,"  /*/*          -  $ ,9, ":6  "%," / /*     &   " ,, &  6 ,     " & 66&&& &  2 ,3& 6  "% *=  ''&&" " " %  $ & ''& = &  $66&" #$ " 6 % 6 ,      %@   "%66&"#$ ""  ,"  //* &  6 $9, ": " , 66& && &  $66&" #$ "     &&   7 " ""& ,&&"&  $66&"  #$ "   66"7   , &"&   66& ""& ,&  -         66&"  #$ "  &    $9, ": "  ,  /    -    $9, ":   66&"", 7&,

/ ,7  & ,  $66&"#$ "" ""&%"7  %    "  & , 7 &  &     && 

& $    66&" #$ " ", 7  *       $9, ":  -  %  66&" #$ "  $ & " , "       7 & & &  $6 &  "   **% @  %       "%  ,"  ***          &3  6"$ &" ,,  $     **%    $ & 6     "%  ,"  ***          & 3   6 " " ,,   " &   66& && &  $66&" #$ " 6 % 6 ,      % @      "%  ,"  ***          3   6 " " ,,   " 66&&& & 

$66&" #$ "     &&   7 " ""& ,&&"&  $66&"  #$ "   66"7   , &"&   66& ""& ,&  -         66&"  #$ "  &    $ & "  ,       -    $ &   66&" ", 7 & , 

     , 7   & ,    $66&" #$ " "  "  "&%  "7   %    "  & , 7 &  &     && 

&$  66&"#$ "", 7 1    $ &  -  %  66&" #$ " , !5   +   "      7 & & &  $6 & "  1*%@   "%  1*     &   & 6 " +   7 "    &      "& ,,&  ", , &%   + "  9,   % &+ "& ,&  -   +  6     "%       & 6   1*   & 7 "    &   , " & 66&&& &  2 , #  D,  6     "%  1*   4

 ",, %+  ,,  7&%   &  < ,%   2  +  2 ,&6  , !5 $,  2      , , & -   & "  &&   3  &+ &"7&,&  2 ,  -&  -  , <  -6 6     "%  & &4

 ",%# D,  & &"  !5 % #$ "-

    ,

 7&  2 , @ ! 6     "%  1* 4

  ",    !5  ,#$ "%  " &  %     &,  $66&"#$ ",!5 6 %6, 

  1% @      "%   &  1*  &  +     & 6 7 "    &   " &66&&& & 

$66&" #$ " , !5      &&   7 """&,&&"&  $66&"&#$ ",!5  66"7 &,&"&  &66& ""&,&  -         66&"&  #$ " , !5   &   + " ,  & &   &     &"   -  %  66&" #$ "  #$   & "       7 & & &  $6 & "  1%@  %    "%  ,"  /*       + 6 "#$  "    -  # $ 6  "%," /*       + 6 "   "   ," 66&&& &  #$   , % 7 & "    % @     "%#$    &" &

   $66&" #$ " 6 % 6 ,      *%@   "%," /*  

 &  + 6 "   "   ," 66&&& &  $66&" #$ "     &&   7 " ""& ,&&"&  $66&"  #$ "   66"7   , &"&   66& ""& ,&  -      66&"#$ " &  #$  "  ,      -   #$    66&" ",

7 & , 

    , 7   & ,   %  , "& &  7&& &    & ,    $66&"  #$ " "  "  "&%  "7   %    "  & , 7 &  &     && 

& $    66&"#$ "", 7    #$   -  %  66&"#$ "D-   ,  "      7 & & &  $6 & "  %@  %    "%  ,"      ,  6 4  



   " D-   7&    11 #>? 7 ", "   -  D -  6  "%    ,  6 4   

   " D-   7&    11#>?7 "," ,66" &,  

   66& &&  &% &    , 7 "    "  7  2 , #    6     "%   %  D-   &    "  &   6 %     " #$ "   4     4 #F- &  &,&  "    $66&"#$ "6  "%66& " &  " D-    ,  

   66& && &  $66&" #$ "     &&   7 " ""& ,&&"&  $66&"  #$ "   66"7   , &"&   66& ""& ,&  - %66&"!5    &    7 & & &  !     % 7 & "   1% @   "%!5 &2   ,"7 /, "&    $66&" !5  6     "%    &  "    & 2       &   && / , "&        29/ L*     "%   &'' &&,6&  1&   & 7   "    # &  &  &    &  & & "&  D  "  !5 "&. %  %  "&    &   %    ,   @ 0./  %   "&@66 "  7     & ,. % "7   &"& %  "   $66&" !5      &&   7 " ""& ,&&"& 

$66&"!5  66"7  ,&"& 66&""&,&  -  %  66&" !5   7  ,  &    7 & & &  !     % 7 & "   1% @   "%!5 &2   ,"7  6   $66&" !5  6     "%    &  " &2    &  &&6       #!/1/L*     "%    &  & "     ,6   6   $  6  7   D  "  !5 !7  ,&.  &% %    "&7  ,  7 7  ,  ,&   $66&" !5      &&   7 " ""& ,&&"&  $66&"!5  66"7  ,&"& 66&""&,&  $66&"#$ ",!5      &66  $66&"#$ "     &" ,& - $ . 1 ,    ,  & ,& 6"   -   &"& ,& &"&- $.*,   $66&" #$ "   "    &  

    

 , 6 6 

" 

 

 7& "&7   "       &      &  "        & $    #$ "  & , &  & -  & & 66&" #$ "  &     -   &      & ,&    & !& & , 7 

   "&%  %66&"#$ "  &"      &     7     -  "   ,%  #$ "6&    $66&" !5      &" ,& - $ . 1 ,     ,  & ,& 6"   -   &"& ,& &"&- $.*,   $66&" !5    "    &   

    

 ,  

" 

 

 7& "&7 $    !5  "     7 "7 & -  & &

66&" !5   &

    -   &      & ,&    & !& & , 7 

   "&%   %  66&" !5     & "     &  7        7   &    " &&" 4$" " 7        ,

(     "   /  0           *   - 1*  %   &   *N%/%/    7  & " &&"3 &7  

   ,

(     "   / 0        * -1* %  &    *N%/%/      - (