Legislator Swiss Legal AI Agent European & Swiss Legal Corpus
DE FR IT EN
Court Decisions Legislation Analyze in Legislator
1-06-5072\2 ECLI:EE:VMK:2006:1.06.5072.17493 Kohtuotsus AI generated

1-06-5072\2 · 1-06-5072\2 · Viru Maakohus Narva kohtumaja

Case Number 1-06-5072\2
Court / Authority
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus
Jurisdiction Estonia · Case Law (EE)
Open official source ↗ Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Decision Summary (Facts, Holding & Outcome)

AI generated

                  !"#""$%        &'()*      +,- ,.      /.,+0 0.0%      -0%10, 2,0/ % 334 / 0  5)'...

Headnote / Official Regeste

AI generated
                  !"#""$%        &'()*      +,- ,.      /.,+0 0.0%      -0%10, 2,0/ % 334 / 0  5)'...

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full Text of the Judgment · 1-06-5072\2

  

            

  !"#""$%  

     &'()*      +,- ,.      /.,+0 0.0%  

   -0%10, 2,0/ % 334 / 0  5)'+16$$5)+1 6$5'+1.71.8#/ 2,0/ % 334 / 0  5 )(+16$$5)+1.71$ +0660#0,0/+ 0   ,,0,/0,9%                        ,404%44+, 90+,%$-0/0,-0%9,  !"#$   ,, /4       334  % &'(   )* &+) .71. #77/  / 0  ' &,0+* //%,1 / /"  ,, /4 -0%10, 2,0/ % 334  % &',   ) * &+) .71 . #77/  / 0  ( &+#* //%,1 / /" 

 ,, /4-0%10, 2,0/ % 334 %)-( &.71.#77/ / 0 & *4 %,1 / /"   /%+/ 5'+1$3  / 0 / 0# 0,4# 0/00+$#: /+/ / 0 . /0

   1      + ,/ 0

  ./0      %-2 & *         + 

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

   "  %/ 5)+1+ 0+ / .+00+%,1 / !"","""$ "/"( 670%,,1#77/+:6+ / 0,&3 * /&3 /0 /*4& 3##0,4 0/ 0* 670%%,1 / /"      %-2 &    *        +   *   2/ 0

          1 

 +/  2,0/ %+0/:0,4;0+ /+# 000+4;/3 /4//  0.: /# 0+"  34          5   #         ,4 ' &,0+ // % 4* ,$ /+4= / . -0/0, -0%9, 6+/ #,+ .#0,0/+ 0  //4:1 <00 /)& // 0/ 0 40 /0 /*,  0,/$#,+/#6/010# 000 /& 0/ 0*,$0 60/ /010# 000 /) &3 40 3##0,4 0/ 0*, 0,/./ .-0/0,-0%9,6+//++ /# 0+ +0# 000 /('&3 //+# 4% 3##0,4,0+*, 0,/"  34                          #      

 0 60/ 40/010# 000 /(& 3##0,4+#//% 4 3##0*,"   /:0,44;# ,+# 4>+/ 060?0/ %>+/ 0 ,, 40 + <4 0  % &"'"" %/,1 , !!*;  60 #::/#0/01 @)$! #"$ /0+0?,44$44$4+ 046<0+004$60010+$4#,%40./ 016$ #,166A +0/4$ 604$ 4+,0 %  7%/4" <+/0+0?, B# ,1A /1 /4 #,+0"  7+.#: /0/4 ,4./+4/+0<3+0,4,4 #, /00#%0+4 %0+0, (') 0 / C 6,1  %: %0+4 %0+0 , ()$ %/0,#<0 )'!!" /+4 . ,4 %:< %<//+ /7/# 0 + / 4   . + //  0.: /# 00/0 /$#740 / # 04#0,4+0$0//010# /, /+40 %: ,4/ # 01$ #/#,+ .,#<.0 %:0++000 /,/+4%: ,4/ ,4"  1 ,:0/0 / # 0 # 0%/,14 /+0< 0 /4  / % /#. ,/ 0+0 0" //   40/ 0//7/+0/7/# 0 (670%#DD4# 0+//  0 .: /# 0 /$ 334+,00+01,:404%<//+/7/# 0.. +/ ,4"  4 0<# 04  //  0+0 %:< 0 /4 60++/ ,0<   670% . +  ,1,,/+0  /%/#.4%740/%/0#0,0/+ ,#40# 0+0/#0,0/+ 0 $ /0/40  /+0 .++/ 0< 0 0 /# 0 %/  0 /  670% . + //  0 +/# 0 /"   ./++/# 0+ /% /  -0%10, 2,0/ %/ 334 // 0 0++0 $ 0/  /0#$ /01/ 040  16    /% /#/  1$ +/0   # /  , !"" % +,, $ 0< 04 ++/$ 40  B/+ /0 . 6 3/6 0/0 ,0/0 04 0A 5 ( +1   7/0 ///$ 4%+/ #,4  04 ,4# 0 00 #71+ # 01 /% /#/  +/ ,/+  ,04 99/ . #?0/#, 0  1 0 $ #++0 / 6 < ,.<0 /0/# 0  %70#+/ 3#,0+0 ,#0 0+0$0< 04 ++/4 ,04/ /# 000 #71+0,4.0 .#0+ ;

 /0  40 += %$ >9, ( . 16    # +0+ /0 %0,,1 8#/ 2,0/ %1#33 %70 0 1 0 ,/+ ,04,#0//4.%0#+0,0%/0+0  /0+0%+,, $ 0++1 = 1 /  ,10+ /0!#..0 ..%0# !"""8#,/7,%+ 1E3 /.0 #33 #?0/#,,40+0 0.0%+0F  %0+>9,0 #0 0/06..0 #33 99/+ #%+0F • .%0#+  ., / 06/0#<, 0 + + . .%0#+  06/0#< / /< +:66, 0+ + 0,0%/0  /40  % +,,  #33  99//, +%.+,+0F #331 /.70+0.77,4#?0/#,1 0 ($1##+!""% //4. 7%:0/4 2,0/ %+//0#,,64# 0+6+/ 0/DD/./06+/"    

*                              +  *+    *   %&'2 &'(    +11 %&'( )*&+)    1  #//0#$++0  $0 %0#/#06,,4 5)(.)'.710//0,7/4/0$ +/0 # /,!""%+,, $0< 04 ++/#33 #?0/#,.99/ 0,0%/0+0+0+ /0+0 /0+0$ 0++1 = •  /<  0+ + . )"" >9,  #. .0  #33  %70 0  1 0  99/  + %,%+0$ /040 $ 0/ %,%$ 3,4,4 "'"!)!$ , +0+,0$    

 *                                         

      +  *+     *  %&'2 &'(    +11 %&', )*)    1 #/ /0#$ !"" 0++ !" 6 <,4 0  0 B>:.0  A .0  & ,10+ /0(<$%*/0#,,64# 0+/,1 +++0##0/ / /0/7/# 0+ +,4 4 >> 6+/ 0, 60/+0 ;  +, >E,%+0$ 00.0  +: / >E,%/  /0170 0+.6/$#++0/+0# 0,>E,% $/0/40  0++01,,/,+0 ?33 + /%+"    

*              4               

+11 %)-( &    "       334 // 0 0++0 $0//0#$+/0 # /,!""% +,, $0< 04 ++/$40 B/+ /0.6 3/6 0/0,0/0 04 0A5(+1  7/0 ///$16  #:01-0%10, 2,0/ %14%+/#33 ,/+ ,04 99/.#?0/#,%70 0 1 0 #0+ ;/0 40 +=%$>9, ($ 0++1  %0+#//0%70#0++#33 99/1,+0F

*                                +  *+    *  %&'2    +    * +11 %&'2 )*&+)    1  #/ /0#$ .%0#+  ., / , !"" ,4  /0#  / 0  +0% 0+4#40 +=%$>9,0,0%/0+0 /0+0,/#40/%/# 0 $ 0++1  !""" ,4  3++,#0//4 # " %,%+0$ " /9#2%+0 . " 2,0/ %+099/%/# 0 "

    

 *             4   6                          + 11  %).' &    1   :+ -0%10, 2,0/ %$/0#/ .+, 90+,%$8#/ 2,0/ %$/0# / .-0/0,-0%9,.,1,,6/% ,,,1,,6D ,,0,/ 0,9% %0+ "'""" :+#/4 +06601 ,:< 6D /  -0%10, 2,0/ %+0  / 0 = %&'( )*&+).71(/  0

 %,1 / /$ %&', )*&+).712/ 0

 %,1 / /$ %)-( &.71./0 %,1 / /" / / 0  #77/ . /0

  %,1 / /"  %,1 / 0 /$ ,#0+/ , / 0

    . /0  %,1 / / % /%+/  5 ( +1   0 6DD/ 0 0+0 /7/# 0+0$

  / 0.. + 2,0/ %06,0/#0//++///01 ,,1./0%,1 / /,/ 070"%/ 2,0/ %6+/%++%</4 01+/0 !""0 0+0/7/# 0+0+%/7/.+"  #+06601,:<6D/ 8#/ 2,0/ %+0 / 0 = %&'2 ) *&+).71)/ 0

 %,1 / /$ %).' &.71./0%,1 / /" / / 0 #77/)/ 0

 %,1 / //,1# / 0.1 

 % /%+/ 5(+1"%/ 2,0/ %6+/%++%</401+/0 !"""" &+#670%* / 0/7/.+"  / /,1+ 334 //%4 %+4 4$ 0/ %4  :+#/4 +0660 /$ ,: /%4 0++01$ ,4 4 %<//++/ ,: +0 +0660#0,0/+ 0 +4# 0 $ +0660 :+## 0+%+4 4#/:0+ //0/"  >D./ .4/0/ 4 :+#/4+060/"   . /+ # 0 71  .:4    %# 0+0$ 0/ +0660#0,0/+ 0 +4# 0+ +0660 :+##,0 + /+ /0 /:0+ 0 //0 %+4 $ :40 / +0660#0,0/+ 0,#40 /,,,600/4"   /00<//  0/% //4 .+40$/:0,4/0. / 0#77# 0#/%40+ 0+ ,,1.,440  5')'!"    +,- ,. /,