Legislator Case Law & Legislation
4-20-2368/14 AI generated

4-20-2368/14 · Tartu Maakohus Viljandi kohtumaja

Case Number 4-20-2368/14
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

� 4,r6� 5/5,668,,� 4567,85�.5,8.� 5/5,668/.,5� OJKA ZKFBnI]P�5,r56�5/5,668/.,5�4.�€685,r� ‚ƒ$:

Legislator headnote

AI generated

4-20-2368/14 · Tartu Maakohus Viljandi kohtumaja: � 4,r6� 5/5,668,,� 4567,85�.5,8.� 5/5,668/.,5� OJKA ZKFBnI]P�5,r56�5/5,668/.,5�4.�€685,r� ‚ƒ$:

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

���� 

��

��� !"#$!%$&'(

)*+�,-./0.�1)23�4567,85�/7�9 '$%$:";

<=1)=1>*?@ABCDEFGHIJKLKAMLNLEIFKLKANOA1?<)P2?P)))1><��QR

STUVU

W 'RXR

YYZA [\FN]A ^OL_LBEFFOJA `abcdb`cea� � f.8g�h./.�5/5.�[iAjA`ceAIkAe�lHOkJAO]D]EO]DGJk]A

m)�EO]DGJnDJBFEoAKbCA`ccALFOCEoA[iAjA`pqAIkAe�lHOkJA

-5r�21m�EO]DGJnDJBFEoAKbCAm))�.����1*+)*+1)1)�MHHOFKAE]KFM]E]AO]D]EO]DGJA

2sm�EO]DGJnDJBFEA.,8/5.�.5r�2s�^HLG]P�/5�KnntJM\JKELEFAN\FKCILBFIA]KLNt]EFtAnItB]KFIJBFAEuuk]A2s�,85��vSTSwx

XR

ySTSwxS

SS

GHHOELC]Kl]KAELDEFtACEKFKLAEHJEMJNL�MHHO]EFtAnItB]KFIJBFAEuuAELkLM]E]AlHEMJNL�

wTVz

{5-�|5,�'( # :!#& 

}HEIJNA[FMJ�~R wxS

SVwRXR

� 4,r6� 5/5,668,,� 4567,85�.5,8.� 5/5,668/.,5� OJKA ZKFBnI]P�5,r56�5/5,668/.,5�4.�€685,r� ‚ƒ$:

„ SU†

‡RR SySw�ˆ558‰�>32)2)s*)2*Š�.6‰�‹‹‹‹‹‹‹�‹=‹�‹‹‹‹‹‹‹‹�‹‹‹‹�‹‹‹‹‹‹‹‹‹‹‹�Œ��Ž‡Q~‡‘’

�“

VTUUS

zR VwSRUwVz

” R ‡•

–—˜ƒ!—%$

W '": ƒ$‚ #&

”™~v‡•

–šUSw

›œž

z



"$Ÿ

œ ¡¢ $& VyVTRRx

xURySwTVz

wR wx

„ SU†

‡RR SySwR

&$#  # "#ƒ

£¤¤$"#&$(ƒ‚$"RwR

› ¡¥VzSTURUR

„ SU†

‡RR SySwRxS

~R w

vRRz

w

›¦ ¦ ›› R

"!$"$ ‚

ƒ‚&$ƒ#& ¤¤ # "# ( $!$

ž ¡!"$ $xUzRxVz

¤¤

š

œž

”z xywSVw•

wTUV

wxS§

„ SU†

‡RR SySwRx

 VwRUR

(&%''&ƒ$ƒ$ &'ƒW$"%¨ "# ©

�



 





 !!"#!#!$"

%#"#%%



&'( &

')





*& 

')+ 





,-./012230456758956-:6;-./015:5/904567--9/5964810/<615:5/904=29<4596<4<;09>6;0<6;-./06

1223045?86-:67<<38/0@6:5:@56=A<6;8</4/8=86<4<;06A<?04<6=A<6458@049<;;56.0=56A<?04654</8@86

BCDEFGHIJKLIICKLMEFNOBCDEFPCCKLMEFQHNRCISHKLMEFTCRCKCFSF122304;85U046VWXIO

725=86Y--;40961<96<4<;648<6=8<@904/8/8=86;-./012230454/6/58@86=A<67<@<6/58@8648818Z6



[\][^_`abcde]b_a`\][c^fgh

ijklmnhon



d[#$!"



p83/06q88;-./06rsZtsZrtrt61223045?86845:@8/<uDOSvwCCDOTOExCNO;-./0=29<45615:5/95Y86

yyz6{A0:86735|5;/003<6r}Z6Y00:<6rt~}Z8Z6-/4045?861A<4/5/0@6/84018/8638.8/38.=6~€6

/38.=<.<;0/68354/<?86~6725=86:<:?6845:@8@868354/69@;8409<;06/‚‚?86~6/0:@<ZƒNSKCxFNHKF

/‚‚6/5?51<456/2./8Y8;4612238/<„KFFSCNCEOx;-./012230456YA04/01<454/Z,-./01223046

YA04/046~ ZtZrtrtZ



BCDEFQCIJNCKDHTHICCNMLLNSFxLxCKLIICQHNRCISHOxHISFxOKDHTHICCNMLLNSFxCTOEIHKOxHECx

V�†V‡†�‡�‡BCDEFPCCKLMEFNOODCK-3389<4565//5;8:@5Z6ˆ35@‰6Š883515/4895612238/0@6

9@;8409<;06/‚‚6~6/0:@<64--3</81<456/2./8Y8;46-9<6~ Z~tZrtrtZ6Š5<40?86~rZ~tZrtrt6-:6<4<;6

4--3</8:0@6 6/0:@<69@;8409<;;06/‚‚@Z6



‹38;-3389<454/65//5;8:@54/6:2./0=89/6/-<10465xTCKLMEFTHIOuDOSvwCCDOTOExCJCVV†‡Œ†�‡�‡

THNHxHKFNOEFEŽFxECEHKDHTHICCNMLLNSFxCNFxOA<?04<RCKLMFxEFxH†xHKxFFICEH/‚‚956<9Y8:@<6

‘HIICŽCNHExFxxO’ODHLLSHNV“†‡Œ†�‡�‡”�V†‡Œ†�‡�‡†ƒ9@;8409<;06/‚‚RFMOISCRCEOCŽHECx

V“†‡Œ†�‡�‡OEHxHK8Y8;8=8Y23?459//‚‚/0:@5xLLDHECTCOHHNTFIFSIHIJEONO•LIHEOONOHLNO

=A<189<;HxHKFJC.5:@04/6xCCSC†–RCKCŽCDHKKFTHxOKLMECCISHxuDOSvwCCDOTOEx

�„†‡“†�‡�‡xONOEFxO—˜,A<;<IOHSCxRF’LNIFS=A<189<;/2</8>KFIC-9<:6/‚‚9™Z�„†‡“†�‡�‡

KLLxECxKDHTHICCNMLLNSFxCTOEIHKFFO9@;8409<;0/‚‚CRCKCŽCTHNNOKLMCxONEuDOSv

wCCDOTOEx’HSH9@;8409<;;0/‚‚@xLLDHECTCTHIOTCCRCŽCMOTHKFx„‡†‡“†�‡�‡š‡�†V‡†�‡�‡†

xHKOHHNTFIFS„‡†‡“†�‡�‡›RCY23?:5=8/596725=8@59œ9@;8409<;;0/‚‚@xLLDHECTCOJC

EOCŽHECIFS

THEEOHNTFTHxOxE

OONIOŽCNE

9@;8409<;06

/‚‚

RFMOISCRCE

RC

KDHTHICCNMLLNSFxCTOEIHKKF†‡W†V‡†�‡�‡=A//<4uDOSvwCCDOTOEx.5:@04/9@;8409<;0/‚‚6

RFMOISCRCJCIHIJ’CNFxŽHHTCxE=A<18904/šRFMOISCRC:A04/04>OEHxHK4--3</8U6NSKCxFNHKF

/‚‚EFIIHS‡Œ†V‡†�‡�‡‡“†V‡†�‡�‡RCV�†V‡†�‡�‡†‡Œ†V‡†�‡�‡xLLDHECxHxHKEFISH

9@;8409<;;F/‚‚@>‡“†V‡†�‡�‡RCV�†V‡†�‡�‡HxHK/‚‚95OHHNTFIFS†žOEKONOHLNOHxHKEONO•LIH

/5596;2//5488@8=Z



,3<1<:889.--9@04815/:<;6-:6/5<:0@65//578:5;067‚‚38/86ˆ35@‰6Š883515/486;83<4/046/2</1<4595†

p8995612238/0@6~6/0:@<69@;8409<;;06/‚‚@>61<99OxEHxHKLIV�†V‡†�‡�‡xOHxFJCxLLDHECIFS

;4:546 6/0:@<6Ÿ4--3</818/86~ 6/0:@<œZ6ˆ35@‰6Š883515/46-:6;-3@0=89/69@;8409<;06/‚‚6

xLLDHECTHxO753<--@<96-9:0@6/595|-:<6/5596;3<1<:889.--9@04815/:<;0956;2//548818/06:<:?6

<4<;0956-:68:/0@6=A<189046/‚‚/0:@<@564--3</CTHxOKx;0<@6<4<;69@;8409<;06/‚‚6/0:@564<<4;<6

/2<54618.0464--3</8:0@65<6-95Z



¡LMEFHxEFIJ‡W†VV†�‡�‡†

¡DHTHICCNMLLNSFxCTOEIHKCŽCNSCxKLMEFHxEFIJHNOEY22U6538;-3389<4565//5;8:@56Y003@5Z6¢xHKF

7A.Y5:@045@>65/6/8967-956=A<189<;6/‚‚672384/6/5.86/‚‚/0:@5>67-95672@5=8@†–RCKCŽCxHS

�



 





 

 

 



  

   



   





   



 !  "#$$%&"%$'#()'$%%&"%$'#()'$

 

+

 ,-!  

./

  



 

 

      01%$







     !



3322456789:;6<=>?8@=?2



A+BCD.EF!.    !









  

   



A+BCD.E�'GF  

 

 

   

!



  







 



 

  

   

&HI)1

 !  

   



 





J&K$')0%(KL&0%'$K*J&H$)M&&(KL$)NOPONPNP

 !QH%RST&&H%"%$0&'%

 

 .U   0%#0)G&FNFPNPNP$%G%"&$&F�

   V   

 .,.EDEDE



 CWX!W    

  ! 

  

    

   



*#($%R&

   

 

  

  







 CUY D  !

!





 ! 

 /   !

  

   

 

!  

Z  

 

!  

 





   



 



  

 

! !Z



   

 

 



       

   !





  

!  

  

 ! 0%R1'%#R#01%$(H#"#*&&'LKK'R)0&"%$*#()%H&(KHH&'#*%%$$%(&%&H%0$#

 

 

 H&L)'R&"#0%'%



[KL)0'%#&\1%$QH%RST&&H%"%$0&'%

  

 



%&$'#(*#*G

   \







!

  F�$)*R#0KKH#$&"#0%(0



]HI%0$&R%0&0^&K')1%$QH%RST&&H%"%$0K*&I&'R&*)R"K$#I&$0#KK*#

 

    

_#(%*R&R&J&H$)M&&(KL$)

NOPODEDE

 !QH%RST&&H%"%$0&'%

 !

  ./ 

!

 



 

$



`&''(#H^&0$&$)RR#G#$&&'0%'$a



]#I&Hb#*$





[KL$)*#(